5 ms·
> Either you keep your head stationary and get the non-Spatial Audio sound (i.e. what they optimized for 90%+ of their audience) I literally have no idea what
by crazygringo 6y ago
> Either you keep your head stationary and get the non-Spatial Audio sound (i.e. what they optimized for 90%+ of their audience)
I literally have no idea what you're talking about.
Using Spatial Audio on my AirPods Pro is insanely better, and still very much spatial, even without actively moving my head.
First, the sound appears to be coming from outside of my head, rather than between my ears -- no "headphone fatigue". It's vastly more comfortable and realistic.
Second, while dialog comes from straight ahead, sound effects like doors opening, cars honking etc. clearly come from angles, and things like wind come from all around, like an actual surround sound experience.
Third, because the dialog tracks are separated from other sounds spatially, the dialog is easier to understand as well. I used to sometimes put on subtitles for certain material to understand fully in normal stereo -- I never have to anymore with spatial audio.
> Taking traditional multi-source audio (Dolby/Atmos/etc) and jamming it into stereo is old tech
I've used all that old tech too, and for whatever reason Apple's spatial audio is leagues better. I'm not sure if it's something about being optimized for known headphone characteristics, or the head tracking, or something clever with the inward-facing microphones, or all of the above, but it's nothing like that old tech.
> now want to work backwards into what it may be useful for.
It's useful for listening, end of story. I'm honestly mystified why you think it's a gimmick. I can't even imagine going back to listening to movies and TV without it. (I project from my iPad onto a screen, connect my AirPods Pro, and it's basically like being in an actual cinema, but without waking anyone else up at night from booming surround sound.)
- layer8 6y ago> the sound appears to be coming from outside of my head, rather than between my ears It’s a pity that Apple doesn’t provide that feature as a simple option that one can apply to any audio source.
- armincerf 6y agoIt gets activated on any audio source in a surround sound format, it can’t be applied to stereo sources because stereo audio doesn’t contain any positional info
- layer8 6y agoIt’s possible to apply Dolby Headphone (or similar systems) to any stereo signal, to get rid of the “in your head” sound.
- germinalphrase 6y agoCan you offer a good example video? I’ve done some binaural recording in the past, but my reaction so far to Apple’s spatial audio has been… kinda meh.
- crazygringo 6y agoI remember the first thing I tried when it came out was the first episode of See on the Apple TV+ app. It's a great showcase for it. It's sci-fi drama so has a lot of really immersive audio, Apple TV+ supports spatial audio, and the first episodes of Apple's series are free so it's easy to try. Try toggling the Spatial Audio option as you're watching to really get a sense of the difference. It's huge.
- dkonofalski 6y agoSee is amazing for it, even though I'm not a big fan of the show. It's so heavily based on sounds and audio that they really went all out on the audio for it.
- christoph 6y agoMost of the content on Disney+ sounds great in my experience. The Guardians of the Galaxy 2 intro scene is a good demo scene.
- pimlottc 6y agoHamilton on Disney+ is my go-to to test/show off spatial audio. It really does sound like the audio is coming from specific places on the stage.
- afavour 6y agoI think most of what you're saying applies to 3D TV, too. And that ended up being a dud. IMO the problem with both is that they're an awful shared experience, and a lot of TV watching is done by more than one person at a time.
- slownews45 6y agoIt's weird because I've had the BEST experience with apple in terms of shared experiences. I go to share audio on my iphone, then I share with my wifes airpods. Seems to work fine.
- afavour 6y agoEveryone is different, I suppose. A shared TV watching experience where we're both plugged into our own isolated audio and can't hear each other talk would be an awful experience for me.
- a4isms 6y agoNot only is everyone different, but we have different needs at different times. My partner and I use shared audio infrequently, but when we need it, we need it. Our use case is watching something together in bed while the kids are going to sleep. We put our AirPods Pro in “Transparent” mode, which allows us to converse with each other just fine. To say that “Your Mileage May Vary” would be putting it mildly. I accept that this feature may not be useful for you, in exactly the same way that Dark Mode in IOS is not useful for me, but seems to have its fans.
- crazygringo 6y ago> and can't hear each other talk That's what transparency mode is for. You can hear each other perfectly. You don't need noise cancellation as much when you're at home. It's more for the subway, planes, etc.
- slownews45 6y agoActually apple has a setting for this (at least on the pro's) which is called transparency. Works surprisingly well. You get the TV / movie audio in ear, and then any other audio from outside. We use it to keep an ear out for kids (bathroom breaks / falls off bed or whatever) and to chat with each other. But yes - some people do hate apple products - so different uses I think for different folks. My one MAJOR complaint is the volume of the mode switch sound on these things is way way too loud! Perhaps there is a setting for that I haven't found. Bong! in the ear is super annoying. Make it a click or something.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoDoes anyone happen to know of a non-headphone-specific solution for this, which actually does a good job? It doesn't need to work when I move my head, neither does the Virtual Barbershop[1] and yet the effect on my run-of-the-mill earbuds is still incredible. I'm open to little hardware boxes, software that modifies my computer's audio as it plays, a filter for ffmpeg, etc, as long as I can use whatever headphones I want and the spatial effect is high quality. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUDTlvagjJA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUDTlvagjJA
- crazygringo 6y agoI've tried a bunch of them over the years, heck way back when there was an analog box you could buy that did it. And there are still a ton -- heck, there's a checkbox built-in in VLC under Audio Effects > Filter > Headphone virtualization. But none of them that I've tried come anywhere close to what Apple has done. I don't know why. However, there is an official Dolby Atmos Surround Sound effect for Windows 10: https://www.howtogeek.com/309853/how-to-use-dolby-atmos-surround-sound-on-windows-10/ https://www.howtogeek.com/309853/how-to-use-dolby-atmos-surr... I've never tried it, but if anything currently competes decently with Apple's version, that might be it.