6 ms·
I gotta say, those cones are awful. They marked off a lane, but used VERY few cones to do it, and from the side street the car is on it's not at all clear that
by ajross 6y ago
I gotta say, those cones are awful. They marked off a lane, but used VERY few cones to do it, and from the side street the car is on it's not at all clear that it's the right lane that's been closed.
This is the kind of situation that confuses new human drivers too. Interpreting it basically requires that you have a model in your head of what cones are used for and the ability to guess that the traffic approaching from the left in only one lane indicates that the traffic to the right must use the left lane.
I'd be very curious if this conework was even legal. If you want to guide left-turning vehicles around the right lane you need to put something IN FRONT of the lane you closed. And that applies to side streets too, I'm almost sure.
Watch /r/idiotsincars for a bit, you'll see people misidentify this kind of situation all the time.
Frankly what the car did, stopping and calling for help, is the right move. A new human driver would almost certainly have just pulled out into the wrong lane.
- cddotdotslash 6y agoThey may be confusing, but I highly doubt a human driver would pull to the middle of the road and stop for 5+ minutes as drivers honked and drove around. Honestly, if it had just stayed on the side street, I wouldn't be so critical, but the fact that even after an assistance team was dispatched, the car pulled into the main highway and then immediately stopped would have frightened me enough to get out of the car and wait on the sidewalk. You can also see a moment where the car starts to pull out into traffic as another car is passing it and then immediately slams on the brakes.
- chris_wot 6y agoI seriously think that if the car is about to take off by itself unexpected, then it would be a bad idea to get out of it.
- loopz 6y agoIf control by human is so poor, this is a huge murder vehicle. Sure the systems are improving, but programmers should see all sorts of problems with this that can't be mitigated.
- ajross 6y ago> If [... then] this is a huge murder vehicle Stop it. Waymo vehicles (Tesla autonomy too, FWIW) are extremely safe, that is just an experimental fact. The circumstance in question here has nothing to do with safety, really. The bug is that it caused a traffic obstruction while the (human) operators attempted to get the car oriented. Hyperbolizing the circumstances is really not appropriate. This was not a safety situation, really, at any point.
- carapace 6y agoYou stop it. They are testing huge, fast robots in public streets. It's messed up. There's a joke among cyclists: "If you want to get away with killing someone just be sure that you're driving a car and they're riding a bike." We could make a similar joke about these killer robot cars. "If you want to test killer robots on the public just make sure they are shaped like cars." (And if you need to, you can throw in a "safety driver" as a sort of moral crumple zone to deflect the blame when your robot kills e.g. Elaine Herzberg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Elaine_Herzberg#Aftermath https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Elaine_Herzberg#After... ) - - - - We could build self-driving golf carts (slow, light, not so capable of killing) and work up to cars, eh? We don't have to go straight to fast heavy cars, eh?
- loopz 6y agoChill. It should just give pause for thought, not stop thought.
- zitterbewegung 6y agoI get confused about construction sites that are much well laid out than this. I think that I would have panicked and slowed down or actually drive in the wrong side of the cones. I acknowledge that it is weird that the remote assistance team can't remotely stop the vehicle and I agree that it should have behaved differently but maybe there is some kind of engineering reason or just a glitch. It seems to recalculate what to do three times.
- hermitdev 6y agoThere was a cone in the middle of the blocked off (right-hand) lane at the turn where it initially got stuck. Seems maybe the spacing between the cones was more cause for the confusion?
- ec109685 6y agoA human would have seen what all the other cars were doing, and emulated that eventually, even if the construction was poorly marked. It was incredible to watch how Waymo was able to plot the huge number of cars accurately around the vehicle throughout the drive. But as soon as something creative was required, it all fell apart. I still remember a talk where someone from the original DARPA challenge was recounting an episode where two autonomous cars arrived at an intersection precisely at the same time. They deadlocked because they were waiting for each other to go. A programmer added jitter to work around that situation, but it is one of those things humans innately would figure out.
- raverbashing 6y ago> A human would have seen what all the other cars were doing, and emulated that eventually, even if the construction was poorly marked. I have a hunch that 90% of self-driving could be solved like that, but then there's always that 10% of situations where there's nobody in front or someone who doesn't know what they're doing. But yes it would be a good heuristic.
- mannykannot 6y agoUntil, in this case, the car in front made a left turn.
- angry_octet 6y agoBut it would still have escaped the deadlock it was in.
- mannykannot 6y agoIn this case, if it followed the car ahead through a left turn, then that would be so, but if it did not, and it were still in the section of road restricted by the cones, it would have become stuck again, just as it did after it made the initial turn onto the restricted road. The thing is, the strategy of 'follow other traffic' needs exit rules, and while it is relatively straightforward to begin the strategy when stuck, deciding when to abandon it is less clear-cut. Did the left-turning vehicle do so because this was the correct way to deal with the problem, or did it have a different goal?
- dawnerd 6y agoThey did something similar by my house on a pretty lightly travelled road and it was confusing as hell. People were using both sides of the cones and realizing too late they were in the wrong side.
- hawthornio 6y agoI agree. In my town roadwork on a four lane road caused both lanes to be diverted into two sparsely-coned lanes on one side of the road, and some human drivers started driving in the wrong lane into what would be opposing traffic.
- manigandham 6y agoIt's perfectly clear. There are 2 cones and a sign set diagonally across the lane: https://i.imgur.com/8ViGpLP.png https://i.imgur.com/8ViGpLP.png You cannot drive into that lane without hitting those cones. It's hard to see from the camera angle in the backseat but a driver in the front would definitely understand that the lane is blocked.
- babesh 6y agoThe first cone was placed a few feet to the right of the lane divider. That and that the next cone was on the divider indicated that the right lane was closed. I wonder if the traffic on the left lane somehow shifted the code/network into favoring that it was only the right lane that was closed. That may have gotten it moving after the first hang up. However, once it turned into the left lane and passed the first cone (which was offset to the right of the divider), it saw the second cone placed in the center and forgot that it was the right lane that was closed. I think it pulled over because it thought that both lanes were closed or did not know which one was closed. It’s modeling of a sequence of cones closing lanes and retention of that model seems inadequate.
- DrScump 6y agoI'd be very curious if this conework was even legal It doesn't matter if it's legal. It is not code compliant. Neither is "double parking". But it happens beyond the control of mere mortal drivers, and it must be maneuvered through safely when it happens. It's like kids dashing into the street -- it's not legal, yet you aren't empowered to simply hit them if it can be avoided. Here in California, it happens all the time. There was a half block of EL Camino Real in Sunnyvale this afternoon that was simply coned off with no signage and no warning by construction people working on a new building. I called it in to Sunnyvale DPS, and they were totally unaware of it. There were two near-collisions in the 45 seconds I was within view. You have day laborers with no clue about traffic safety and ignorant of context given hand signs and no instructions, let alone legal standards. Even if you place cones and signage perfectly per code, you still have to deal with signs or cones being knocked out of position or out of view.
- markvdb 6y agoYou may want to look at this from a wider angle. Obviously the driving logic should handle this properly. But... it also has the potential of production testing road infrastructure automatically. Once it's good enough obviously. P.S. I hope similar tech will be built for other types of road use, so cars alone don't shape our roads even more.
- ajross 6y ago> I called it in to Sunnyvale DPS, and they were totally unaware of it. There were two near-collisions in the 45 seconds I was within view. Seems like if those confused drivers had merely stopped where they were, safety would have been improved! Again, the question isn't whether or not automation technology can be confused by bad signage, we know it can. Nor is there a question that humans can be confused by the same situation. The question is, when faced with situations like this, we can trust the automation to operate safely. And it seems like Waymo passed the test. It's true the externalities are different for the different technologies though. If you put down bad cones currently, you raise the likelihood of an accident. If you mark your lane badly in the era of automated vehicles, you cause a traffic jam. I know which I'd prefer.
- jjav 6y ago> If you want to guide left-turning vehicles around the right lane you need to put something IN FRONT of the lane you closed. The important point is that a human driver (as all the human drivers in the video) has no trouble. A lot of driving is not by the book, but humans coordinate and go with the flow. The software in these cars breaks down as soon as anything unexpected happens.
- mannykannot 6y agoI second DrScump's point, but it is also a fact that the car did recognize that the lane was a no-go area, at least in its immediate vicinity. From the video, the fragility revealed here seems to be that the system driving the car is attemptng to follow the route from the planning system very explcitly, down to which lane to use, and there seems to have been no effective way to get that plan revised in the face of the problem. In general, I would imagine that following a route plan to the lane level of detail is important; I can see that it would be when approaching a turn, for example. Also, when the car first encounters the cones, it only recognizes that the lane is blocked for a short distance: after that, each cone encountered seems to be a separate problem. Humans easily generalize a line of cones to a blocked lane and modify their plans accordingly, but we do not have AGI yet.
- quantified 6y agoLovely coincidence that this is in the news feed too just now: [http://files.meetup.com/119715/WhyHeideggerianAIFailed.pdf http://files.meetup.com/119715/WhyHeideggerianAIFailed.pdf]
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoDirect link to relevant part of video: https://youtu.be/zdKCQKBvH-A?t=1008 https://youtu.be/zdKCQKBvH-A?t=1008