6 ms·
The London Underground's Oyster (more like OMNY than MetroCard) has a refundable deposit. So in principle you could give back your Oyster and get the deposit. O
by tialaramex 6y ago
The London Underground's Oyster (more like OMNY than MetroCard) has a refundable deposit. So in principle you could give back your Oyster and get the deposit. Of course it's not very much money and most people might need an Oyster again sooner or later so this is rarely taken up, but it discourages people from throwing them away.
Because people from far away are less likely to imagine ever needing an Oyster again, yet might still need one right now (especially before contactless payment cards would work just as well for most short term visitors) there was a scheme where you could just "donate" your card to charity at places like airports, I don't know if it still exists.
Because Oyster is variable fare even in the simplest scenarios (a trip from Stockwell to Brixton for example, versus a train going from central London out to Amersham at the far end of the line are different prices, before any consideration about season tickets, time of day etc.) it is possible to have a card that's valid to enter the system (it has enough money that you could make some trip) but then make a trip it can't pay for. In this case the balance on the card falls below zero on exit, to use it again you'll need to first pay the excess and enough for a ride somewhere. So you'd expect to see some number of cards discarded in this state, since they are in some sense less than worthless. But the inconvenience of needing a new card seems to out-weigh that.
- dheera 6y agoThis is the way almost all RFID systems I have used work, including Tokyo, Taipei, Singapore, Guangzhou, Hong Kong, Beijing, Shanghai, Chengdu, Wuhan, Shenzhen, Bangkok, Hangzhou, and the SF bay area. The RFID cards, however, are far more durable than the flimsy MetroCards that NYC uses. I keep all the cards from cities I visit though, since more often than not I end up passing through the city again within a few years. Some cities' cards unfortunately expire and eat all your balance, while others keep them for 10+ years. It's really nice though to just land at an airport and be on your way in minutes without fumbling and getting in line. On another hand I kind of miss the subway tokens that Boston used to use a long time ago. One of the advantages of tokens is that they are very much like NFTs in that if you have a token, it is a promise of a ride, any time, now or in the future. So you could also use them as an investment vehicle by buying 1000 of them, and the transit agency gets 1000 * (fare price) in liquid cash upfront that they can use to scale their infrastructure and make upgrades, while you can re-sell those tokens at a profit 4 years later. Or if you were arriving in Boston for college, you could buy enough transit ride tokens for 4 years upfront, if you were smart. Unfortunately with the RFID systems they don't usually pay dividends or interest on the balance on the card.
- tialaramex 6y agoI don't (as a rule) fly, so I certainly haven't visited as many far away cities as you. However, don't you find that increasingly contactless payment just works anyway? Certainly all Oyster terminals have accepted my Android phone for some time [If you use it constantly I believe the cheapest options still involve paying up front for an Oyster - but visiting once a week for work, or a few days on holiday the system tracks where you went, then works out after the fact what the cheapest way to do what you did would have been, and charges any contactless payment system accordingly]
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> However, don't you find that increasingly contactless payment just works anyway? Aside from the (bigger) reason that they aren’t accepted in all stations yet, one reason I haven’t switched in NYC is I’m nervous about my phone running out of battery.
- dheera 6y agoYes this. It's much more reliable to just put the RFID card inside my phone case. I can continue to swipe into transit "with my phone" even if the battery is dead. Also I always have to disable NFC on my phone because I have 2 phones and if they have NFC enabled they're always trying to talk to each other in my pocket and vibrating my crotch all day from it. Really bad UX.
- t3rabytes 6y agoThe iOS wallet implementation allows access to certain cards long after the phone is “dead” https://support.apple.com/guide/security/express-cards-with-power-reserve-sec90cd29d1f/web https://support.apple.com/guide/security/express-cards-with-...
- JCharante 6y agoI really like Bangkok's integrations where the card you use for the BTS also works with some food courts, so it's an extra incentive to store it (you get to leave the airport and grab a meal without even having to go to an ATM!) Although having the BTS, MTR, and SkyTrain managed differently means having to store 3 thick cards plus extra cards for some food courts just for a single city. Do the subways in Chinese cities have a system where you can just load the cards onto your phone? Hmm, now that I think about it not many Chinese phones have NFC.
- gberger 6y agoIn practice, you don't even need to give the Oyster card back to collect the deposit.
- pimlottc 6y agoWhat does that mean? You can just go to some sort of service desk and ask for your deposit back without presenting anything?
- gberger 6y agoYes, using a machine like this one [0] you just need to present your card to the contactless terminal and you'll be able to get £5 back in cash. [0]: https://www.google.com/search?q=oyster+card+machine&tbm=isch&ved=2ahUKEwia64P3vtDwAhXB0YUKHVzKAJUQ2-cCegQIABAA&oq=oyster+card+machine&gs_lcp=CgNpbWcQAzICCAAyBggAEAcQHjIECAAQGFCse1ise2DefGgAcAB4AIABNYgBNZIBATGYAQCgAQGqAQtnd3Mtd2l6LWltZ8ABAQ&sclient=img&ei=Q0OiYNq9L8GjlwTclIOoCQ&bih=1098&biw=1872&rlz=1C5GCEM_enGB952GB952#imgrc=Lx0vEpccu7ItoM https://www.google.com/search?q=oyster+card+machine&tbm=isch...