2 ms·
FWIW: the metal components of lithium batteries (especially cobalt) tend to be the economically limiting resources, not the lithium itself. But the point is va
by ajross 6y ago
FWIW: the metal components of lithium batteries (especially cobalt) tend to be the economically limiting resources, not the lithium itself. But the point is valid: batteries are indeed harder to recycle than bulk steel, but relative to the cost of extracting new materials recycling is far more effective economically.
Also: it's not like EVs don't have steel chassis. It's (very roughly) the engine block and transmission mass that gets replaced by a battery. Once you remove that battery, the vehicles recycle identically. The only question is about how effective battery recycling is or can be (and it's pretty good already!)
- niblettc 6y agoIt actually is that many vehicles don't have a steel chassis. The Model Y for instance has an aluminum chassis to save weight. There even other materials such as Carbon Fiber used in some high end vehicle.
- cptskippy 6y agoThe rear underbody of the Y is aluminum but it still has a steel chassis. Aluminum can never fully replace steel because it lacks the strength and rigidity. Regardless, aluminum is expensive to extract and refine, requiring a tremendous amount of energy. In terms of cost, on average aluminum is more expensive than steel.
- robocat 6y ago> Aluminum can never fully replace steel because it lacks the strength and rigidity. Huh? The main reason is because Aluminium is expensive. The BWW i3 uses an Aluminium frame exactly because it reduces weight. https://www.marklines.com/en/report_all/Munro003_201710 https://www.marklines.com/en/report_all/Munro003_201710
- cptskippy 6y agoNone of what you said contradicts what you quoted. Steel is a stronger material than aluminum, the trade offs are that it's harder to form and weights more.