5 ms·
Facebook’s Secret Rules on Word “Zionist” Impede Criticism of Israel
- mikewarot 6y agoNot surprising, considering how any mention of covid, no matter how incidental, flags a post with fact-checking. Every single post there is likely put through sentiment analysis and sent off to any number of pipelines if found to warrant further attention. It's the world we live in, not the one I grew up in. We could easily put the genie back in the bottle by hosting all this stuff ourselves, and encrypting it before sending it off to our friends, and using secure operating systems. However, the social inertia means that will never happen en masse.
- zpeti 6y agoIt just depends on the extent of it and the scale. Piss enough people off enough, and they will want to move. I think we are close personally. It doesn’t take that much for a group of conservative people to move somewhere else if everyone is pissed. They just need another platform.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThe conservatives keep on moving from /r/the_donald to Voat to Gab to Parler. It is just that they end up creating such a cesspool of hate and misinformation that nobody wants to do business with that platform, whether it be infrastructure, payment processors, or advertisers. That makes it unviable in the long term.
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe question is, do “conservative people” only want other conservative people as an audience? While there are plenty of competent conservatives, there also seem to be a lot of people whose primary motive in posting on Facebook is to “trigger the libs” and that doesn’t happen without “libs” to “trigger”
- TheAdamAndChe 6y agoLook at Twitter, you see a similar sentiment on the other side. In the television industry, you've seen a massive segmentation in the news and TV channels over the years. 40 years ago, there were only a few news channels that tried to target the largest demographics possible. Because of that, they largely stayed neutral. However, market competition and other forces have led to a separation between left- and right-leaning news channels. If given the choice, people avoid information that doesn't align with their worldview. Fast forward to now. Social media companies are anything but unbiased, enforcing a mentality of "tolerance," multiculturalism, and cultural relativism. In such an environment, pushback from people who disagree makes a lot of sense, though it isn't good.
- grishka 6y agoFederation is a good enough solution to this problem. End-to-end encryption requires key management, which is a hassle most people would rather avoid.
- shadowmore 6y agoThis back-and-forth will never end until there's government regulation that tells the creators of digital communication platforms, in no uncertain terms, "You do not get to control the content on the platform you have built, because the platform exists to serve the people of this country, and this country has law enforcement agencies whose job it is to police any illegal communication." As long as corporations have the right to control what people say just because it's on their servers, and as long as they don't feel threatened by the state, this problem will persist.
- mschuster91 6y agoNo country has the capacity to have law enforcement go on active patrols in the digital space, many fail even to intervene when they're called in. Platforms need to have some ability to moderate themselves, the things that are sorely lacking is due process in front of an actual court on one side, and some form of international agreement on how to deal with freedom of speech on the other side. Just take Nazi symbols: it's perfectly legal in the US to fly a Swastika flag on your home, to take a picture of that and to post it on Twitter. In Germany, all three of these acts would be illegal per §86a StGB (with the exception if one was a journalist and tweeted that photo to publicly document this). In other countries, e.g. Russia, flying the rainbow flag may be illegal - something that is perfectly legal and mainstream in Western countries. Porn is another thing: what is legal in the US under freedom of speech / art, may be illegal in Muslim countries. Not to mention that while porn may be legal in the US, advertisers still don't really want to have their brand appear next to fetish porn. Should Twitter now ban such accounts worldwide, restrict the availability of the content to certain jurisdictions, should it do nothing? These are highly relevant problems, which we need to solve as societies of this world.
- antiethnostate 6y agoAlright. So, if a country says "you cannot criticize anyone who promotes exclusionary ethnostates", or even "you cannot criticize anyone who promotes exclusionary Jewish ethnostates in particular", then Facebook should ban that content on behalf of the exclusionary ethnostate supporters. Otherwise, allow criticism of exclusionary ethnostates. White supremacy and zionism are two sides of the same coin—both feed off each other, justify each other, complement each other.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThe distinction between when Zionist is acceptable is bizarre. If someone acts on the ideology, you can't criticize them but if they don't act it's fine? I'd guess that their excuse would be that only Israeli's could be responsible for the forced expulsion of Palestinians while anyone can be a Zionist but it just seems backwards to me.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI'm a pretty staunch critic of Israel's actions overall, but I shy away from using the word Zionist, because I think it's too bound up and associated with the language used by some serious anti-Semites. And no, I don't think criticizing Israel is anti-Semitic, but anti-Semitism is still out there (and growing again it seems), and often starts with legitimate criticism of Israel and then crosses lines. I don't really want to make fellow company with some of the people who make a point of using the word as their focal point of attack. It's far too easy to lose nuance in this discussion.
- chongli 6y agoYeah. The word has taken on the connotations of a slur. Serious, charitable, good-faith critics, of any government (or any group, for that matter), should avoid slurs like the plague. Stick with criticizing policies. The government of Israel should be criticized but that has nothing to do with who they are, only what they do.
- renjimen 6y agoThis is a good point. The dictionary contains definitions but misses social context, which changes over time. Just like the language we use for disability, racial identity, or any other emotionally charged subject.
- speeder 6y agoAlthough I have a great-grandparents that were ethnic hebrews... I must say that I am not surprised anti-semitism is growing, considering many people now considered "villains" for whatever reason ARE jewish. The average human is a simple creature and quickly create some heuristics of the kind: "if a bunch of people from certain group is evil, then the whole group is evil". Doesn't help that it is very hard to find neutral ground too, for example Austria was supposed to be the neutral ground for negotiations between Iran and US in the Iran vs Israel nuke conflict, then they went ahead and hoisted Israeli flags. Iran now is sending their delegation home basically.
- tuyguntn 6y agoI always wonder why Israel gets so much exceptionally good support from USA. You can't boycott made in Israel product, Israel is always considered as defending (doesn't matter if root cause in specific cases were Israel) even though it has superior military advantage comparing to tiny Palestine, who uses toy like rockets, don't get me wrong, I am making an assumption based on damage their rockets made on the streets of Israel. Anything related to Zionism, Nazi or some conspiracy theories against Israel is prohibited, but using words like Islamic extremist or Muslim terrorist are fine (even though it hurts another 1B Muslim population). Same applies to what Twitter did to pro-Trump articles/tweets. Not saying Trump is good or bad, but some people had opinion pro-Biden, others pro-Trump, but Biden got unfair advantage when Twitter started censoring pro-Trump articles. I think this double standard is going to hurt next generations, by silencing alternative ideas/opinions. All opinions should be equal, unless it promotes danger to human life.
- sm0ss117 6y agoThere's a lot going on but the basic reasons are: Evangelical white Christians think the existence of Israel is necessary to bring about the Apocalypse, a thing they want because they go to heaven. The Israeli right wing wants criticism of Israel to be inseparable from criticism of Jewish people. This means you can't criticize Israel without being painted as anti-Semitic, and to be fair there are a lot ppl who criticize Israel for deeply anti-Semitic reasons.
- vimacs2 6y agoThe deep irony of this is that Israel have an apartheid system that discriminates against many ethnic Semites (such as Palestinians). That and they supply military arms and training for far right groups in South and Central America - include ones with anti-Semite beliefs.
- satellite2 6y agoAny source on the support of Israel for biblical reasons?
- 6y ago
- dogma1138 6y agoJust use “Israel” not the “Zionists”...
- bjourne 6y agoProlific Israel critic Norman Finkelstein, has suggested that the Palestinians' supporters should replace "Zionism" with "Jewish supremacy". Because to them, Zionism and Jewish supremacy is the same thing. It would be quite difficult for Facebook and the other tech giants to ban "fuck Jewish supremacy" while allowing "fuck white supremacy" (or "fuck black supremacy"). Another advantage would be that labeling Israel a "Jewish supremacist state" is both a more precise and a more serious allegation than labeling it a "Zionist state". Given what is going on in Gaza and the evictions in East Jerusalem, the allegation probably isn't far-fetched to the general public. Furthermore, it allows for those who define themselves as Zionists not to feel threatened, unless they also support supremacist policies. Like how I don't feel threatened by condemnations of white supremacy or how most Muslims don't feel threatened by condemnations of ISIS or Saudi Arabia. However, unlike white supremacy, Jewish supremacy has strong non-Jewish support; from evangelical Christians in the US and many right-wing parties in Europe. To the latter group, Israel's treatment of "the Muslims" is something to be imitated in their home countries. In a way, the war over the word Zionism is like the war over Communism in reverse. Communists had to defend or downplay the Soviet Union's human rights abuses, exactly like Zionists today defend Israel's abuses. They had to argue that Communism wasn't the same thing as the Soviet System, just like Zionists have to argue that Zionism isn't the same thing as Israel's record-breaking 50-year-old long occupation. The Communists lost the war over the word and today most Communists call themselves Socialists instead (me included). We'll see if the Zionists can defend their word better. They certainly are in a much better position to do so than the Communists ever were.
- oblak 6y agoZionism is jewish nationalism. Wiki[0] says so in the very first sentence [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zionism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zionism > However, unlike white supremacy, Jewish supremacy has strong non-Jewish support; from evangelical Christians in the US and many right-wing parties in Europe. To the latter group, Israel's treatment of "the Muslims" is something to be imitated in their home countries. Sorry to say I know a few individuals who are disgusting racists but somehow always seem to root for Israel when the news hit about the latest big enough skirmish or weapons testing/bombing
- 6y ago
- stuaxo 6y agoHow unsurprising this has been flagged.