5 ms·
I cannot shake off the feeling that the core developers standing behind systemd, pulseaudio, Gnome desktop spend a lot of time using macOS, and like it better t
by nine_k 6y ago
I cannot shake off the feeling that the core developers standing behind systemd, pulseaudio, Gnome desktop spend a lot of time using macOS, and like it better than Linux.
This would explain why they imitate or copy many of its features (and misfeatures), and seemingly tend to replace the Unix ways with entirely different approaches. Effectively forcing things on users, as it was with pulseaudio and systemd, is also a very macOS thing to do.
I'm not opposed to replacing Unix with different approaches, as long as they keep playing on its key strengths, and do not remove modularity and composability. That is, Plan 9 is fine with me. Much of what Red Hat does, sadly, no.
- zxzax 6y agoIf plan 9 is what you want, I would encourage you to use 9front. I can't see why you would use Linux if you didn't like Red Hat, they have been a key contributor in Linux land for a long time, employing many long-time kernel developers.
- nine_k 6y agoI'm not sure if 9front can be a daily driver yet; say, it does not seem to be able to run Emacs. Would be nice though. Not that I don't like Red Hat. They are the poster child of a successful open-source company, and did and keep doing a ton of great things. I only don't like certain directions of development of certain userspace things which happen to be done under their corporate umbrella. These things, systemd in particular, were quite noticeable on the Linux landscape as of recently, both in the tiny desktop niche, and the huge server sector. Nobody's perfect, you know.
- zxzax 6y agoI have to say, that seems like a strange requirement: I have never really considered Emacs (or Lisp) to be particularly Unix-like at all! I think the plan 9 people would probably tell you to ditch Emacs and use acme (Me personally, I say use whatever you want).
- nine_k 6y agoEmacs inside is very unixy, under a particular angle. Everything is a list, a ton of small composable functions doing one thing well, one common language that unifies all key interfaces, and the general lack of a predefined final construction, but rather a bucket of Lego blocks around a kernel which does the heavy lifting. Acme us interesting, but pretty different; its automation is apparently written in the shell language using normal OS commands. AFAICT the Plan 9 shell lacks structured data types comparable to Lisp's: it has lists, but not nested lists, so such constructs are a bit less robust. Also, AFAICT, Acme actively wants mouse operations; I hope reasonable keyboard equivalents exist. I'll explore more of it in my copious free time (sigh).
- zxzax 6y agoHaving a lot of small composable functions and a lot of singly linked lists describes most functional programming languages though. I think that's only one part of the traditional Unix design. Though to me it was always seemed like the inspiration goes the opposite way -- it seems like Unix was in some ways designed as a "Lisp-like," where the shell works as a somewhat restricted version of functional programming that only operates on one data type.
- gsich 6y agoI don't blame them. Linux desktop is still a mess. systemd is great though.
- wearywanderer 6y ago> [Gnome developers imitating/coping MacOS features] I've heard this a lot, but having used Gnome briefly and MacOS fairly extensively, I just don't see it. Also, have you seen KDE's Dolphin? If ever there was a Finder clone, it's Dolphin. With regards to copying MacOS, Dolphin devs have wiped the floor clean with Gnome. Besides Dolphin specifically, KDE in general is flexible enough that making it look and feel like MacOS is pretty easy. Gnome though? It's not particularly MacOS-y by default, and Gnome devs have naked contempt for customization, so good luck if you want to try anyway. However, I share your suspicion that most Gnome developers do not actually use Gnome as their daily driver.
- nine_k 6y agoYes, that naked contempt to customization is what I find more macOS-y than any exact copy of the visuals. KDE in this regard is pretty safe: you can bend and shape it to taste pretty thoroughly. Interestingly, classic MacOS, at the times of 6.5 or 7, was somehow more customizable, and seemed to have more power-user features. Just like, well, Gnome back in the day %) So, my daily driver is Xfce.
- zxzax 6y agoThe customization in the desktop of GNOME itself is still there, but it has mostly moved to shell extensions. If you're willing to deal with that, you can change quite a bit of functionality. The apps are a different story, those tend not to go for a lot of customization and will usually just focus on optimizing for one or two use cases. If you have other use cases, the suggestion there would probably be to make a separate app.
- XorNot 6y agoGNOME would be fine and was fine up until the attempt at tablet integration happened, and it's been total chaos since then. The problem is they hopped aboard the same bandwagon Microsoft did with Windows 8, where every started throwing tablet/touch style UI onto desktop interfaces. For the life of me, I don't understand why there wasn't a happy middle ground of "or we'll render the main menu as a regular menu bar". But at this point it's not a GNOME criticism so much as an entire UI/UX industry criticism.