2 ms·
A tiny minority of Facebook users is millions of people. Lots of people have international family and friends. A fallback approach is infeasible for legal requi
by pjc50 6y ago
A tiny minority of Facebook users is millions of people. Lots of people have international family and friends. A fallback approach is infeasible for legal requirements, unless it's there for appealing the fine to a lower value.
The question is potentially very difficult, and could only be resolved by constructive engagement with the party making the rules.
Don't forget what happens when people travel.
- peoplefromibiza 6y agomany more people have friends and family in the US, but are not allowed to enter the country freely. Borders are heavily controlled by USA, why shouldn't other countries to the same?
- trasz 6y agoThe question can be solved trivially easily by just using a big-hammer approach of banning any transfer of personal information to US, period. There are no reasons for allowing the transfer to happen, other than making it easier for Facebook to make money. FB would implement it by only storing interactions involving any EU nationals in EU. We do want to make it easier for Facebook for political reasons, though, and it's still not particularly hard: just declare that only the data/conversations involving US citizens can be stored on US servers.
- bryan_w 6y agoAre you saying that an American shouldn't be able to pull up the profile of an EU user? Seems a bit extreme.
- trasz 6y agoOf course not; the data would come from FB's EU servers. The "transfer" above applies to where the data is stored, not where it can be accessed from. From the users point of view the only change would be... nothing; the latency is already at the point where it wouldn't incur any observable penalty.
- ConceptJunkie 6y agoI don't have many Facebook friends, but they include people on at least 3 other continents. I'm sure a lot of folks have at least some friends in other countries.