4 ms·
I absolutely disagree with this. Free markets just drive people to their worst tendencies, to lie, cheat, and exploit others when they have the advantage. Eve
by kelnos 6y ago
I absolutely disagree with this. Free markets just drive people to their worst tendencies, to lie, cheat, and exploit others when they have the advantage.
Even if that wasn't the case, we don't really have much in the way of free markets in the world, or even within legal jurisdictions. Regulation is everywhere, and markets are always restricted to some extent. I don't believe that's a bad thing overall (for example, I don't think we should go back to allowing unrestricted child labor, or rolling back gains in the minimum wage), though often regulation does create unnecessarily inefficient markets (e.g., many credit airline deregulation as the main driver behind today's comparatively cheap ticket prices, but deregulation has not made flying less safe).
If we were to remove all regulation and bring markets as close to full freedom as possible, I would only expect income and wealth inequality to get worse, not better.
(Also, for anyone confused, I edited my wording after the parent quoted me, but my meaning is -- hopefully -- the same. Sorry about that!)
- WalterBright 6y ago> Free markets just drive people to their worst tendencies, to lie, cheat, and exploit others when they have the advantage. I recommend reading about the Soviet economy and how it functioned. Do you really think that under socialism, people stop lying, cheating, and exploiting others? Note that lying, cheating, exploiting is illegal in a free market.
- kelnos 6y agoI don't think it's fair to suggest that anything other than our current system is the Soviet system. It makes me feel like you're arguing in bad faith to present such an obviously-false dichotomy. People of course lie, cheat, and exploit others in our current system (and of course did so in the Soviet system as well). Some of it is illegal, but unfortunately happens anyway, because people are often vulnerable and law enforcement can't help them. Much of it is legal exploitation, too, though. Making markets freer can never fix these problems, by definition. Restrictions can, though they can't and won't fix everything. I don't think my point a few steps upthread was that restrictions on markets are necessarily the answer, at least not in all cases. We need a fundamental shift in humanity's attitude toward what it means to live and prop up others so they can also live. I'm not really holding my breath for that to happen in my lifetime, though. So we need more blunt instruments like income and wealth taxes, wealth redistribution schemes that don't create more problems than they solve. It's hard to get right, and easy to get disastrously wrong, but I think it's worth trying. Our current trajectory puts us in line to eventually become a world of corporate-run states, and that's not going to be good for anybody but the shareholders and executives.
- WalterBright 6y ago> We need a fundamental shift in humanity's attitude I'm sorry, but you're not going to change human nature. Every system that has tried to deny human nature, or change it, has resulted in misery, death and disaster. Why not work with human nature? That's what free markets do. Free markets lift people out of poverty. Look what happened in the US 1800-1900. Scores of millions lifted themselves out of poverty into the middle class. Every country that tries this experiences the same result. > that's not going to be good for anybody So far, Amazon, Microsoft, Google, Netflix have improved my life in many ways. The road to Utopia is not an all-powerful government that regulates and micromanages our lives. Freedom is the road.
- sshumaker 6y agoWalter - no one is advocating for a radical 180 degree change of humanity. But even within the United States we have seen radically different approaches to inequity. Today’s economy most closely resembles the Gilded Age when it comes to concentration of wealth. At the turn of the 20th century, there was a strong nationwide response to the problems dramatic inequality caused for society - ending up with trustbusting, labor laws, unions, and higher taxes on the wealthy, culminating in the New Deal and GI bill. Those changes persisted post-WW2 when American equality was at its best and we enjoyed unprecedented growth, and really only were unwound in the Reagan administration and beyond.
- WalterBright 6y ago> we have seen radically different approaches to inequity Not once have seen changes to human nature. > unprecedented growth Are you sure about that? It was higher in the 19th century. > only were unwound in the Reagan administration Forgetting the stagflation of the 1970's and Carter's "Malaise Forever". Things got a lot better under Reagan. The Guilded Age saw massive increases in the standard of living across the board. The notion that it was some hellish period in our history is unfounded. I've read "Titan", the biography of Rockefeller. The book failed miserably at presenting any evidence whatsoever that Rockefeller got rich at the expense of the poor.
- anoncake 6y agoThere are possibilities other than unfettered market capitalism and an oppressive dictatorship that tries to plan an economy with at best primitive computers.
- WalterBright 6y ago> primitive computers Do you want your life specified and controlled by AI?
- anoncake 6y agoAnd again: There are possibilities other than AI overlords and the computers the Soviet planners had available.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's kind of up to you to enumerate those possibilities and give examples of them working.
- anoncake 6y agoEnumerate what? Computers more advanced than what existed in 1989 that didn't turn into oppressive AIs?
- WalterBright 6y ago> Enumerate what? You wrote: "There are possibilities" Enumerate the possibilities.
- anoncake 6y agoAll you do is selectively quoting me and making false dichotomies. You aren't interested in a serious discussion.