4 ms·
What about if Amazon prevented a seller from advertising “direct to sale at a discount” and bypassing Amazon on their product page?
by vlovich123 6y ago
What about if Amazon prevented a seller from advertising “direct to sale at a discount” and bypassing Amazon on their product page?
- void_mint 6y agouhhh....this happens all the time already. Lots of Amazon sellers maintain web stores and purchasing options outside of Amazon.
- enos_feedler 6y agoAnd do they link to those stores from their amazon product descriptions?
- void_mint 6y agoCan you point to an example of Epic doing that from an Apple-owned page (meaning, specifically, not from the app that Epic owns)? You're moving the goal posts further away from this example making sense.
- ntr-- 6y agoI think it's a bit disingenuous to imply that the example in question^1 is less extreme than Amazon allowing sellers to directly link to discounted options directly on their listings. The app in question was built, packaged, distributed, installed and runs on Apple funded SDKs after all. 1. https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-store-2045x979-730033169.png https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-stor...
- void_mint 6y agoThe source of the app is owned and maintained by Epic. The source of an Amazon seller page is made through Amazon's portal.
- enos_feedler 6y agoIts splitting hairs to break this down into who compiled the code. The “source” of both experiences is maintained by the developer/seller. In one case it’s some configuration and the other case it’s Apple platform bitcode
- void_mint 6y ago> Its splitting hairs to break this down into who compiled the code. It's not. The difference between building your store and getting a booth in someone else's.
- enos_feedler 6y agoThis makes no sense. Both the app store and amazon is someone elses store wrt Fortnite
- void_mint 6y agohttps://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-store-2045x979-730033169.png https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-direct-pay-apple-app-stor... Show me the app store in this image?
- ntr-- 6y agoTo extend your simile, in this case Epic appears to have accepted a booth in a marketplace where there is significant foot traffic, easy access and well tested distribution channels. They are quite content selling their wares there yet do not want to pay the asking price and are actively telling people to go to their own marketplace on the other side of town. Doesn't sound like a vendor I would want in my market either.
- void_mint 6y ago> in this case Epic appears to have accepted a booth in a marketplace where there is significant foot traffic, easy access and well tested distribution channels. No, and again, these moving goal posts make this conversation more and more meaningless. Epic wants to sell their currency outside of the app store. They're not allowed to do so by Apple's TOS. This is the same as Amazon saying a website cannot sell to users on the Seller's personal site if the buyer owns an Amazon account. It's just monopoly garbage. If it were possible to buy from _either_ the App Store or Epic's store, Epic would certainly ablige and just include a 30% upcharge. Of course, nobody would use it (as has been proven over and over again), but they would absolutely include it.
- gsich 6y agoThat's an ebay thing. I haven't seen different product descriptions on Amazon. There is only 1, no matter which seller you buy from.
- oh_sigh 6y agoThat seller almost certainly signed a contract with amazon saying that they would give amazon most-favored nation status with regards to product prices. So they could absolutely say such a thing, but in the end they couldn't contractually offer anything at a cheaper rate than what they list it for on amazon.
- vlovich123 6y agoThat's identical to contracts Epic signs to be on the Apple Store in the first place.
- PeterisP 6y agoNo, that's definitely not identical - no one, including Apple, is asserting that the fact that Fortnite users could by the same thing cheaper directly was a contract violation, the contentious issue was only that this cheaper price was being advertised on the iOS app.
- vlovich123 6y agoRight. Just as with Amazon. You don’t necessarily see Amazon with the lowest price for an item (the most favored nation thing may happen but I don’t know that that’s standard SOP for everything on the store, eg PlayStation may have discounts through other channels and for certain types of vendors they view as fungible without a brand they may not care at all). But you don’t see advertising for the cheaper option on the Amazon page.