4 ms·
>screams of these right to repair folks when apple alerts the user to a non-apple battery ring pretty damn hollow you might be oblivious to the fact this Apple
by rasz 6y ago
>screams of these right to repair folks when apple alerts the user to a non-apple battery ring pretty damn hollow
you might be oblivious to the fact this Apple Alert is not about fake battery - it also pops up if you insert Genuine battery from another brand new iphone. Battery alert is about Control over the phone user believes to own.
- zepto 6y ago> it also pops up if you insert Genuine battery from another brand new iphone. It’s almost always going to be triggered by a replacement battery of unknown origin and almost never by someone taking a battery from a brand new iPhone, so this is an obvious red herring.
- rasz 6y ago> almost never by someone taking a battery from a brand new iPhone This is incorrect. There is no almost, all original Apple brand new batteries will trigger scareware until battery is crypto paired with the phone using RepairCal. Oh, and you cant see battery cycle count to be sure you got a good battery, apps showing cycle count were removed from app store for some absolutely coincidental and unrelated reason.
- zepto 6y ago> This is incorrect. Not at all. It will almost never happen because it’s not something people generally do. It’s a meaningless red herring.
- rasz 6y agoYes, just like farmers never self service modern John Deere tractors, that just "isnt something people generally do". Talking about self service is a meaningless red herring, clearly!
- zepto 6y agoThat’s not an analogy. We’re not talking about self service - we’re talking about the red herring of taking batteries from new iPhones to put them in old ones. That isn’t an example of “self service”. It isn’t something people do. If you are doing self service, nothing stops you from ignoring the warning if you know what you are doing.
- parineum 6y agoIt would have been trivial for Apple to sign the batteries as genuine instead they tie it to a specific serial number. The level of effort to those two solutions is very similar. The decision of which to do is a business decision.
- zepto 6y agoThe signature would just be cloned.
- parineum 6y agoAre you familiar with private keys?
- drdeca 6y agoElaborate. What is preventing copying the same exact message, with the same exact signature? If the message is the same, the signature should still be valid for the message, even if one cannot produce a valid signature for any other message. Is there a reason the same message wouldn’t work?
- zepto 6y agoYes. Because there is nothing unique about batteries, there is no way to defend against a replay attack in this scenario.
- whoknowswhat11 6y agoAre folks here just so anti-apple that they make up these "easy" solutions (which of course are totally bogus)? Please explain how private keys resolve this issue (knowing that scammers will be a) getting access to lots of existing dying batteries and b) may even buy and return new phones to pull out their genuine batteries.
- zepto 6y ago> Are folks here just so anti-apple that they make up these "easy" solutions I think it’s the other way around. People in general underestimate how complex technical solutions actually are, and this leads to attributing malice to those who appear to be withholding those simple solutions. In many ways it’s a manifestation of the ‘fundamental attribution error’: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error I don’t think this is specific to Apple, it’s just a general cognitive bias.
- whoknowswhat11 6y agoYou might be oblivious and totally clueless that a chip can be re-used, it will be. Chips from used apple phone batteries will be slapped onto the bogus batteries and installed. I mean - seriously, how do you think half the printer ink folks defeat the DRM there? Why do they want your old (original) cartridges? Really depressing to see the level of discourse here on HN - and not understanding how if it can be scammed it will be. Seriously, people will take apple phones, pull and replace a part like a battery and return it even.
- rasz 6y agoThat would mean crypto signing battery to cpu is useless, so why do it? I dont give a flying duck about Apple being scammed by someone returning dummy phone with fake parts. Its in Apple interest to inspect what they refund. I do however care about sustainable repairable hardware. I dont want disposable future Apple is selling us on. New macbooks are just like their phones, consumable good calculated to fail in max 3 years once you run out of SSD cycles.