2 ms·
You have an implicit assumption that progress (in terms of absolute wealth) and equality are negatively correlated. Many of the people who argue the other way
by ZeroGravitas 6y ago
You have an implicit assumption that progress (in terms of absolute wealth) and equality are negatively correlated.
Many of the people who argue the other way disagree with that assumption.
I would say historically equality has preceded and caused growth from Magna Carta onwards, do slave states progress more than those with hired workers? Did Monarchies progress faster than constitutional monarchies or republics?
There's an interesting argument that 20th century warfare lead to socialism since you need lots of healthy trained soldiers, compared with a knight on a horse where the power is concentrated. And so the country that promises more to their soldiers can steal progress from the others. And that might reverse again with robot-driven wars.
A libertarian perspective would point to what fraction of the billionaire's wealth was accumulated from free exchange versus coercion, corruption, nepotism, extracting rents and gaming the system as a better measure of both progress and equality.
Even the sophisticated arguments for inequality generally take the view that monopolies are bad, but any attempt to regulate them will be worse because it will be gamed by the powerful to achieve the opposite and strengthen monopolies.