13 ms·
Eh, I can’t be bothered to care. Cellebrite hoards 0-days so they can use them to hack phones. They know about exploitable vulnerabilities but aren’t saying any
by kstrauser 6y ago
Eh, I can’t be bothered to care. Cellebrite hoards 0-days so they can use them to hack phones. They know about exploitable vulnerabilities but aren’t saying anything about them because they profit from insecurity. Thing is, just because Cellebrite knows about a thing doesn’t mean, say, China’s CCP or the Russian mafia or anyone else doesn’t also know about that thing. You and I are less safe just because Cellebrite wants to profit off of those vulnerabilities.
I just can’t work up the ability to sympathize with Cellebrite. The law may have something to say about Moxie’s writing, but in my opinion he has the clear ethical upper ground in this argument.
- markus_zhang 6y agoIs there a way to further damage its profitability and force it to release 0-day in a legal way?
- kstrauser 6y agoIf/when I am appointed Lord Emperor, I would absolutely enforce the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act against the officers of such companies. Unless an audit could prove that every single one of their customers was a legitimate law enforcement organization, I’d go with the default assumption that they’re black hat hackers who happen to have a couple of legal sales. Let them prove otherwise. Note that this is one of many, many reasons it’s unlikely that I’ll ever be appointed Lord Emperor.
- lsh123 6y agoThe fact that Signal got their hands on a copy of the Cellebrite product makes “let them prove otherwise” disclaimer a moot point ;)
- salawat 6y agoNot necessarily. That could have been an unused loaner from an anonymous law enforcement quartermaster who had a moment of conscience. Cellebrite, as I recall hearing (Or was it StingRay?) have pretty strict non-disclosure license terms; I doubt Cellebrite knowingly sold one to Moxie.
- shoto_io 6y agoI’m sure they have some sort of a business case lying around somewhere. So they can put a price tag on each 0-day. If they can't be forced, maybe they can be paid.
- nearbuy 6y agoYou're not supposed to sympathize with Cellebrite, according to the article. > If you work at Cellebrite, on the other hand: get down off your high horse, stop it with the “we’re the good guys” shtick, quit selling to authoritarian governments, and for god’s sake, fix your shit. > Giving defense attorneys more ammo to push back harder against the use of Cellebrite devices against their clients is Good and Right and Just. The general point that Moxie made — Cellebrite’s tools are buggy A.F. and can be exploited in ways that undermine the reliability of their reports and extractions as evidence, which is the entire point of their existence — is actually more important than the specifics of this exploit You're kind of missing the point of the article. The article agrees with you that Signal's hack was a net positive and Cellebrite is not a good company.
- kstrauser 6y agoI saw those parts, but my overall impression was that the author thought Signal was foolish to write up their adventure and they shouldn’t have done it (while conceding that Cellebrite aren’t angels). I also disagree with the notion that it’s good that Cellebrite exists because without them we’d have stronger anti-encryption laws. That’s hypothetical and all we know is what we have today. I’m not thrilled that someone is peeing on my basement carpet instead of peeing in my living room; I’d rather not have someone peeing on any of my rugs.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI’m not reading the article as a criticism of the work Signal has done, but their “lol u got pwned” way of announcing it — in particular, their coy threat about exploiting the vulnerability. Specifically: - The threat is likelier to annoy judges than garner sympathy - Following through on it is probably illegal - Worse, following through could put their users in legal (and/or physical) jeopardy - More generally, Signal should consult with lawyers before doing things like this
- indigochill 6y ago> Following through on it is probably illegal I'm curious how? If they announce publicly that they will place files on devices that may exploit a publicly announced vulnerability in Cellebrite, then it's Cellebrite's prerogative to fix the vulnerability. If they knowingly ignore a publicly disclosed risk, then they have only themselves to blame.
- spoonjim 6y agoIf Cellebrite was disclosing these vulns when they found them, there would be no business, thus no Cellebrite, thus they wouldn’t have found them. “Destroy Cellebrite” is a possible outcome but “Have Cellebrite release 0days when they find them” isn’t.
- kstrauser 6y agoTheir terrible business model isn’t my concern. And “keep security vulnerabilities secret and hope that we’re the only ones who can use them” is, indeed, terrible.
- spoonjim 6y agoRight, so your beef with Cellebrite is that they exist (fair) not that they hoard 0days (which is a necessary condition for them to exist).
- Kim_Bruning 6y agoI disagree with your re-casting of the parent's statement. I believe the parent said that they are in fact opposed to Cellebrite's hoarding of 0-days.
- kstrauser 6y agoI’m not sure how you came up with that incorrect conclusion.
- ric2b 6y agoAny 0-days they find can be used on already confiscated devices even if they report them and the manufacturer issues a fix, so their business could in theory still work.