3 ms·
Okay as far as it goes, but it doesn't explain how to fix the problem. We need to drum up interest for a solution. The way I like to explain it is that Bitcoin
by skybrian 6y ago
Okay as far as it goes, but it doesn't explain how to fix the problem. We need to drum up interest for a solution.
The way I like to explain it is that Bitcoin is collectively giving away about $1.5 billion a month in prize money to miners. That's the root of the problem. Miners will spend up to $1.5 billion a month on electricity (mainly) and their other expenses. Currently it's about 10x Google's electricity usage.
Total revenue is proportional to the block reward (an algorithmic parameter) and Bitcoin price. So to fix this, either they could reduce the block reward ahead of schedule (won't happen) or something could happen to crash Bitcoin's price. More transaction volume would actually be better if it were due to a fire sale.
Taxing holdings of Bitcoin would be a way to convince people and businesses to sell and discourage buying, at least for those that pay their taxes.
Or who knows, maybe threatening to do this would result in enough consensus to accelerate the block reward halving schedule?
- Taek 6y ago> We need to drum up interest for a solution. There is already massive interest in finding more efficient ways to solve the problem. It's a difficult problem to solve (as Elon Musk will likely learn in the coming year). The cost of proof of work is paid in two forms. The first is in the form of inflation. Merely holding onto Bitcoin means eating dilution as new Bitcoins are printed to fund the mining ecosystem. And the second cost is in terms of transaction fees. At times, it can cost $20+ to send a transaction over the Bitcoin network, and a more efficient / higher throughput system could significantly reduce these fees. The users of Bitcoin are already themselves naturally incentivized to look for better solutions, even completely absent any care about the environment.
- reader_mode 6y ago>The users of Bitcoin are already themselves naturally incentivized to look for better solutions This would imply the users of Bitcoin use it for anything more than speculative investment.
- skybrian 6y agoHolders of Bitcoin want to see the price go up, which makes the problem worse. So the primary incentive is very bad and that's how we got here. More enlightened self-interest would be to want to see the price go up without using more electricity, but this is secondary to the primary incentive. To get action from enlightened self-interest, there needs to be leadership for making changes. (Ethereum seems to have this?)
- atweiden 6y ago> To get action from enlightened self-interest, there needs to be leadership for making changes. (Ethereum seems to have this?) Knowledge preceedes enlightenment. For example, Git is also green-friendly, and shares a virtually identical consensus model to pure PoS consensus designs. It’s just that “green-friendliness” wasn’t a design goal of cryptocurrency — creating a lasting store of value sans institutions, exchangeable pseudonymously over the internet, was. As it were, pure PoS consensus suffers from the misfeature of not even having a quantitative fork ranking protocol — i.e. it lacks a way to objectively compare the truthfulness of divergent blockchains [1]. In PoW networks, cumulative hashing power can be simply and easily mathematically compared to produce cold, quantitative consensus. In PoS networks, there is no hashing power, and human intervention is required — just like Git. Which begs the question, why do PoS networks even need a blockchain? I think we all know the reason for that, though — Git doesn’t have a hype train. Git just isn’t good enough at separating the general public from their hard-earned money. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27144921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27144921
- skybrian 6y agoSaying "just use git" seems simplistic. But I could imagine a Debian-like organization that chooses a pool of trusted servers run by independent organizations in multiple countries, where they all have to agree, and with a full transparency log like DNS.
- nine_k 6y agoBitcoin is trustless, it is designed to withstand quite serious attempts at committing fraud (haha, a pun). Git was designed for cooperative work, and critically depends on trust (commit access). Merkle trees are easy, scalable schemes of trustless consensus, less so :(
- reader_mode 6y agoThe saddest or the most idiotic part of this whole story is the "bitcoin to the moon" crowd. Bitcoin price almost directly increases the effort spent on mining - if you're going into bitcoin now hoping it will 2x this literally means you're hoping it will 2x the hardware and energy consumption.
- wmf 6y agoIn one sense the solution is PoS. But Bitcoin will never ever ever adopt PoS, so we need to somehow convince hodlers and traders to switch to another cryptocurrency in a way that doesn't look like discrimination (e.g. outright banning PoW). A global carbon tax is an obvious yet oh so difficult possibility. Some kind of memetic warfare might be more feasible.
- wpietri 6y agoGreat point! For what it's worth, they could easily spend more than that $1.5 billion. Or at least cause to be spent. There's well known theft of electricity and computation for mining. Give the opaqueness of the industry, it's totally plausible that there are under-the-table deals or power diversions at large scale. Some people will be in the grip of sunk-cost fallacy or irrational optimism about Bitcoin's future gains. And then of course there are the negative externalities from things like pollution.
- c1sc0 6y agoOne way would be to simply start to do CO2 offsets of the total estimated energy spent per block mined. It’s a fun thing to calculate & dream about but enforcement would be hard.
- lottin 6y agoThe way the bitcoin network works, as far as I understand it, is by running a lottery every 10 minutes. The thing is there are many ways of running a lottery that don't involve burning tons of electricity in the process. In fact most lotteries don't burn any energy at all. Why the inventors of bitcoin decided to do it this way is beyond me.
- useryman 6y ago> there are many ways of running a lottery that don't involve burning tons of electricity in the process You need something to be the limiting factor on the amount that you can try to win such a lottery. With proof of work, it's electricity. (assuming everyone is about as efficient as each other) Early on, they talked about it being proportional to cpu-time. That has become more abstract since.
- lottin 6y agoThe limiting factor can be the price of the lottery ticket. (It seems the most obvious limiting factor, by the way.)
- useryman 6y agoBut what's the cost of the lottery ticket? Is it a certain amount work done? That's "proof of work". Is it an amount of the currency? That's "proof of stake", kinda. I haven't heard of any cryptos that require you to risk your coins to mine. Sounds like a neat gimmick, but hard to implement.
- rcxdude 6y agoThe lottery isn't the point, it's a side effect. The network needs consensus on what transactions have happened and which haven't. The main difficulty in getting this when you can't trust the nodes that someone can just spin up an arbitrary number of nodes to overwhelm the consensus, if the consensus just goes by majority vote. If you want to prevent this you need to tie the consensus to something which is scarce, which is what proof of work does. As a side effect of how this is implemented, it becomes a lottery. If you implement proof of stake, for example (where the scarce resource becomes the currency of the network itself, which is a lot trickier to implement and especially quite hard to bootstrap from nothing because in the early days of a currency there's going to be only a few people owning it), then there's no need for the reward process to be a lottery (though it still can be).