5 ms·
What amuses me in all these articles is that they never acknowledge that most humans are incapable of full level five driving. There are a ton of situations wh
by jedberg 6y ago
What amuses me in all these articles is that they never acknowledge that most humans are incapable of full level five driving.
There are a ton of situations where humans fail at driving too. Like white out snow or heavy rain and fog. Or confusing cones. :)
- kens 6y agoThere's a recent video of drivers encountering a new traffic circle and going wildly wrong. Multiple drivers pull into the left lane (i.e. oncoming traffic) and go around the circle the wrong way. Imagine the outrage if a self-driving car behaved like the drivers in the video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDaQZUzJCNM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bDaQZUzJCNM
- ec109685 6y agoBut when you don’t allow drivers to take over, you need be perfect in all situations or your end up in this type of traffic circle all the time (or have to limit coverage are severely).
- lsh123 6y agoYet in that video you don’t see a single crash or collision! Yes the situation is confusing for drivers but they manage to figure out how to get out of it without damages or delays even if they do it against “the plan”.
- toast0 6y agoSure, that's because traffic circles are terrible. The truck with the long trailer likely took the left turn to avoid it, possibly because clearance around the circle wasn't obvious (there's another truck with a shorter trailer that barely makes it around) and then people behind it followed. The local traffic engineering folks around where I live are gung-ho on traffic circles, but I've yet to see one in the US where a traffic signal wouldn't have been a better investment.
- katbyte 6y agoWhy do you think traffic lights are better? I like not having to wait on a red for an empty street or have to stop for stop signs at intersections. They are better and safer in every way and stats back that up (not to mention better for the environment and your car maintenance bills) https://youtu.be/AqcyRxZJCXc https://youtu.be/AqcyRxZJCXc
- toast0 6y ago> I like not having to wait on a red for an empty street or have to stop for stop signs at intersections. Me too; but traffic signals are more than capable of detecting empty streets and oncoming traffic and changing lights to green before you get to the intersection. > They are better and safer in every way and stats back that up (not to mention better for the environment and your car maintenance bills) Traffic circles are tolerable with low traffic, but when traffic increases, especially if the traffic is asymmetric, it's possible for some directions to be blocked for a long time, and there's no fairness mechanism. Because speeds in traffic circles are slower than in signaled intersections with a green, it takes longer for the backlog to clear the intersection. And, while there's still throughput when one entrance dominates and blocks other entrances, if one exit is blocked, it can block the whole intersection and there's zero throughput; in a signaled intersection, other exits can usually still be used even if one is jammed. Slowing for a roundabout when I wouldn't need to slow for a traffic signal that would likely turn green for me is bad for the environment. Extra miles driven from longer paths, and wear on tires from taking a circular path instead of a straight path is bad for the environment and my maintenance bills. They use more space than a signaled intersection, and may displace trees or impact waterways and drainage. It's hard to look for pedestrians crossing from the right while also looking for a space in traffic from the left. Navigating them on bicycles can be tricky too, as there are a lot of crossovers.
- angry_octet 6y agoFrankly, you can't have driven in places that use roundabouts much, because in practice these are not problems. Asymmetric flow isn't a problem if there are occasional vehicles which force the dominant flow to give way. In rare situations it is beneficial to put a traffic light on the dominant flow entrance to break it up. Blocked exits are rarely a problem for other exits on multilane roundabouts, and rarely more of a problem that blocking the box on an intersection with lights -- it's all about the attitude of drivers. "Wear in tired from taking a circular path" -- is this supposed to be satire?
- manigandham 6y agoMachine learning has probably closed most of the gap in pattern matching the scene but humans are still magnitudes better at predicting intentions and communicating instantly with the other drivers with little more than a glance. This is why chaotic traffic situations without lane markings or signals can still move fluidly without crashes. Autonomous vehicles would be at a standstill in that situation.
- DrScump 6y agoWhen drivers screw up, they face expensive consequences, so they have a substantial incentive to not screw up, at least.
- volkl48 6y agoSnow is a fun condition, because it is a time when it may be impossible to drive to the letter of the law, but perfectly practical to drive by not following it. It's going to be interesting to me how you work out: "It's legally required to use the left turn lane, but since it's not plowed out well enough everyone is turning from the travel lane instead and this is temporarily acceptable to both other drivers and any law enforcement"
- cycomanic 6y agoBut most of the drivers were perfectly fine with the cones and driving past it with no issues. The thing is if one waymo car was confused by the cones likely all waymo cars would be. I can only imagine the chaos ensuing if another one or two waymo taxis would have arrived at the same location. Would they have gotten stuck behind each other. Simultaneously trying to desperately call for help and go around each other?
- jjav 6y ago> What amuses me in all these articles is that they never acknowledge that most humans are incapable of full level five driving. Since billions of people are driving unassisted every day, that's clearly not true.
- mmis1000 6y agoHuman may violate known rules(or even laws) temporarily if all known legal solution can't get itself out of the problem. But AI nowadays don't do (or the designer of AI aren't allowed to? Is that even legal to do?). And besides that. If such decision actually cause injury eventually, who should response for that? The AI designer? The car company? The AI itself? The car owner? We still don't have a definitive answer for that yet.