3 ms·
> I called it in to Sunnyvale DPS, and they were totally unaware of it. There were two near-collisions in the 45 seconds I was within view. Seems like if those
by ajross 6y ago
> I called it in to Sunnyvale DPS, and they were totally unaware of it. There were two near-collisions in the 45 seconds I was within view.
Seems like if those confused drivers had merely stopped where they were, safety would have been improved!
Again, the question isn't whether or not automation technology can be confused by bad signage, we know it can. Nor is there a question that humans can be confused by the same situation. The question is, when faced with situations like this, we can trust the automation to operate safely.
And it seems like Waymo passed the test.
It's true the externalities are different for the different technologies though. If you put down bad cones currently, you raise the likelihood of an accident. If you mark your lane badly in the era of automated vehicles, you cause a traffic jam. I know which I'd prefer.
- GeekyBear 6y ago> it seems like Waymo passed the test It did not seem so to me. Blocking the road (when it was clearly possible to get out of the way) increased the danger to others through inaction. Issac Asimov would tut tut.
- ajross 6y agoYou're not controlling your variables. The choice isn't between "block the road" and "unimpeded safe traffic", it's between "block the road" and "dangerous driving conditions". As we all know bad signage causes accidents. Here, it did not. Because the car stopped.
- GeekyBear 6y ago>The choice isn't between "block the road" and "unimpeded safe traffic", it's between "block the road" and "dangerous driving conditions". The choice was between block the road, or pull off to the side, when it was clearly safe to do so.
- ajross 6y ago> or pull off to the side The car did pull off to the side. Those cones mark the side of the road. What you're demanding it do is to cross the cones to pull off the closed-off shoulder of the road. Which is (1) illegal and (2) only safe because of assumptions you're making about why that road was closed. I mean, consider that they had a giant automated Waymo-branded repaving machine coming down in that lane. Would pulling off the the side have been the right choice? Again, it's true that an AI isn't going to have the same context that you do as a functioning human driver. And so it's going to make different decisions in pursuit of safety than you would. That's not evidence that it's unsafe. This behavior simply wasn't unsafe.
- GeekyBear 6y ago>The car did pull off to the side. That's not what I saw. The car attempted to follow it's planned route to use the right lane, and stopped in place when it saw the next traffic cone, partially blocking the left lane. Then it backed up and fully blocked the left lane.