2 ms·
Can we call it free choice if it's based on a lie? Whether meatspace or in-app, the astrologists aren't saying, "come here to receive generic life advice based
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Can we call it free choice if it's based on a lie?
Whether meatspace or in-app, the astrologists aren't saying, "come here to receive generic life advice based on (at best) educated guesses about you or (at worst) output of a random number generator". No, they're promising reliable advice, and back it with absurd "explanations". It's not much different than any other kind of fraud - it only survives because it's been an established practice since way before science allowed us to call bullshit on it.
(I don't buy the usual argument to grant it plausible deniability: that their customers know they're being lied to, and consider this entertainment. I've not heard of an astrologist checking that their customers realize they're participating in a LARP.)
And since you mentioned gambling: it's not all free choice either. There's a spectrum there. Some people can handle it responsibly as a form of entertainment. Other people, arguably most people, are at risk of getting hooked and losing their ability to freely choose whether to play or not.
Putting the general question of free will aside, it's inaccurate to consider people as agents who mostly make informed choices and occasionally let their emotions get the best of them. On the contrary, humans mostly do things on autopilot, and occasionally find enough power of will to make a choice and override their default behavior.
- sneak 6y ago> Can we call it free choice if it's based on a lie? Yes, as humans have to determine the truth in all things they engage with themselves. Religion, association, food, work, investment... we leave the risk assessment to the person whose money is on the line. > And since you mentioned gambling: it's not all free choice either. There's a spectrum there. Some people can handle it responsibly as a form of entertainment. Other people, arguably most people, are at risk of getting hooked and losing their ability to freely choose whether to play or not. And yet we allow it, because they risk no one but themselves. Some of those people who get "hooked" also, by their own free will, later stop gambling, so I am skeptical of your "some people aren't exercising a choice" dichotomy.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Yes, as humans have to determine the truth in all things they engage with themselves. Religion, association, food, work, investment... we leave the risk assessment to the person whose money is on the line. Except when we don't, because it doesn't scale. Attacker vs. Defender problem. A big chunk of regulation - like the parts that define what is fraud, or ones concerned with product safety - are a recognition of the fact that people cannot, in practice, assess trustworthiness of things they engage themselves in. They'd spend all their time doing only that, and never achieving anything. Society needs high level of baseline trust to be maintained just to function. > And yet we allow it, because they risk no one but themselves. We actually limit it strongly, precisely because it hurts a lot of people other than the players. Gambling addiction is a problem whose main victims are the families of the addicted. It's a type of problem similar to alcoholism - its spread destroys communities and increases poverty. And so games of chance are a highly regulated space.