4 ms·
Autonomous driving is the perfect example of 80/20 (or more like 99/01) I'm sure autonomous cars can drive fine on Mountain View's straight wide streets, with
by lm28469 6y ago
Autonomous driving is the perfect example of 80/20 (or more like 99/01)
I'm sure autonomous cars can drive fine on Mountain View's straight wide streets, with 360 days of sun a year, barely any rain and no snow.
Put them in Swiss snowy mountain roads, in the middle of narrow historical Italian towns, or on an unmarked multi lane roundabout [0] and it's a whole other set of problems.
Autonomous cars is a good toy project but when you think about it's only going to make us even more addicted to cars, commute longer, pollute more. We'll need to redesign major portions of out infrastructures so that smart (ie dumb) cars can read the roads properly. I can't even imagine the amount of time and money we spent on this, realistically all you need is some kind of dumb algorithm to take care of stop and go traffic and emergency braking. Everything else will be too faillible and require someone to constantly make sure the car doesn't suddenly decide to commit suicide
[0] https://static.actu.fr/uploads/2019/11/paris-arc-triomphe-rond-point-étoile-champs-elysees-accident-1.jpg https://static.actu.fr/uploads/2019/11/paris-arc-triomphe-ro...
- ghaff 6y agoYou don't even need to get to the genuinely tough scenarios that I almost certainly would have sweaty palms driving in. There are just a lot of scenarios with utility or delivery trucks blocking lands, even modest snow, construction work, unprotected lefts with various complications, pedestrians doing crazy things, roads not on maps, etc. But an autonomous vehicle needs to be able to handle pretty much all those things even without a human present.
- alkonaut 6y agoIt's just a matter of whether it's 40/60, 50/50 or eventually 80/20. The point I think is still valid: some fixed cost gets you half the way from where you are, towards 100. You will never get to 100, and the place where you might stop and think "This will be more expensive than a private driver for the coming decade" is probably lower than we think (say 90/10 or even 80/20). Making a car that can do 99% of my highway driving or 90% of my driving time will be easy, possibly even in my lifetime. But neither of those makes for truly autonomous taxis, and they won't drive me home from the pub when I sleep in my back seat, so I really don't see the point.
- ghaff 6y agoI actually think fully autonomous driving for some subset of highway driving would be a really big deal--both for reasons of convenience and safety. But you're right. It doesn't buy you a taxi service which is what a lot of people care about.
- Digit-Al 6y agoThat's what I was just thinking. You could potentially have autonomous geofencing. You enter your destination into the satnav and then start driving; when you get to a geofenced highway that is considered "AI safe" the car will give you a signal. At that point, if you wish you can set the car to autonomous mode and your seat will automatically move back a bit and tilt back so you can relax; maybe even take a nap (not sure about that though). When you are about 10 minutes away from exiting the geofenced section the car will return your seat to the normal driving position and sound an alarm so you have time to get your brain back into gear and take over control again.