7 ms·
The statement "Tesla market value is the same as everybody else put together" means either Tesla is expensive or everybody else is cheap or the statement is ina
by bryanlarsen 6y ago
The statement "Tesla market value is the same as everybody else put together" means either Tesla is expensive or everybody else is cheap or the statement is inaccurate. It's a little bit of all three.
All other car companies are primarily debt financed rather than equity financed. Ford's market cap is $45B, but because it has $120B in debt which means it is worth $120B to it's bondholders and $45B to stockholders for a total enterprise value of $160B.
So Tesla isn't worth as much as all of the companies put together, it's worth about as much as 2 or 3 of the big ones. Which is still a lot.
But all the other car companies are facing an existential threat. Climate change and the EV transition are going to be tough. That has to be depressing their valuations some.
Tesla also has a really good profit margin. If they can keep that up, it goes a long way to justifying their prices. Pretty big if, that one -- the general assumption is that it will go down as they go downmarket to chase volume. Vertical integration might let them keep it up, though. Think of it like Apple -- 20% market share but >80% of the profit.
What I'm saying is that if Toyota or Volkswagen had no debt, a Tesla level profit margin and no overhanging challenge like the transition to EV, they'd have a market cap similar to Tesla's.
That still doesn't justify Tesla's market cap, but it makes it seem less insane.
- treis 6y ago>Ford's market cap is $45B, but because it has $120B in debt which means it is worth $120B to it's bondholders and $45B to stockholders for a total enterprise value of $160B. I believe that's a bit misleading because it includes Ford's lending arm. They borrow money and lend it out at higher rates. So lots of Ford debt is lent back out to consumers at profit.
- cl0ckt0wer 6y agoI thought money that was owed to you was counted as an asset, not a debt?
- thaumasiotes 6y agoIf I borrow $300,000 at 2% interest and lend it to you at 5% interest, I have an asset based on my loan to you and a liability based on my debt to whoever loaned me the same amount. They don't net out -- if you default, my asset will disappear without taking the liability with it. But it might be strange to say that I'm worth $300,000 based on my debt, when the whole concept of that debt is that it's theoretically guaranteed by, and related to, that asset. This combined situation does not suggest that I'm personally worth $300,000; I'm earning the difference in interest, and my debt to my creditor is based mostly off of your net worth, not my net worth.
- civilian 6y agoWouldn't Ford then have assets, to cancel out of the debt? I imagine that "120B in debt" means net debt, but I'm not sure. [follow-up] yes, that's $120B net debt. They have a total $160B of debt, and ~$23B of that is from the automotive side of the business, not the financing side. https://stockdividendscreener.com/auto-manufacturers/ford-total-debt-and-leverage-ratio-analysis/ https://stockdividendscreener.com/auto-manufacturers/ford-to...
- treis 6y agoThey do, but the GP was talking about the enterprise value. Kind of like taking the value of your home and subtracting the mortgage to get your equity. They're doing the reverse and adding equity + Deb to get the total value of the enterprise. That works if the debt is for things like building factories or designing cars. But when's it's borrowed and then lent straight out it doesn't make sense.
- hahaxdxd123 6y agoDebt is a good thing for Ford! The majority of their debt comes from financing the sales of their cars to fleets, dealers, or consumers. This earned them 1.7B last year. Tesla's real advantage imo comes down to not having dealers eat into their margins. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Motor_Credit_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Motor_Credit_Company
- Kranar 6y agoYes, debt is a good thing for Ford which is why its market cap alone is not a good indicator of its value in this case. OPs entire point is that when you factor in the EV instead of the MC, Tesla still comes out looking good but within reason.
- ska 6y ago> out looking good but within reason. The actual term was "less insane" which isn't really the same thing.
- MrPowers 6y agoI agree with the sentiment that comparing Tesla's market cap with traditional car companies is inaccurate. For certain companies, market capitalization is a good proxy for enterprise value, but as this poster is mentioning, that's not always the case for companies with debt. enterprise_value = market_cap + debt - cash Looking at the market caps of long-standing US car manufacturers is doubly problematic cause they have significant pension obligations. They're producing cars to build shareholder value and pay for retirements. Comparing market capitalizations of companies that have completely different debt / pension obligations is misleading.
- mxschumacher 6y agoAt the same time we have to consider that debt is both exceptionally cheap and advantageous in an inflationary environment. Having to serve debt at 2% is much, much easier than doing so at 7%+
- anyfoo 6y ago> Climate change and the EV transition are going to be tough. That has to be depressing their valuations some. Does it have to be? I can imagine that going from 100 years[1] of internal combustion engines to an entirely different type of drive train is going to be jarring, to say the least. But neither are EV completely new at this point, nor is a car just its drive train. Surely other comparable transitions have been successful? Any older computer corporation has more or less reinvented itself a few times. More topically, airplane manufactures must have gone from piston engines to vastly different jet engines at some point[2]. [1] BMW for example exists since 1916. [2] Apparently Boeing was originally founded in 1916, too.
- kickopotomus 6y ago> But neither are EV completely new at this point, nor is a car just its drive train. Exactly this. The EV drivetrain is also simpler than an ICE because a transmission is not needed[1]. I think the hardest part about vehicle manufacturing, which is the issue Tesla seems to run into repeatedly, is dependable mass production. The major auto conglomerates have a lot of experience with cranking out massive volumes of quality vehicles. I don't think that re-tooling their production lines is going to be a problem. The primary issue with switching to EVs, which Tesla should capitalize on, will continue to be energy storage. Sourcing large quantities of batteries is tricky. Tesla had the right idea to just vertically integrate cell production and likely has a lot to gain by being the premier battery producer for the industry. As an aside, hopefully the switch to EVs will help fund research for the next breakthrough in battery tech. [1]: Application-dependent but most 2-axle consumer electric vehicles should not need a transmission
- mxschumacher 6y agoIn light of the Panasonic partnership with its large involvement in the gigafactory, I don't understand why Tesla is supposed to be considered vertically integrated in batteries. Nothing stops Panasonic from collaborating with a car maker that churns out 10m+ cars per year
- reducesuffering 6y ago
- victor106 6y ago> Tesla also has a really good profit margin. Their net profit margin is barely 2%.[1] I would not call it good by any stretch. By contrast Apple has a 25% net margin[2]. That is what I call good. [1] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/profit-... [2] https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AAPL/apple/profit-margins https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/AAPL/apple/profit-...
- Seanambers 6y agoNo, that is extraordinary. Are you really comparing a software and IT company with a car manufacturer?
- touisteur 6y agoApple isn't a hardware company anymore?
- belval 6y agoIf you look at their where their 25% profit margins come from then no, they aren't a hardware company. If Apple tried to make a car tomorrow they would not have 25% margins on it. From a market valuation standpoint, this is also why Apple valuation is 44 times higher than Ford's.
- OneLessThing 6y agoI looked into it[1], their net profit margins were 32% last quarter. 36% gross margins on hardware products (iPhone, Mac, etc) and 70% gross margins on services (AppleCare, Cloud Services, etc.). However services only comprise 19% of their sales, the other 81% of their sales are from hardware products (mostly iPhones). Their service sales seem to all stem from them making the hardware. For example the AppStore walled garden is protected by the hardware, AppleCare services their hardware, and Cloud services are integrated into their devices, etc. It may be possible in the future for apple to get high margin "service" sales from an Apple Car App Store, buying games and movies for your self driving car, for example. Regardless I'd definitely consider Apple a hardware company. [1] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY21_Q2_Consolidated_Financial_Statements.pdf https://www.apple.com/newsroom/pdfs/FY21_Q2_Consolidated_Fin...
- nunez 6y agoThere are other things to consider too: - Tesla is achieving vertical integration to a degree no other mainstream auto OEM has achieved. The only other example of vertical integration to the extreme that I can think of is Koeneigsegg, and they are _very_ niche. This only helps Tesla make cheaper cars faster while collecting more margin per car. - Tesla's FSD marketing is highly contentious, but they are the only auto manufacturer that is building (designing) their own SoCs explicitly for this. I wouldn't be surprised if they are outspending other auto OEMs on autonomous driving R&D by several degrees of magnitude. - Tesla still has a major, major lead in EV battery tech which will only be cemented if they can get 4680 into revenue production. They also own the largest and (arguably) most reliable charging network in the world, which is growing at a faster rate than Electrify America, the second biggest competitor. I think that Tesla is overpriced long term in a world where 91% of American cars are EVs and 48% of them are self-driving, but I think they are correctly priced for _right now_
- TechBro8615 6y ago> Tesla is achieving vertical integration to a degree no other mainstream auto OEM has achieved This is crucial. It’s also why Tesla vs automakers reminds me of Apple iPhone vs existing cell phones. Sure making an electric car is “not that hard,” but because the carmakers didn’t take Tesla seriously for 10+ years, they now have a lot of catching up to do.
- adflux 6y ago... isn't iPhone production outsourced? That's the opposite of vertical integration
- nunez 6y agoOutsourced using in-house designs, and, in Tesla's case, in-house assembly lines and factories. Even the SPEAKERS inside of the Model 3 and Y are designed by Tesla (and manufactured by a vendor). That's the big difference. It's also the reason why legacy manufacturers will struggle to effectively respond to Tesla. It takes a LOT of money and egos to upend generations of culture (and accept hundreds of millions in losses in the process)
- underwater 6y agoiPhones are not a commodity product. At the moment Teslas are. How will Tesla convince consumers that their car, with a high profit margin, is worth it over a mature EV vehicle from Ford, BMW, etc.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAs of right now, the most mature EVs are Teslas. They've established themselves as the gold standard of EVs. If anything, their main hurdle is still convincing consumers to buy EVs instead of ICE cars.
- rsj_hn 6y agoI would say there are three main hurdles: * Convincing the public to spend 50-70K on a car * Convincing the public to buy an EV * Convincing the public that Tesla can be trusted for long term repair costs/reliability Right now Tesla is squarely in the luxury vehicle market, competing against Lexus/BMW/Mercedes, rather than against Mazda/Honda/Kia, and it's a new automaker, so we don't have good long term reliability or serviceability data, nor do we have good info on how long the batteries will last, or what costs someone buying a 10 year old model Y will face. These questions will resolve themselves with time, but whether they will all resolve in Tesla's favor is another matter.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoFair enough. Especially the third one. Especially outside US. I've been joking to my wife for years now that we should get a Tesla eventually. Over that time, I've seen her going from "what's up with these EVs anyway?", through "that's a really expensive car", to "sure, but if anything breaks, IIRC the closest shop that can repair it is in Norway".
- rsj_hn 6y agoYeah, I think Tesla is just shooting themselves in the foot here. They should be sponsoring a healthy third party aftermarket, they should be adding easy to use ODB ports, they should be publishing service bulletins. And if indeed Munro and other EV enthusiasts are right that maintenance costs will be 90% lower, Tesla should be offering 20 year warranties on their car to give potential buyers, especially used car buyers, ease of mind when purchasing their cars. It's a new tech, there are lots of question marks about long term reliability, so if Tesla is so confident that these are non-issues, they should step in and insure car buyers from these risks. If indeed these cars are incredibly cheap to maintain, it wont cost Tesla much and will open a floodgate of new buyers.
- samatman 6y agoIf Tesla carves out an Apple-sized share of a market where all new passenger autos are EVs, its valuation is reasonable. That's not an impossible outcome. I have no bets in this market, I'm strictly wait-and-see. It's worth pointing out that Apple's valuation before it carved out that "Apple-sized share" was much, much lower.
- mxschumacher 6y agoI'm having deep trouble trying to appreciate this argument, apple has deep network effects it has build an ecosystem, a platform. If I want to use iOS I have to buy Apple hardware, if I want to offer a mobile app I have to go through the app store. Nowhere does Tesla exhibit similiar properties, instead it competes in the hyper-competitive, high capex and low margin car business. Trying to beat Toyota at scale manufacturing is a very tall order