3 ms·
Yeah, that's my question with all this. I mean, ransomware is obviously illegal. Finding vulnerabilities in smart contracts - well, "the code is the contract",
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Yeah, that's my question with all this. I mean, ransomware is obviously illegal. Finding vulnerabilities in smart contracts - well, "the code is the contract", so the hacker is just executing the code as it was published.
I mean, the whole reason Ethereum Classic exists is because a subset of Ether folks felt that restoring the funds in the original DAO hack was contrary to the whole "the code is the contract" ethos.
- splintercell 6y agoIf Code is law then hard fork is also law. Otherwise those Ethereum classic people are saying that code is law but only the DSL of Solidity. Outside updatable Ethereum engine code is not law.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> If Code is law then hard fork is also law Not at all. All crypto currency only has value because other people collectively choose to "believe" a certain chain. Usually there is global consensus of which chain is the "true" chain, but there have been many times in the past that one group has decided to follow a different fork for whatever reason. I mean, Bitcoin has Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin Gold. The value that gets allocated to a particular fork just depends on the number of other people that choose to follow that chain.
- splintercell 6y agoYou were just giving me arbitrary facts after saying “no”. I get this feeling you don’t understand what I’m talking about. The biggest code is lowercase was after the Dao fork when Ethereum hard forked. The argument given by Therion classic people was that since code is law it’s unethical and incorrect to hard for the funds away from the hacker, because he now legitimately owns the stolen funds.
- PeterisP 6y agoIgnoring contract law (which would not blindly accept "the code is the contract", and people's ethos does not allow them to arbitrarily decide how contracts shall work in the country where they live), the fact that some action was explicitly written in a contract that was properly signed by everyone does not necessarily mean that the action was lawful. For example, if you intentionally misrepresent what the contract means to deceive someone into signing a contract, then is fraud, and it also invalidates the contract. If the fraudster already got the money according to that (invalid) contract, no matter if it's cash or crypto, they possess it, but it's not lawfully theirs.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI mean, at its heart then you are really arguing than smart contracts shouldn't exist in the first place (I don't really disagree). The entire reason that smart contracts exist is to get rid of the need for any trusted third party intermediary because (as proponents argue) all of the logic for the contract is completely embedded in the code. If it then becomes necessary to say "The code is the contract, unless there's a bug, in which case we'll have some single or set of arbiters decide what the code was really supposed to do" then why have smart contracts at all, why not just go through a normal escrow process where there is an independent arbiter trusted to determine who "lawfully" deserves the funds.
- PeterisP 6y agoI'm not necessarily arguing that smart contracts shouldn't exist in the first place - perhaps they have a valid future role in effectively and cheaply adjudicating small claims where currently it might not be worth to enforce a contract due to the effort and costs of the legal process; something vaguely like what arbitration was intended to be. This use case would IMHO have a quite large market, and it would be perfectly compatible with those smart contracts having a proper (non-code) appeals process explicitly designed in the system - the benefit would be that the third party (arbiters, or state, or whatever) is not used in most cases, because that would be costly.
- 6y ago