5 ms·
> [encourage night-shift workers to] take other modes of transportation, including public transit or ride-share services It's not obvious to me that ride-share
by sokoloff 6y ago
> [encourage night-shift workers to] take other modes of transportation, including public transit or ride-share services
It's not obvious to me that ride-share services would be materially safer here. It seems like many of the same concerns for night-shift workers in other jobs would also apply to ride-share drivers, added to the propensity for the flexibility of those jobs to increase the number of people driving ride-shares in addition to other full-time employment.
- watwut 6y agoChances are, your ride share is in the middle of shift. Not in the end of shift when driver is most tired. Assuming ride share means Uber and such. AFAIK, drivers treat it as job.
- bootlooped 6y agoWhen I was working a third shift factory job, there was no public transportation that was remotely close to covering my commute, and taking Uber to and from work would have taken a huge bite out of my paycheck. These remedies just aren't realistic for a large number of third shift workers.
- Ericson2314 6y agoPublic transit is the only option. I would love to see a general audit of night shift work and ongoing plans to keep it at an absolute minimum, but that's probably too utopian a project to see in this country any time soon :/.
- sokoloff 6y agoMany night shift jobs already pay a shift differential. Many employees seek out those shifts. Why would we, as a society, want to prevent these seemingly mutually beneficial arrangements? Don’t like shift work? Don’t take a job that requires it, but don’t ban others who do prefer it from taking it because you don’t like it.
- renewiltord 6y agoFor the same reason we, as a society, place wage floors, etc. The crime committed when two people form a lopsided employment relationship isn’t really against either of them (because clearly each is deriving sufficient utility); it’s against us. We don’t want to be employed in this manner so we prevent the existence of these things.
- sokoloff 6y agoWho is we? Some people prefer to work at different times. Maybe they like having sunlight in their free time instead of their work time.
- renewiltord 6y ago“We” is a generalized aggregate of society weighted by political power. Some people also prefer to work for less than minimum wage because they are on the wrong side of an information asymmetry. And yet they cannot. Because they have not sinned against themselves or their employer but against us.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI agree. Some workschedules are quite toxic, and (perhaps biased as someone sensitive to circadian rhythm disturbances) would prefer not to see this normalized as it is today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shift_work#/media/File:Child_Labor_in_United_States_1908,_12_hour_night_shifts.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shift_work#/media/File:Child_L... I don't want that to come back either. > Maybe they like having sunlight in their free time instead of their work time. With a real night shift (3rd shift) your body would strongly want to sleep through all the good sunlight anyways. And if you do stay up for it, well good luck enjoying any part of the day. Anyways to some it all up, maybe PP should check out https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674238091 https://www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674238091
- 6y ago
- treeman79 6y agoMy area only just restored bus service a week ago. Many nearby places closed in part because workers had no way to arrive without a bus.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Public transit is the only option. You don't seem to realize that jobs are not always in dense areas.
- burnished 6y agoI know that the conversation wasn't in depth, but I'd like to point out that 'public transit' also includes shuttles, it doesn't just mean 'city bus with schedule determined by best fit for public use'. Depending on circumstance a couple shuttles to a couple 'park and rides' could smooth out some issues. Maybe some one smarter than me could devise an elegant way to handle the last mile.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI meant good option: a normative not descriptive statement. So either we build more public transit, or relocate night shifts away from areas without it. If the job is at a giant factory of some sort outside the city, I would like to see some sort of shuttle between the factory and a transit station. I am not sure how safe park-and-rides are during that last mile, but housing for commuters ought to be in areas dense enough to not require cars, even if the commuters are doing some sort of reverse commute.
- Tiktaalik 6y agoNot building public transit is a political choice, not some natural way of things
- ekianjo 6y agobuilding and maintaining a reliable public transit takes a lot of resources and planning, things that politicians are notoriously bad at managing. In France there's a lot of public transit but it is plagued by strikes all the time making it completely unreliable to use it for work.
- actually_a_dog 6y agoNot entirely: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp...
- cortesoft 6y agoMany cities don't run public transportation at night. Even the ones that do run reduced routes.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Public transit is the only option. Often not an option, as grave/swing shift often has the end that isn’t in common with day shift facing reduced frequency or no service on public transit lines.
- vkou 6y agoI'm not sure how many people actually know night-shift workers, but a friend of mine is one. He is no position to afford to take a taxi to get to work, regular public transit does not run at the hours he commutes, and even if he worked a 9-5, there is no public transit that will get him from the town he lives into the town he works in. And no, he can't remotely afford moving closer to work. Being poor is very expensive.
- kwdc 6y agoCheap taxis are something I've never experienced. I'd even say taxis are hideously expensive especially for actual trips over significant distance and/or on a regular basis. The better way to deal with shift work is to be ultra mindful of diet and exercise since night work messes with metabolism and hormones in general. Or stop doing night shift but thats a long term solution and usually you're doing that shift work for actual economic reasons.
- eru 6y agoIn many places, Uber was significantly cheaper than what local taxes used to charge. So on the margin, many more people could afford the former for more trips compared to the latter. That's independent of still being expensive in an absolute sense.
- vkou 6y agoIt used to be cheaper - when VCs were pouring billions into capturing market share. Now, prices are almost identical in most regions. And, as you alluded, when you're working a crappy night-shift job, you can't afford either one.
- midasuni 6y agoI used to work regular night shifts when I was in my 20s - 2300-1100. public transport was available for those times, but occasionally I’d drive as it tended to be faster - especially on the way in. One morning I was driving back home and it was really sunny, no AC in the car, and the traffic ground to a halt on the m25. I closed my eyes and woke when the car behind beeped me for not moving forward. Fortunatly it was stoped traffic rather than sluggish traffic. It was the day shifts that needed a taxi - 1130-2330 for example was too late to get the last train. Work provided a taxi at those times (and on Christmas Day / Boxing Day)