4 ms·
This is why Broadcom chips come with proprietary blobs: the FCC and corresponding regulatory bodies elsewhere would never approve them if they had open source f
by bitwize 6y ago
This is why Broadcom chips come with proprietary blobs: the FCC and corresponding regulatory bodies elsewhere would never approve them if they had open source firmware or were fully documented.
- vineyardmike 6y agoSource? This seems unlikely considering the existence of legal SDR. Also proprietary blobs seem like a whole separate thing that companies would do to protect IP.
- generalizations 6y agoCan confirm. Look at the FCC regulations for selling rf-emitting devices. The seller has to show that the device will only emit at the specified frequencies and power. When it's consumer-facing, like a wifi router, one way to do that when the hardware itself is technically capable of more, is to lock down the firmware. The downvotes on gp are misinformed.
- monocasa 6y agoThese chips and their closed blobs are older than the relevant FCC regulation.
- aksss 6y agoHasn’t the relevant fcc regulation (concerning signal strength and use) been around since the eighties at least?
- monocasa 6y agoIt was a 2015 ruling that can be seen as not allowing user modifiable firmware for transmitter hardware. https://www.wired.com/2016/03/way-go-fcc-now-manufacturers-locking-routers/ https://www.wired.com/2016/03/way-go-fcc-now-manufacturers-l...
- grishka 6y agoI've seen this same argument about cellular modems too, and that, too, has never prevented people from reverse engineering them.
- BelenusMordred 6y agoIn a very limited set of mobile baseband radio chips, it's a massive undertaking. All that's around is OsmocomBB(A few 3G chipsets) and FreeCalypso(One discontinued Texas Instruments 2G chip), both of which I believe were built off leaked code. The main developer behind FreeCalypso has found a Chinese supplier still producing the TI chips though, so it lives on.
- fragileone 6y agoDo you know anything about the future open-source modems? Most promising project I've seen is working on the PinePhone modem https://linuxsmartphones.com/hackers-develop-open-source-firmware-for-the-pinephone-modem-use-it-to-make-phone-calls/ https://linuxsmartphones.com/hackers-develop-open-source-fir...