7 ms·
> A better metric would be "energy use per double-spend that was prevented." Not for a general audience. The purpose of a currency is to enable transactions. I
by wpietri 6y ago
> A better metric would be "energy use per double-spend that was prevented."
Not for a general audience. The purpose of a currency is to enable transactions. Internally, I get why people involved might fuss about the metric. But from the societal perspective it's reasonable to ask, "What does it cost per unit of value created?"
- arcticbull 6y agoFurther the purpose of mining is to enable mutations to the chain as quantized into transactions. If you stop permitting mutations energy use drops to zero, ergo energy use per transaction is totally reasonable.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoThat's not how logic works. That would be like saying "you need light to your math homework so we will measure how many math problems you can do per lumen of light". The throughput of transactions is not coupled to the amount of electricity used to mine. They are two elements in the system, that doesn't mean they move proportionally in any way.
- arcticbull 6y agoA better analogy would be trying to use a 7-seater dump truck as a school bus, then complaining when the 'haters' analysis is based on "gallons of gasoline per available seat-day." As if the fact the gallons of gasoline per seat-day changes based on external factors (i.e. with the weather or traffic) makes any difference? It legitimately does not matter that (i) not all 7 seats may be populated each day or that (ii) the gas required varies day to day based on externalities. That's why we invented averages and spot measurements. So fine, "kWh per available transaction-second" may be a more apt moniker however that's strictly what I've been talking about. Since 100% of electricity usage is attributable to mutations, this is a completely fair quantization. As blocks have been overwhelmingly full for years, the point on discrepancy is pretty much moot. And further, the point is a dump truck is totally unsuitable for use as a school bus. You are more than welcome to measure Wh of electricity used per math question in regards to the lighting setup. You'll find that number small and irrelevant, however. On the other hand if it requires a few thousand kWh worth of light to do a math question, you're well within your rights to ask (a) why you're doing math questions in what must be a stadium setting and (b) whether there's a more efficient lighting solution. Which are exactly the questions we're asking here. So, respectfully, that's exactly how logic works.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoNo one is complaining and no one said "haters", these are things you hallucinated. I'm not defending bitcoin, I'm just pointing out that you have huge misunderstanding about how it and cryptocurrency works in general even though these things have been explained to you over and over. Bitcoin's electricity use it because of its sustained price. If the miners could not consistently sell for high prices the overall electricity use would go down. Price/electricity usage going up or down does not affect throughput over the long term. Bitcoin's throughput is from being artificially crippled to sell a second layer. If the maximum block size was raised, it would have more throughput. The max block size does not change the amount of electricity used from the block reward. The same way that you would not measure your internet connection on mb per kw/hr since the energy used by 10mbs service is going to be the same as 1000gbs service. The two things are barely correlated. Energy per transaction is barely correlated. I know it is simple and easy to look at two numbers and pretend they depend on each other, but that isn't the dynamic here, which is why everything you are saying is nonsense.
- arcticbull 6y ago> No one is complaining and no one said "haters", these are things you hallucinated. > ... which is why everything you are saying is nonsense. You're being rude again. Once again this is against the site terms. I'm happy to engage in any civil conversation with you that doesn't involve name-calling, as I'm sure you've seen a number of times. This thread, however is closed.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoNo one is being rude to you. If you don't want someone to mention that you made up something they didn't say, then don't do that. If you say the same things over and over that have been explained to you to be false, don't be surprised if that gets brought up. If you can confront what I'm saying with something true, feel free.
- arcticbull 6y ago
- lottin 6y ago> The throughput of transactions is not coupled to the amount of electricity used to mine. They are two elements in the system, that doesn't mean they move proportionally in any way. We know that. This is not an argument against cost per transaction being an adequate measure of efficiency for a transaction processing system.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoCost per transaction to the users is important, but it is mostly separate from the cost of mining. The cost of mining is dictated by the price. Conflating the two doesn't make sense, because they aren't correlated and the costs are taken on by different groups of people. Not only that, but not all cryptocurrencies are even trying to optimize for this. I would say that bitcoin is actually in the opposite direction and trying to be as expensive per transaction for both the miners and users as possible.
- skybrian 6y agoOkay as far as it goes, but it doesn't explain how to fix the problem. We need to drum up interest for a solution. The way I like to explain it is that Bitcoin is collectively giving away about $1.5 billion a month in prize money to miners. That's the root of the problem. Miners will spend up to $1.5 billion a month on electricity (mainly) and their other expenses. Currently it's about 10x Google's electricity usage. Total revenue is proportional to the block reward (an algorithmic parameter) and Bitcoin price. So to fix this, either they could reduce the block reward ahead of schedule (won't happen) or something could happen to crash Bitcoin's price. More transaction volume would actually be better if it were due to a fire sale. Taxing holdings of Bitcoin would be a way to convince people and businesses to sell and discourage buying, at least for those that pay their taxes. Or who knows, maybe threatening to do this would result in enough consensus to accelerate the block reward halving schedule?
- Taek 6y ago> We need to drum up interest for a solution. There is already massive interest in finding more efficient ways to solve the problem. It's a difficult problem to solve (as Elon Musk will likely learn in the coming year). The cost of proof of work is paid in two forms. The first is in the form of inflation. Merely holding onto Bitcoin means eating dilution as new Bitcoins are printed to fund the mining ecosystem. And the second cost is in terms of transaction fees. At times, it can cost $20+ to send a transaction over the Bitcoin network, and a more efficient / higher throughput system could significantly reduce these fees. The users of Bitcoin are already themselves naturally incentivized to look for better solutions, even completely absent any care about the environment.
- reader_mode 6y ago>The users of Bitcoin are already themselves naturally incentivized to look for better solutions This would imply the users of Bitcoin use it for anything more than speculative investment.
- skybrian 6y agoHolders of Bitcoin want to see the price go up, which makes the problem worse. So the primary incentive is very bad and that's how we got here. More enlightened self-interest would be to want to see the price go up without using more electricity, but this is secondary to the primary incentive. To get action from enlightened self-interest, there needs to be leadership for making changes. (Ethereum seems to have this?)
- Taek 6y agoNot all transactions are created equal. Some transactions are more valuable than others, and there is also value in just maintaining a steady state (holding wealth). Something that also seems to get lost in the mix frequently is the fact that bitcoin owners themselves are the ones paying for the electricity. The security benefit comes at a cost - manifested as inflation (not just transaction fees) - and that cost is borne by all of the owners of Bitcoin. To that extent, the participants in Bitcoin are actually incentivized to use more efficient systems, because it means the inflation cost of being a participant is lower. That they don't use cheaper systems indicates (though there are plenty of confounding factors) that they see value in paying the larger cost of holding Bitcoin.
- wpietri 6y agoWith no transactions, the wealth stored is valueless, like deeds to property on the moon. People store wealth in currencies only because they think they can get it out later. That's in contrast to assets like houses or land, which have use value. And Bitcoin users are only paying the fraction of the cost paid for energy. But that ignores negative externalities like the pollution that's the subject of the article.
- Taek 6y agoOf course, you need _some_ amount of transactions. But that could theoretically be 500 a year and still adding just as much value as bitcoin today, so long as the transactions were sufficiently significant.
- wpietri 6y agoProbably not. An important component in value for many assets is liquidity. That's even more true for a currency.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> But from the societal perspective it's reasonable to ask, "What does it cost per unit of value created?" Then you have to define value. I don't think it's transactions. Any random bank can make transactions. People can transact with cash. Cryptocurrencies create value by providing other properties such as decentralization, trustlessness, privacy. For example, Monero enables private and untraceable transactions and for privacy enthusiasts it has essentially infinite value. With this definition of value, we can see how bitcoin isn't providing much. By now it's centralized, has no privacy, has high fees... It sucks basically. The only reason it's still the number one currency seems to be inertia. It's the most frustrating thing about this market honestly. Not only is bitcoin still king but it drags down better coins when its value plummets.
- Slartie 6y ago> I don't think it's transactions. Interesting. > For example, Monero enables private and untraceable transactions [...] So so... > Cryptocurrencies create value by providing other properties such as decentralization, trustlessness, privacy. Let's add "a largely unregulated gambling area where people with too much money can bet their excess money on being among those who pull out before the music eventually stops" to that list, shall we? That's also where your frustration comes from: Bitcoin is perfectly fine for this kind of "value proposition", hence it stays King of the Hill.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> So so... What I mean is people can transact via traditional systems just fine and they choose cryptocurrency because of other qualities. > largely unregulated gambling area The speculation is a separate thing from the coins themselves. People also speculate with fiat currencies, stocks, real estate. > That's also where your frustration comes from: Bitcoin is perfectly fine for this kind of "value proposition", hence it stays King of the Hill. Yes. What I don't understand is how it drags the whole market along with it no matter where it goes.
- Slartie 6y ago