3 ms·
Hasn’t the exact same amount of time elapsed without finding any evidence of a lab leak?
by tshaddox 6y ago
Hasn’t the exact same amount of time elapsed without finding any evidence of a lab leak?
- gnicholas 6y agoNature leaves a trail, so if you don’t find a trail then it becomes increasingly implausible that COVID resulted from a natural process. There are currently several intermediate steps that have not been uncovered anywhere, and which would have to have happened in order for this to be a natural process.
- tshaddox 6y agoThis just sounds like the “lack of evidence is evidence of a conspiracy” epistemology so often resorted to by conspiracy theorists. The problem with the epistemology is that it applies equally well to all conceivable conspiracies.
- gnicholas 6y agoThis may be true in general, but in this case we're trying to figure out if something is man-made or occurred naturally. No one is saying it couldn't have happened naturally, but natural evolution happens differently (and more slowly and messily) than human creation. In prior cases (SARS and MERS), plenty of evidence of natural evolution was found very quickly. Here it has been conspicuously absent. What conclusion would you draw from that?
- Izkata 6y ago> but in this case we're trying to figure out if something is man-made or occurred naturally. False dichotomy. The main lab-leak theory is that a natural virus being studied escaped from a lab, not a man-made one.
- tomjen3 6y agoYou only need a handful of people working on this to have knowledge of it. The PRC is really good at locking up people to keep them quiet.
- Dah00n 6y agoI'm not sure I follow the logic. If China is so good at keeping people quiet, how do you know? Sounds to me that for us to know they have to be less than good at it?
- Dah00n 6y agoI'm sorry but I really cannot see how everyone knowing (since we on HN knows it must be widespread) is China being good at keeping people quiet. Instead of downvoting how about explaining the logic?
- ChemSpider 6y agoNope - no investigation for _that_ theory allowed by Beijing.