3 ms·
> 15%/month didn't sound that bad to her This is why when economists talk about consumers acting as rational market participants I just laugh and shake my head
by whimsicalism 6y ago
> 15%/month didn't sound that bad to her
This is why when economists talk about consumers acting as rational market participants I just laugh and shake my head.
Have they met people?
- elliekelly 6y agoWhen your only options are (1) a loan at 15% while you’re unemployed but you get another 30-60 days of a roof over your head or (2) immediate homelessness then the high-interest loan is the rational choice.
- reader_x 6y agoI think Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky already put the “rational market participant” myth to bed for good.
- whimsicalism 6y agoDefinitely, for the consumer. I think the idea that "rational market participant emerges when you get the average of a lot of people (ie. the firm) together to make a decision" still remains alive and well. There is sort of a Darwinian argument there, that in the long-run only the rational market participant remains in business and functioning as a firm. The import of behavioral econ. definitely remains understated today. I am also interested in philosophical thinkers, like Elizabeth Anderson or Michael Sandel, that take questions like these and explore the implications that they might have for how we ought to structure society.
- sidlls 6y agoThat seems likely to veer into begging the question or tautology territory.
- kortilla 6y agoHas it occurred to you that people taking payday loans don’t have a lot of options? This isn’t someone deciding between 15% monthly and a nice 4% annual personal loan. This is someone deciding between 15% monthly and homelessness. Choosing the interest rate is rational.
- belltaco 6y agoIs it that high because of the risk? Why aren't competitors lowering the rates if it's that high and excessive.
- xiphias2 6y agoBecause it's that hard to find a job during COVID. If she's not able to pay back the loan, she will be killed and her family is responsible for paying it back. The amount of undocumented suffering in the poor world right now is huge.