3 ms·
If I where in their shoes, these would the multiple dimensions I'd think about when taking that decision: - legal (living in Germany I am legally only allowed
by atoav 6y ago
If I where in their shoes, these would the multiple dimensions I'd think about when taking that decision:
- legal (living in Germany I am legally only allowed to share personal data from my users with entities with whom I have a data processing contract ("Datenverarbeitungsvertrag") that specifies how they treat said data)
- practical (using a provider which people trust, will make more people switch on telemetry. People who use your software usually trust you – so it makes sense to collect telemetry yourself)
- personal (I want to know what I am running where, feels better to me)
- political (no need to feed big monopolists yet another shovel of user data. After all I make open source software because I want the world to become a better place)
- ethical (is it ethical to use a provider which could do god knows what with your users data? Users trust you, which means you have to choose providers which you can trust)
- symbolical (whom does a open source project trust with their users data? What does this in itself communicate?)
That being said this is opt-in, which leaves the decision about many of these things to the users. However to me this episode revealed something about their thinking on that specific issue – or rather the lack of it. I wouldn't have raised an eyebrow if they managed to express a good reason why they want to rely specifically on those services, why they trust them with their user data etc. What raised my eyebrows is, that they didn't think about that at all, which means the privacy of their users isn't valued as high as I would have assumed prior.
Their reaction gives some hope they learn from this.