4 ms·
Counterpoint: There are lots of engineers who are pretty excited about Go. Go ranked #5 in the 2020 StackOverflow Survey's "Most Loved Languages" section, for e
by throwaway894345 6y ago
Counterpoint: There are lots of engineers who are pretty excited about Go. Go ranked #5 in the 2020 StackOverflow Survey's "Most Loved Languages" section, for example, and I've never even heard of an account in which the manager lobbied to use Go for a project--it's almost always bottom up. Seems like it's not just managers who appreciate being able to come into a project and quickly come up to speed and contribute. It's strange to me that you portray that property so negatively.
- ghostwriter 6y ago> Counterpoint: There are lots of engineers who are pretty excited about Go. true, there are lots of junior engineers who don't know better tooling yet and that are still excited about taking random surveys.
- ironmagma 6y agoIt was also the #21 (37% of respondents) most dreaded. For context, the “love” rating was a 62% response, so that means it’s something like a 2:1 love to dread ratio. At my current company it’s definitely leadership pushing for Go and not the other way around, and lots of startups have chosen Go early and are stuck to it inflexibly. Edit: I retract this. Looks like the metrics are simply inverses (even though they shouldn’t be).
- tptacek 6y agoThis is deeply silly (so is that "dreaded" metric). Go is here less dreaded than Julia and Swift, two enthusiast-driven languages, as well as Ruby, and is just 2 slots up from Python. You gave away the game when you pointed out it was the "#21 most dreaded". What is anyone supposed to do with that very specific number?
- ironmagma 6y agoThe whole survey is fuzzy data of course, it could even be the same people dreading a language as loving it. That’s why I provided the percentage respondents. Citing either one as the value of a language is of course dubious, but if we’re acknowledging one metric we may as well acknowledge the other.
- morelisp 6y ago> it could even be the same people dreading a language as loving it Are they not literally inverses of each other? It's two ways of stating the same number, not something you can take as two data points.
- ironmagma 6y agoThe survey doesn’t say how the data was collected, but there has to at least be a middle “neutral” option because the two numbers don’t always add to 100%. Semantically they are opposites, but so are love and hate, and we know that a person can love and hate another person at the same time, or so the songs tell us.
- morelisp 6y agoThey do always add up to 100%.
- ironmagma 6y agoI think you’re right, it was confusing because sometimes it was only to 99% but that’s probably rounding. Disappointing and a poor survey methodology or at least poor presentation. There are definitely some languages I both love and dread, like Java and it would be nice to see those as separate metrics.
- tptacek 6y agoIt would be one thing if Go was one of the top 5 most loved and one of the top 5 most dreaded languages. That would suggest (imperfectly, but meaningfully) that it was a polarizing language. But it's the #21st most dreaded language; it is less dreaded than Julia, which is a pure enthusiast language. Your data point actually doesn't show anything. I think you'd be on rhetorically surer footing just arguing that these surveys don't mean anything. The fact of the matter is that while Go certainly has a squadron of haters on message boards (it made several design decisions that were almost precision-targeted to alienate PL connoisseurs), huge numbers of working programmers really like Go. It's silly to argue that isn't true.
- Google234 6y agoYou would really put Swift over rust as an enthusiast-driven language??
- tptacek 6y agoNo, I didn't mention Rust at all. Resist the impulse to reduce everything to zero-sum competitions between languages.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> lots of startups have chosen Go early and are stuck to it inflexibly. Is the implication here that it's a common experience among startups to pick Go and regret the decision? Can you give any evidence to support this (e.g., a survey of startups that chose Go and whether or not they regret their decision)? Or perhaps the implication is that Go is uniquely difficult to migrate away from? I have a hard time believing that--it's expensive to change languages across the board except for a handful of special cases that were designed for interop from the start (e.g., Java and Kotlin, C and C++, etc)--I don't see anything that makes Go uniquely difficult to migrate away from.
- ironmagma 6y agoThere’s no implication intended, it’s just related information that I have which could spark a discussion. (I obtained it through speaking to a lot of companies I’ve been interviewing with in the past weeks.) I’m sure Go is possible to migrate from, it’s just that companies that have it are decided on it and not interested in alternatives.
- beforeolives 6y ago> It was also the #21 (37% of respondents) most dreaded. This could trick someone who doesn't know that there are 25 languages in that survey and that the most dreaded chart is just an inverse of the most loved chart. You could also say that Typescript is the #24 most dreaded language (32.9% of respondents)... it's also the second most loved language. Rust is the #25 most dreaded language (because there are 25 languages on that list). https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-most-loved-dreaded-and-wanted-languages-dreaded https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2020#technology-mo...
- ironmagma 6y agoRust is an 86% to 14% ratio (6:1 love to dread) which would for example mean it’s less controversial. Not that I put any stake into these numbers.
- beforeolives 6y agoIt's important to note that Rust is not used nearly as much commercially which means that most of the people who use it are enthusiasts who like the language. So when you have a metric like > % of developers who are developing with the language or technology and have expressed interest in continuing to develop with it you then get a very strong selection effect which is the main reason why Rust has been at the top of that survey for a number of years now.