5 ms·
>Apparently they're already about as long as steel can take, so they're getting wider instead. How does a ship being longer cause stress on the steel?
by gruez 6y ago
>Apparently they're already about as long as steel can take, so they're getting wider instead.
How does a ship being longer cause stress on the steel?
- bombcar 6y agoOut on the ocean there are waves - if the ship is between two of them it acts like a bridge and the steel has to support the weight or snap in two.
- usrusr 6y agoBut there's an obvious solution to that: more steel. Still, a far more effective solution would be increase width and draught likewise to reach your target volume. And that's where we're back at ${canal}max classes (locks also impose a length limit but I'd assume that those are much easier to adapt than width/depth). If Suez Canal authorities are serious about trying to prevent future Ever Given incidents (how serious they are likely depends on the exact outcome of the ongoing liability fights) they should keep some parts of the canal at the existing profile (locks perhaps?) to prevent suezmax 2.0 (or whatever their current version+1 is)
- manquer 6y agoMore steel/thicker/different steel is expensive, as is say some other material like carbon fiber composites . We could make a much bigger , lighter efficient ship with carbon fiber entirely, however there is no economic incentive to spend 100x on the ship, fuel costs and economies of scale rtc don't help recover that capital cost
- dmurray 6y ago> More steel/thicker/different steel is expensive Expensive would be OK, of course a bigger ship costs more to build than a small one, but you hope to make the investment back by carrying more cargo and additionally benefit from some economies of scale. However, the biggest ships we have are at the limit of how thick we can join steel plates with current welding technologies. So there's some non-linearity here.
- manquer 6y agoYeah, it is ecosystem of changes, you need bigger docks , shipyards and canals in conjunction with the technology improvements. The costs of all of it needs to be economically feasible even if the technology is there, I don't think welding is only reason we have been limited in the size
- bombcar 6y agoYou can see the practical limit in the ships designed to go directly from China - Los Angeles - as it's just open sea.
- manquer 6y agoNo doubt those waters are ideal given the high traffic and limited geographic barriers, even these however ships would still need to dock in LA. I am not saying the limit doesn't play a major role, I am saying if it's was the main bottleneck there would be a lot of r&d in solving it, solving it would certainly help, but the economics and other limitations mean solving welding won't mean a revolutionary change to ship sizes
- CalChris 6y agoThose ships still have to enter the harbor and then have to be unloaded. The Benjamin Franklin has a 52 foot draft and stacks containers 10 high [1]. That means deeper dredging and bigger cranes. She called on LA, Oakland and Seattle but now transits from Asia to Europe via the Suez Canal. Who pays for this dredging and these cranes? The localities. It's difficult to defray these costs with shipping fees. American President Lines pulled their headquarters from Oakland to Phoenix when Oakland did that. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMA_CGM_Benjamin_Franklin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CMA_CGM_Benjamin_Franklin [2] https://www.prlog.org/10551489-apl-phoenix-headquarters-relocation-complete.html https://www.prlog.org/10551489-apl-phoenix-headquarters-relo...
- cobbal 6y agoEventually, a long enough ship should be supported by 3 or more waves at the same time, assuming waves have some sort of maximum wavelength. (Disclaimer: no idea what I’m talking about)
- patentatt 6y agoRandom thought: Why don’t we see things like ship trains? With many linked smaller hulls being pulled by a single tug. Or something to that effect. Seems like a solution to that phenomenon.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoI would think (i.e. pure conjecture) that it's about economies of scale. Making enough smaller ships to make trains will costs more steel. Making a train that fills up a similar area in the ocean reduces the available storage per shipment. Follow this thought to "let's just make these trains as long as possible." You can imagine some wild consequences, both positive and negative.
- icegreentea2 6y agoSteering would be painful. Trains work particularly great because of the tracks. Also, drag on a hull is such that longer hulls tend to be more efficient.
- GordonS 6y agoWould you need to do much tricky steering outside of getting in/put of ports? At ports, even ships themselves are often pulled by tugs because of the difficulty of manoeuvring in such a small and busy space.
- PoignardAzur 6y agoAt that point you might as well make multiple ships.
- krisoft 6y agoShips don't always float on mirror flat oceans. Waves wave around them which can create more buoyant force one the ends than at the middle. This makes the middle "sag down" and the structure of the ship has to be strong enough to take the associated tension and compression. It can also happen that there is more buoyant force at the middle forcing it up while the ends are somewhat less supported. (Also known as "hogging".) The longer the ship is the stronger these forces can be.
- atatatat 6y agoLeverage, concisely.