3 ms·
As much as I feel like NY City transit deserves state-level funding, I don't feel comfortable taxing people in low-income rural areas of the state $330 a year f
by nerdponx 6y ago
As much as I feel like NY City transit deserves state-level funding, I don't feel comfortable taxing people in low-income rural areas of the state $330 a year for this. I'd rather tax luxury developers and employers of white-collar workers who commute to the office.
- throwaway3699 6y agoThat's a great way to chase off more of the high-wage tax base in NYC. What's wrong with the fare model?
- nerdponx 6y agoThis is assuming that there are no fares, as suggested by GP. Also I think you are overestimating the elasticity of demand for residence in New York City with respect to tax rates, at least for people and businesses with large amounts of money. I'm not even close to what you would call a high income earner in New York City, but I would be fine with paying increased subway fares in order to subsidize bus fares in outer boroughs, paying $15 instead of $2.75 for East River ferry rides, etc. Shuffling around pocket change from people who won't even notice it's gone to people who need it desperately is not going to keep people out of New York. The biggest problem is real estate, both for the city's non-wealthy residents and for its small businesses. And even people with good incomes don't like being juiced for $4k++ in order to avoid living like a broke student with a 90 minute commute.
- chimeracoder 6y ago> As much as I feel like NY City transit deserves state-level funding, I don't feel comfortable taxing people in low-income rural areas of the state $330 a year for this The MTA already invests disproportionate levels of funds on commuter rail services that are used ~exclusively by non-city residents, far out of line with their usage. It's totally reasonable to have them contribute more, instead of forcing the city to shoulder an even greater burden. And that's just looking at MTA funds, not even considering the amount of money spent on maintaining free roads and highways in other parts of the state (the funding for which is already drawn disproportionately from NYC's tax base).
- nerdponx 6y agoMetro North fares are also pretty high, and the suit-and-tie Metro North riders also aren't the people I had in mind who would be hurt by an extra $330/year tax. Highway maintenance is another story and you have a good point there. But I really wish that people wouldn't treat the state's finances like a battle of wills between the poor oppressed Westchester commuters and Manhattan tech bros versus the greedy rural upstate leeches.
- stereo 6y agoCity dwellers disproportionately pay for a lot of the infrastructure used in rural areas, where lower densities increase costs. Highways, postal services, utilities, etc. get charged the same, but cost less to deliver or are used less by city dwellers.