3 ms·
If that were the case, why doesn’t the same principle apply to Cellebrite? After all, they exploit vulnerabilities in lots of software to deliver their own serv
by vlovich123 6y ago
If that were the case, why doesn’t the same principle apply to Cellebrite? After all, they exploit vulnerabilities in lots of software to deliver their own services and there’s no indication they share their work with the vendors.
- vxNsr 6y agoBecause they don’t plant boobytraps in their wake. Signal isn’t saying “we’re just hacking into property we have a legal right to access” (which is what LE is doing in the US) they’re essentially saying “we’re gonna hack and damage government property and police evidence”
- ambicapter 6y agoSure, that's what the article is claiming, but I don't see how Cellebrite is "government" or "police".
- nearbuy 6y agoCellebrite, the company, wouldn't be the one getting hacked. It's the police agencies' equipment that could potentially get hacked.
- alisonkisk 6y agoYou're asking why lawful search and seizure is OK but obstruction of justice is not. Intent matters in the law.
- sneak 6y agoYou're going to have a long way to go to claim that Signal publishing files onto hundreds or thousands of devices is obstruction of justice. The law doesn't look kindly on prior restraint.
- dTal 6y agoCellebrite isn't definitionally lawful. It's a private company that sells to other private entities that may or may not choose to use their software lawfully. I don't think they (should) get a pass just because some of their clients happen to be LEO.
- PeterisP 6y agoThe proper perspective is not to look at "exploiting Cellebrite's software" an "exploiting Signal's software" but to look at who has the lawful possession of specific devices that software is running on. It's not a crime to exploit vulnerabilities in software developed by someone else, it's a crime to exploit vulnerabilities to do things on systems owned/run by others. A LE officer with a proper warrant running Cellebrite extraction tools on your phone has full rights to execute exploits on your phone. On the other hand, the phone's owner or Signal has no right to execute exploits on that officers' computer with Cellebrite tools. They can get their own computer with Cellebrite tools (as Signal did) and exploit vulnerabilities there as much as they want (as Signal did), and not tell the vendor the details (as Signal did), that's all legal, but deploying an exploit on phones with the intent that it might get executed on someone else's machine is illegal.