3 ms·
I think the Fear is that if the loophole is closed, the businesses will move elsewhere, taking an X amount of jobs with them - from which the government earns s
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
I think the Fear is that if the loophole is closed, the businesses will move elsewhere, taking an X amount of jobs with them - from which the government earns some income taxes. They take the crumbs instead of nothing, because there's no chance they get the cake.
It may take EU wide legislation to fix, but even that is no guarantee because companies may just opt to not operate in the EU.
- rambambram 6y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but one of the things I vividly remember from law school is that the European Union leaves taxation to the member states.
- FriedrichN 6y ago> taking an X amount of jobs with them All three? These shell companies are often just a post address, sometimes an empty office with a plant (and someone to water the plant every week). The excuse is always that if we won't do it, someone else will and that we need international legislation. While that is true, someone needs to kick it off. And I don't want the crumbs, they can stick those crumbs where the sun don't shine.
- candiodari 6y agoActually Ireland demands that some percentage of workforce plus some percentage of revenue is in Ireland. So no these are sometimes very large offices, and a bunch of actual business is also routed through these offices. Unless you mean in the Netherlands, yes, there you can have a post office/lawyer office, something along those lines.
- markvdb 6y agoIreland at least until recently didn't even require Irish companies to be administered from Ireland. It was also super laissez-fair on arm's length principles for valuing services provided between connected entities. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Concept_and_origin_(1991) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement#Conce...
- varispeed 6y agoThis is a fallacy. Sure government gets income tax, but that is nowhere near the billions that are siphoned out of the economy. The income tax come from workers, who then have less money to spend in the local economy and that causes further negative effects. > that is no guarantee because companies may just opt to not operate in the EU. Great. Tax dodging companies should be banned and because of that local competition will have a chance to grow. If they banned Uber from operating EU wide, I am sure smaller local companies would have picked up the market and that would benefit economy much more.