3 ms·
I think it’s precisely that; with electric, there’s no special product to sell you. With hydrogen, or ethanol, the old oil and gas companies can more easily pi
by teddyh 6y ago
I think it’s precisely that; with electric, there’s no special product to sell you. With hydrogen, or ethanol, the old oil and gas companies can more easily pivot into simply selling another chemical product. With electric cars, the oil and gas companies are like cable TV in the age of the internet; their days are numbered, and they fear it like nothing else.
(Also, governments have nothing to levy special taxes on if cars run on your wall plug.)
Of course, this is all conspiracy theories and speculation. I have nothing to back this up.
- mustafa_pasi 6y agoAsian countries like Japan, Korea and China are the ones who are still pushing hydrogen tech. None of these are big oil producing nations so the conspiracy theory does not make sense.
- whatever1 6y agoPlus the folks here probably forget what poverty looks like. In areas with no infrastructure the only way of getting energy is to literally carry it home for your stove or motorcycle. Gas is ideal for these cases. Hydrogen cylinders maybe? Batteries are definitely a no go to transport energy.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThose cars have 10,000 PSI tanks, and Hydrogen is notorious for leaking through everything. It's not an option for places with no infrastructure. Trickle charging a battery with a small solar panel is what no-infrastructure places are moving towards for charging phones and other electronics. That's not enough energy for cooking or transportation, yet, but I can see it moving towards that. Another option is synthetic fuel. Currently horribly expensive because it is energy intensive and still experimental, it may become viable if solar energy prices continue to drop. It's much less efficient than an EV, but it works with existing gas/diesel/kerosene infrastructure.
- whatever1 6y agoYou don’t have to have 10,000psi tanks. A regular 3,000psi industrial gas cylinder would do the job and it would store energy equivalent of around 8gallons of gasoline. The gas cylinder would weigh ~ 100 pounds. So totally feasible. Now, do we have cheap appliances that consume hydrogen and produce work/heat ? Not yet.
- numpad0 6y agoThere is supposedly a huge gas deposit under the sea between those three countries so it’s supposedly just a matter of negotiating and setting up a fair mining operations and start extracting it to theoretically become big oils overnight. That isn’t how things work but that’s the logic behind pushing Hydrogen.
- bkor 6y ago> None of these are big oil producing nations so the conspiracy theory does not make sense. Big companies such as Shell are pushing Hydrogen via something called the "EU green deal". This while Shell (and similar) do not expect hydrogen to be produced via green methods for 15+ years. They push the EU to "subsidize" hydrogen (and other things), to basically get loads of money from people in an indirect way. This was e.g. reported via the journalists at ftm.nl. They're probably unknown to most people here, but loads of their findings resulted in loads of issues for the government (scandals, fraud, etc).
- nojito 6y ago100% electric cars isn’t feasible for countries like Japan https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/toyotas-chief-says-electric-vehicles-are-overhyped-11608196665 https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/toyotas-chief-says-electric...
- bkor 6y ago> 100% electric cars isn’t feasible for countries like Japan Japan heavily subsidises research into Hydrogen. This over anything else, e.g. electric. Quoting a Japanese car manufacturer is therefore a bit biased. Japan has two different energy grids btw, one runs at 50 Hz, the other at 60 Hz. Japan made some really strange decisions regarding their electric grid. That makes Japan unique, it isn't common to have such problems. For most countries the additional electric requirements aren't that significant. Though there will need to be some behavioural change (possibly helped by some technology). E.g. don't charge everything immediately at once, but align the supply and demand. Meaning, don't charge everything at once, charge more when there's an over supply (e.g. windy day/hour).
- fomine3 6y agoEven if there is single power grid in Japan, it's still really small grid compared to America/Europe/China. It's hard to compete with other countries' manufacturing industry with relatively stable green energy if carbon tax become thing. Also nuclear plant is dead end since 2011. That's why they developing hydrogen to store energy. Maybe Korea is in similar situation? But I still doubt is hydrogen for cars (not trucks) practical. Maybe this is just a demo rather than serious competitor to EV.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoI disagree with what he says about co2 and the old “you have to make electricity with something” argument. It wasn’t until I bought a Tesla and did the math myself that I realized how inefficient gas cars are compared to an electricity generating power plant. My equivalent mpg with my electricity rate is something on the order of 150-180 mpg. For trips where we can charge at home (most of our miles) it is a 1/3 of the cost of our Prius to drive. http://chooseev.com/savings-calculator/ http://chooseev.com/savings-calculator/