4 ms·
You're saying MTGox is a bank, they're not, they are an exchange.
by kristianp 15y ago
You're saying MTGox is a bank, they're not, they are an exchange.
- tedunangst 15y agoWhen people are unable to get their money out of an exchange, they don't much care about the difference.
- eli 15y agoAn exchange. That accepts deposits. And holds your money for you. Like a bank.
- nowarninglabel 15y agoA bank is a legally defined concept, this exchange is not one.
- Uchikoma 15y agoI think you've meant: A bank is a legally defined concept where I live, this exchange is not one.
- nowarninglabel 15y agoNot really no, a bank is a legally defined concept in pretty much every country in the world. Suggested reading: http://www1.law.nyu.edu/centralbankscenter/texts/order.html http://www1.law.nyu.edu/centralbankscenter/texts/order.html
- RickHull 15y agoThat page links to the national laws defining central banks. No one is claiming Mt Gox is a central bank.
- nowarninglabel 15y agoIt's a further resource out to the central bank information in various country which further goes towards information on legal definitions of a bank in each country (at least many of the links provide such information). If you have a better site for international banking law definitions separated by country, it'd be awesome to suggest it.
- Uchikoma 15y agoNot sure about the logic: 1. All banks are defined 2. Me: You cannot claim banks are the same everywhere 3. "Pretty much every country" == not everywhere So you agree, or you disagree? Sorry to stick with Aristotelian logic.
- ubernostrum 15y agoThere is a difference between reading the statement as "mtgox offers some services which make it look bank-like" and "mtgox is definitively a bank as defined by applicable laws". The difference, in case you're curious, is willful pedantry, and really just clutters up the thread.
- mcherm 15y agoBy that argument, an exchange is a legally defined concept and MTGox isn't one of those either. MTGox is not a legally regulated bank. They are not a legally regulated exchange. They DO hold accounts on behalf of their customers, performing the function known as "banking". They DO execute trades between their customers, performing the function known as "an exchange".
- rick888 15y agoIt seems they like to use this term, so bitcoin can claim it's still decentralized. Since it's obvious we do need banks for bitcoin (or a safe way to store our currency) and it's not very anonymous, what's the point of using it again? I would rather just use credit cards or cash.
- wmf 15y agoMt.Gox really is an exchange; the whole point of the site is to convert between BTC and USD. If you wanted a bank, you'd use something else. It's also not clear to me that it's safer to store BTC on a server.
- rick888 15y agoIt is an exchange, but hackers are having a field day. People are realizing what the world realized many years ago: we need banks. I feel like bitcoin is going through all of the growing pains and making the same exact mistakes we already learned about currency.
- icebraining 15y agoYou can keep your wallet file secure. Encrypt it, store it in a pen drive and secure it as you want. The decentralization has more to do with the fact that no government can control the currency.
- jellicle 15y agoAs soon as an exchange holds your money for more than ten seconds, it's a bank.