3 ms·
Txs / MWh is not a valid metric for most cryptocurrencies since power consumption is proportional to price, not transactions. Also, BSV and BCH are totally ins
by wmf 6y ago
Txs / MWh is not a valid metric for most cryptocurrencies since power consumption is proportional to price, not transactions.
Also, BSV and BCH are totally insecure so it's not really fair to compare them to secure cryptocurrencies.
- qeternity 6y agoOf course it’s a valid metric. The whole point of this is that most crypto is not used to transact, but to speculate, and so a high price and therefore high carbon footprint with a low transaction throughput is often the whole point of these analyses.
- shawnz 6y agoTransactions aren't the only thing which makes cryptocurrencies useful, and even then, cryptocurrency transactions aren't directly comparable to each other or to transactions in traditional financial systems since they can have a much different risk profile. Furthermore it's not obvious that increased transaction rates are necessary yet in most cryptocurrencies and so it might not make sense to optimize for that yet. There is no point encouraging frivolous data to be added to the blockchain permanently if the demand to make useful transactions isn't there yet.
- pmorici 6y agoIt's proportional to the value a miner is awarded (ie: block reward + transaction fess) for mining a block not the price of the coin. Saying it is the price of the coin is like saying Berkshire Hathaway is worth more than Apple because their share price is a lot higher.
- lvs 6y agoNo, I think you misunderstand. The rewards are predictable, and fees are generally a tiny fraction of the total reward (a few percent or less). The exchange rate vs the price of electricity is what determines whether it's profitable to consume electricity to hash for a PoW chain. There are some efficiency hacks like merged mining that improve the situation a bit, but essentially the person you're downvoting is totally correct.
- drdeca 6y agofor Ethereum, my understanding is that the proportion from fees has been a substantial proportion (like, over 15%? idr the exact proportion, but I'm reasonably sure it is at least 15% ) for over a year.
- actinium226 6y agoWhy are BSV and BCH insecure?
- wmf 6y agoTheir hashrates are really low relative to market cap.
- baby 6y agoThe cost of a 51% attack: https://www.crypto51.app/ https://www.crypto51.app/
- sharperguy 6y agoLarger blocks means that they take longer to propagate across the network, meaning there is a much longer period where two or more miners might find alternative "next blocks", which could be exploited by tricking miners into including a different transaction in each split of the chain. This means that you basically have to wait much longer before you can be sure that your transaction will not be reversed. On top of that, larger blocks also means that home users, or small businesses can no longer run their own fully verifying nodes, meaning that we have to move to relying on larger businesses to take care of attacks on the network, and not to collude to change the ruleset. In reality, Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin SV have not taken off in popularity, due to these issues as well as serious character flaws in their most vocal proponents, meaning that for now their blocks remain small, and the possibility of these attacks isn't actually realized. But if they were to become more popular it would not last long.
- actinium226 6y agoThis is all complete nonsense.
- sharperguy 6y agoSource?
- lawn 6y agoIt's valid for Bitcoin since it doesn't scale on-chain, thus it cannot raise it's efficiency. Also, BCH and BSV aren't "totally insecure" as that's far too black and white. If they were, then they would've been attacked and destroyed long ago and no exchanges would touch them.