4 ms·
> ...and we know that inequality is bad for economic growth... If I look at a list of top billionaires [0] all the American ones are men who are poster childre
by roenxi 6y ago
> ...and we know that inequality is bad for economic growth...
If I look at a list of top billionaires [0] all the American ones are men who are poster children of driving enormous economic growth, and frequently a great deal of social good. Bezos, for example & picking the top, is responsible for rewiring and modernising a big chunk of the worlds logistic systems in a way that was not going to happen if he had been taxed into oblivion.
The problem is the ossification of the upper class; and that is promoted far more by governments bailouts such as seen after the '07 financial crisis, or as will probably surface when people have time to go over what actually happened in the emergency COVID spending. Protecting idiots while they are in charge of the financial system is a much bigger drag on growth than the existence of wealthy people.
Now if we were to talk about stopping those sort of welfare-for-wealthy-people policies then I'm sure we all agree. But taxes are a different policy, they imply we keep going with the welfare and then guess where it landed to try and take it back. I don't buy that the democratic process can handle that level of precision.
Trying to tax billionaires out of existence while the existing ones enjoy a great deal of government support for the financial status quo is exactly the sort of kick-out-the-ladder behaviour the article would lead us to predict for people in quadrant 4 of the article's graph (which is where you're describing them). I'll even go as far as guessing they probably support policies that bring the US into line with Europe - because that is what the article would predict.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#202...
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoBezos is also responsible for creating a new precariat who can only do their jobs by pissing into bottles because they aren't allowed the basic humanity to look after their needs. If you're going to try to persuade me this is a good thing and not a Hobbesian nightmare, you're not going to succeed. This isn't just about taxes. This is about humanism vs financial authoritarianism. It's also about the fact that the world was both more stable and more obviously prosperous when tax rates were much higher. Economies are supposed to be prosperity factories for everyone to enjoy, and not just billionaire factories for a few extremely privileged individuals whose wealth exists because they've placed unacceptable financial and personal burdens on the people who work for them.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoBezos? The world would not be the poorer or have missed out one bit if he hadn’t created Amazon.
- ObserverNeutral 6y agoSomebody else would have created it. The argument around wealth taxes is that we tax lottery winnings, hence we should tax this sort of things. Bill Gates was a fanboy of a company called Digital Equipment which he predicted would be the next big thing. Stuff went the other way for them and Microsoft emerged instead. There is very little agency in these massive net worth stashes People who are smart already know this. Doge developers refute to bow down and genuflect to Musk even though his net worth is 1,000,000 times theirs. Andy Jassy not like he'd not confront and get in heated arguments with Bezos even though his net worth is 300x his own. It's people who buy into the propaganda and Republicans who elevate these people as they were divine beings. They are just smart people who got outsized returns because of luck....a wealth tax would just mimic the mechanism of taxes on lottery winnings
- nickpp 6y agoThe very success of Amazon is proof that the world is better with it than without it: Amazon did not take out money by force. We, the customers, have made it successful by rewarding it with our business every time it won it in our minds over its competitors. Every extra cent of Amazon profit comes from a happy customer. Happy customers == better world. In a world full of competition and alternatives, in a world where the low price is far from being the only differentiating factor, Amazon is winning due to innovation, better customer service and choice, massive, almost infinite, choice.
- md_ 6y agoI’ll avoid taking an absolute position on Amazon—socially beneficial or not—but I do take issue with your argument: only by the most stunted measures of “better” is turning a profit sufficient or even necessary to show someone “makes the world better.”