4 ms·
I often think, especially if you have 'technical' users, better than telemetry is just making it easy to tell you things. I frequently want to be able to just
by OJFord 6y ago
I often think, especially if you have 'technical' users, better than telemetry is just making it easy to tell you things.
I frequently want to be able to just quickly say 'gah, that was annoying, I clicked that instead of that because I thought it would do that, not seeing this covered by those' or whatever, just vent a little bit, and vaguely hope it might be improved.
Not a support chat, happy to have fa follow-up email if more information needed and it's actually being worked on I suppose, but generally just a quick easy fire and forget.
Like telemetry, but where the user provides all the content; not a glorified yes/no to content you've guessed ahead of time.
- dataduck 6y agoSubnautica had this in early access: a "feedback" function where you chose either a smiley or sad face, filled in a free text field, and one click sent it to the devs. From what I hear this worked pretty well.
- tux3 6y agoYup. And Visual Studio has Send a Smile/Frown, firefox had something similar plus a "Report site issue" button that takes you to a simple web form. Those things are not super hard to put in place, and seems like a great way to get feedback that people wouldn't travel all the way to the Github issue tracker for =)
- fartcannon 6y agoVisula studio is also teeming with telemetry, though.
- synthmeat 6y agoYup, this has been best advice I've listened last year, and subsequently built on-site community chatbox. It's been amazing source of QA, feature ideas, discovering who are the real people using the service... We even hired from it. My only reservation was that it won't scale but even for userbase of 100s of thousands registered and millions of uniques a month (in the parlance of dumb telemetry), it has! I love it. To anticipate "why not just discord/telegram/whatever channel/server" - doesn't work as well, there's certain immediacy of it being purpose-built and being right there on site, that's apparently very valuable.
- MikeUt 6y ago> My only reservation was that it won't scale If you get too much feedback, can't you just ignore part of it?
- open-source-ux 6y agoTalking to users can be cheap and easy - easier today with the ease of running remote usability sessions for example. Telemetry is the lazy, unthinking approach developers typically take. They think the telemetry data tells you what users are doing and how. But it doesn't really. It does not tell you how easy, difficult or frustrating the user finds using an app. It does not tell you whether the user accomplished their goal or gave up in frustration. If anyone still thinks running a usability study (to spot usability problems in an app) is too complicated, read this 20+ year old article from Jakob Nielsen (of NNGroup): Why You Only Need to Test with 5 Users: (published in 2000) https://www.nngroup.com/articles/why-you-only-need-to-test-with-5-users/ https://www.nngroup.com/articles/why-you-only-need-to-test-w...
- lifthrasiir 6y agoTantacrul, the project lead for both MuseScore and Audacity, is a professional UI/UX designer and has once conducted a significant first-time user testing for Dorico [1], so I'm pretty sure that he already knows what you are saying. Given his latest video about Audacity [2] though, I guess that Audacity has a very diverse user base and it might be hard to do the user testing while accounting for that diversity (the article you've linked specifically mention this issue). [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-3wEC6Fj_8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-3wEC6Fj_8 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMWNvwLiXIQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMWNvwLiXIQ (includes an interview with original Audacity developers)
- fartcannon 6y agoSo he's already flubbed this once before. How many flubs until we can assume malice? Im getting a Miguel de Icaza vibe from him. Wolf in sheeps clothing.
- fartcannon 6y agoIt's even worse than I imagined. He's refusing to say who owns and how they came to own Audacity 'for fear of getting it wrong'... Something shady is going on for sure and this guy is their PR wall.
- zeckalpha 6y agoSlack provides this in a slick way through the /feedback command
- dylan604 6y agoSlack is a program where the natural interaction with the user is a text field, so a /feedback is up there with about: in the browser's address bar. The user's hands are already on the keyboard. Something like Audacity where the rare time a user enters text is primarily in a Save As dialog, so the user typically isn't in the mode of thinking about text entry and their hands may be no where near the keyboard.
- Thaxll 6y agoIt's a bad idea: 1) people never answer those 2) they're bad at telling what's happening 3) this does not scale at all Telemetry is an automated process and it's just the way to go.
- eli 6y agoThere is lots of evidence in a variety of contexts that humans are very bad at self reporting this kind of thing. You might get bug reports by soliciting feedback but you wouldn’t find out if people discovered a new feature or UI shortcut. How could they complain about a thing they didn’t know about?
- speed_spread 6y agoHence the "technical users" requirement.
- eli 6y agoIf anything I would wager “technical” users are worse at this sort of accurate usability feedback than average.
- torstenvl 6y agoIf they don't know about it, then it isn't bothering them. Why would you want to change that situation?
- capableweb 6y ago> Not a support chat, happy to have fa follow-up email if more information needed and it's actually being worked on I suppose, but generally just a quick easy fire and forget. Yes! Many indie early access games do this great, having a button in the pause menu to just send title + body + optional email with any feedback. Click the button, message sent.
- modernerd 6y agoRaycast (Mac app launcher) has a similar take: https://raycast.com/blog/feedback/ https://raycast.com/blog/feedback/ Building a “send feedback” action into their app was a smart move and I’ve used it quite a bit.