3 ms·
I would wager the ideal goal of the vast majority of people would be increasing income due to wanting to consume more and more, for various reasons, but at its
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
I would wager the ideal goal of the vast majority of people would be increasing income due to wanting to consume more and more, for various reasons, but at its most basic, for the reason of attracting mates.
- wittycardio 6y agoThis is a complete straw man with no scientific basis at all. Desire for constantly increasing consumption could just easily be an artifact of culture. There's no reason to believe it's biological
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe biological part is seeking out a desirable mate (per my amateur understanding of biology - it could be completely wrong). Desirable for many animals includes ability to procure resources (and defend them). Being able to consume displays this (and not necessarily plastic things). Consuming leisure time and activities are a signal that you have the power to do more of what you want to do or obtain it. But I do not claim this is a scientific conclusion, I simply landed on this model as it seemed to match up with my reality.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSorry, that's bullshit. Most sexual behaviors are culturally conditioned and empirically money doesnt make men or women linearly and indefinitely more attracted. What is attractive is social status - in capitalism this is linked mostly to wealth but that's not a given at all. Another thing that's attractive is stability, but that doesn't have anything to do with consumption, in today's world it means having stable access to housing, ideally owning it, mainly.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>means having stable access to housing, ideally owning it, mainly Having access to shelter in a desirable place is currently one of the best signals about one's ability to procure resources and I would categorize it as consumption. You can have stable access to housing where few people want to live, but it will not help you in attracting from a larger pool of mates (if that is your goal).
- sudosysgen 6y agoNo, it simply isn't. The valuable part of housing is land and land cannot be consumed by housing. Its not a signal of the ability to procure resources, it's that housing is the single most major cost and homelessness is the most major financial risk. What's attractive about it isn't that you can consume endless amounts of plastic and steel by proxy, it is that you eliminate risk.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>Its not a signal of the ability to procure resources, it's that housing is the single most major cost and homelessness is the most major financial risk. In my opinion, that one can afford the single most major cost and avoid the most major financial risk is a possible signal of the ability to procure (or defend) resources. >What's attractive about it isn't that you can consume endless amounts of plastic and steel by proxy, it is that you eliminate risk. I agree. But I choose to define the word "consume" in this context to refer to being able to walk away with a contested resource. The more contested the resource, and the more you obtain of it, the more you signal your ability to procure and defend it. That is why I distinguished access to housing in places with high demand versus access to housing in places with low demand in my previous post.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThis is still very contrived. If all housing does is signal income, then why is housing so much more attractive than an expensive car or an expensive watch? Even in places with low demand stable access to housing is still attractive. It's just rarer in places with high demand. This is reproduced in many cultures, for example in some Arab countries "renter" is an insult to someone you are dating.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>If all housing does is signal income, then why is housing so much more attractive than an expensive car or an expensive watch? I do not understand what you mean by this, but I do not claim that "all housing does is signal income". Let me re-characterize my statement for the basis of this discussion, which is that the vast majority of people would have an ideal goal of earning an ever increasing amount of money, regardless of capitalism. My contention is that due to the way people rank themselves versus each other, they will be interested improving (or at least maintaining) their position in the rankings. Why would they want to rank themselves? I posit that it helps for attracting mates. One can even go deeper and attribute it to the function of an ego, or some mechanism in the brain that incentivizes one to assert their priorities over others', allowing them the ability to not only survive, but compete. Going back to your initial reply: >What is attractive is social status - in capitalism this is linked mostly to wealth but that's not a given at all. Another thing that's attractive is stability, but that doesn't have anything to do with consumption, in today's world it means having stable access to housing, ideally owning it, mainly. I agree that it is about social status, which is what I am referring to by people ranking themselves (and each other). But money or not, the root of the ranking is power. Who has more power than who. Money is a proxy for power, which can exist with or without capitalism, so as long as there is money, I would bet that people (in general) will want more and more of it.