3 ms·
The possibilities are of course endless; I think the discussion is about what is claimed today.
by robertlagrant 6y ago
The possibilities are of course endless; I think the discussion is about what is claimed today.
- sigjuice 6y agoWhat's with all the nitpicking? I just don't get it. What is claimed today is entirely reasonable. The landing page says SIMILAR to Java. It doesn't say runs identically on exactly all versions of every system that Java programs will run on. Also, this is a C binary we are talking about. Fundamentally, a C binary will not run on multiple architectures (at least not without some sort of special translation mechanism like Rosetta or qemu user-mode emulation). "Modern desktops and servers" is still pretty much x86-64 for most of the world. Yes, I know there are ARM servers and I'm typing this on an M1 Mac and I own nearly all kinds of Raspberry Pi's (even the minor revs of some models).
- KMag 6y ago> Fundamentally, a C binary will not run on multiple architectures (at least not without some sort of special translation mechanism like Rosetta or qemu user-mode emulation). The C machine model doesn't dictate native compilation. You could (and in fact IBM OS/400 does[0]) compile C to a binary format that does run on multiple architectures. Maybe instead of "C binary" you meant "C compiled to native binary", but that linguistic shortcut also encourages a mental shortcut that excludes several interesting design tradeoffs. In the IBM TIMI case, the equivalent of setting the execute bit on the binary triggers OS/400 to perform the native code generation and save that native code to disk, similar to some versions of Android Runtime, but without mandatory garbage collection. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_i#TIMI https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_i#TIMI
- robertlagrant 6y agoI wasn't making a point about the claimed error. I was saying "think of what can be done in the future" is not relevant.
- tomcam 6y agoHang on. Didn’t the parent post do exactly that?