9 ms·
Gigabyte Brix Pro: A Compact PC for Basic Computing Needs
- ekianjo 6y ago> Basic computing needs So they define basic as anything that's not gaming.
- agumonkey 6y agoSeems fair to me.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoLots of games you can play on this.
- hocuspocus 6y agoWho would want four HDMI ports but zero (mini)DP?
- auxym 6y agoI'm not sure why, but DP seems to be on the way out. Anecdotally, I haven't seen DP ports on displays or laptops bought in the last year or two.
- danhor 6y agoOn Laptops: It's probably because all DPs are routed through the usb-c connectors. No one does hdmi over usb-c, so they're left-over.
- aksss 6y agoYou can do usb-c to hdmi with a dongle of course, so even if driving an hdmi display, usb-c will do that.
- hocuspocus 6y agoAll high-end monitors very much have DP ports. Same with graphics cards.
- aksss 6y agoDP is still king for graphics - better bandwidth, color depth, variable refresh rates, daisy chaining. The limitation is the cable length, where HDMI is way better, but this probably only matters for conference rooms and home theaters. Running laptops exclusively for years I had the same impression about the death of dp. Getting a rig (and high quality monitor) for gaming changed my mind about that. Also, as another said, dp is run out of laptops using USB-c and thunderbolt now. HDMI ports themselves are no longer needed so you won’t see those on laptops much longer, either.
- dkjaudyeqooe 6y agoSomeone who uses TVs as monitors, especially if you want 3 or 4 it's the most economical option. On a higher-end box no DP would be criminal.
- reaperducer 6y ago"Basic" computing is now four HDMI ports and an LTE connection. Good to know.
- kingsuper20 6y agoProbably was cheap to add and there's some commercial market they're aiming at. I've been down the NUC road, and sort of like these kinds of products, but think they're a hard sell. A person could spend $50-$150 (instead of $500 all-in) on eBay and get an ex-corporate small desktop or a Thinkpad, spend a bit more and get a new Mac Mini M1, or view it as a down payment on a decent laptop or desktop. That Brix looks like it's in the middle of a pretty big ecosystem of products. There's more than a few people that might as well just own a Chromebox. If Raspberry PI 4s were just a bit faster, the non-performance home hobbyists might as well go for those as desktops and stick with computers that are cheaper than 2-3 new hardbound books.
- bartvk 6y agoThese are much smaller than an ex-corporate small desktop, right? My Intel NUC can easily be mounted behind my monitor. And although this Gigabyte product may be more expensive, the NUC its price range starts around 150 for Celeron based models a.l the way up to Mac Mini levels.
- kingsuper20 6y agoThose corporate boxes go pretty small. https://www.amazon.com/Lenovo-ThinkCentre-M93-i7-4765T-Win10Pro/dp/B08B21GSCK https://www.amazon.com/Lenovo-ThinkCentre-M93-i7-4765T-Win10... To me NUCs have sort of the same problem as their brethren in this space, you end up with too much money into them. In terms of cheap desktops, I've settled into older Thinkpads for now. Tolerably quiet (although I do consider fanless desktops now and again), cheap, they appear to be the kings of OS compatibility, as fixable as a laptop can be, built-in battery backup for the shitty power we have 'round these parts. At some point I'll have to modernize, but find it hard to spend much on computers. That's what employers/clients are for.
- 6y ago
- ihsw 6y agoThe Ryzen V1605B is a bottom-of-the-barrel Ryzen 1000-series embedded APU. There have been leaps and bounds in the past three years of embedded Ryzen APUs. https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/amd/ryzen_embedded/v1605b https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/amd/ryzen_embedded/v1605b It's disappointing that Gigabyte is choosing to start the AMD Brix platform with such an underwhelming product offering, especially in the face of starting with an Intel Tiger Lake processor. I wonder how much Overclockers.com was paid to gush over TGL-U.
- OakNinja 6y agoCould turn into a decent pfSense/openSense box.
- lostlogin 6y agoEsxi home server - it’s a little under powered in terms of CPU cores, but it’s a great little unit. I like quicksync from Intel for video transcoding, however it’s other features make up for it.
- oneplane 6y agoAny base model NUC is also 'a compact pc for basic computing needs', and the same goes for modern SFF and non-NUC NGFF PCs offered by the likes of Dell, HP and in some cases Apple (Mac Mini).
- 1MachineElf 6y agoSo will the Ryzen version work with ECC RAM?
- walterbell 6y agoAsRock usually does with Ryzen, but testing is needed since these NUC-sized boxes are using laptop chipsets.
- absorber 6y agoIt's kind of vague and hit-and-miss though, even on non-NUC systems ASRock not always supports ECC. Supposedly it's because of AMD's (lack of) clarity about the matter (according to an ASRock rep, at least) This is the mail I sent them in January. Still waiting for a response: > (This is a pretty technical sales question) > I wanted to know about the ECC compatibility of Asrock Rack X470D4U > In the specifications (https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=X470D4U#Specifications https://www.asrockrack.com/general/productdetail.asp?Model=X...) it says the following: > "*For Picasso Ridge and Raven Ridge CPUs, ECC is only supported with PRO CPUs." > However, there is no such thing as "Picasso Ridge". There is however Pinnacle Ridge and Raven Ridge. Perhaps a mistake? > So I was wondering what AMD CPUs had full ECC compatibility (so both detection and correction) > Does the AMD Ryzen 5 1600 have full ECC support on that board, for example?
- walterbell 6y agoRyzen in general is all over the place, sometimes ECC works on systems even when the BIOS has not been officially validated to support ECC. OEMs protect market segments with higher-priced devices, e.g. Ryzen Pro and EPYC/Xeon, which limits where AMD can offer "official" support for ECC.
- fu8ur8uwr8eu 6y agoIn 2019 I purchased an ASRock iBOX-V1000 which is fanless and completely silent (and has Ryzen quad core with integrated Vega GPU) and I have run it with 32GB ECC ram with both Ubuntu 18.04 and 20.04. Works great. Yes, the ECC works in "ECC mode" and Linux can see and report any detected/corrected memory errors. (Never seen any errors. Some people use hair dryers to heat up the ram to test the ECC, though.) I purchased from mitxpc: https://mitxpc.com/products/ibox-v1000?_pos=1&_sid=a0e23dd56&_ss=r https://mitxpc.com/products/ibox-v1000?_pos=1&_sid=a0e23dd56...
- francis-io 6y agoI've been using an i5 nuc for the last 5 or so years as a desktop pc attached to a kvm switch for a work laptop when forced by workplace IT. I'm still surprised how far integrated graphics can get you.
- p1necone 6y agoIntegrated graphics seem to have gone from "so bad that they're almost useless" to "actually enough to run modern games on low settings at playable framerates" in the last 5 or so years. And if they can run games, they're more than good enough for everything else (except for heavy GPU compute stuff).
- ryan-allen 6y agoI have a Asus PN50 4500U running Manjaro for work. I drive a 4k screen over displayport. It's _really_ good!
- lou1306 6y agoOnly 5 years? I remember playing Rocket League "decently" (1080p, 30FPS) on a Skylake laptop (i5-6200) back in ~2016. I would say integrated graphics were already sort-of-okay during the 5-6th generation of Intel Core's.
- lavela 6y ago> The unit can easily hide with other AV Components or not take up much space on the desk. Small form factor usually means dealing with an external power supply. I know about the benefits like taking a heat source out of the device, but I hate dealing with those bricks, especially when there are multiple externally powered devices and you don't have some object to let the power supplies slip behind. Are there any neat solutions for cable management in those cases?
- walterbell 6y agoThe custom SFF PC community has expensive, small, AC-DC power supplies, e.g. https://hdplex.com/hdplex-nanoatx-power-supply-explained https://hdplex.com/hdplex-nanoatx-power-supply-explained
- elcritch 6y agoOne option is to use PoE. You can have one PoE switch at your router and power nuc's or mini-pcs. Looks like there are a few nuc specific options: https://shop.poetexas.com/products/gbt-nuc https://shop.poetexas.com/products/gbt-nuc You could probably find slim DC power bricks.
- Havoc 6y agoBeen down this route - thermals and acoustics are a nightmare. Unless you really can't spare the space for a full tower its better not to
- oneplane 6y agoI'd say "it depends". Having a tiny laptop-type thermal solution (high TDP chip, low mass heatsink, tiny whiny fan) would indeed just be as annoying as a laptop, but there are plenty of configurations where it works just fine. The larger NUC-style devices (generally marketed as "this one has room for a 2.5" drive) with low power chips when used for light basic work don't really consume enough power to get hot. This is even something you can make completely passive; check out some of those ODMs in China that make passively cooled M and U series Intel PCs. Generally marketed as industrial PCs and software routers, they do have 18W parts that work fine in 35°C ambient for years and have plenty of performance. It really depends on what you use it for. (Qotom is one of them, there are a lot of white-label manufacturers, but when they make the boards it's pretty close to the 'actual' ODM instead of just another re-badge)
- walterbell 6y agoDo any of those ODM boxes allow open firmware like coreboot? Protectli is one option, would be nice to have other choices.
- oneplane 6y agoProtectli is just a rebadged ODM box. Most of the boxes I've seen don't have BootGuard fused so you can run coreboot on it. On the other hand, you can't run coreboot on most things, including the Gigabyte Brix Pro.
- walterbell 6y agoAny good search terms for those ODM vendors? e.g. I couldn't find much for a search about Qotom and BootGuard or coreboot.
- MrFoof 6y agoWent down a similar route for a 'mini virtualization server.' HP ProDesk 405 G6 with an AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 4750GE (8C/16T, 3.1GHz base clock, 8 VEGA GPU cores), and tossed in 64GB of DDR4-3200 and a 1TB Samsung 980 Pro. Real storage is like 55TB of RAID 1 or RAID 10 arrays on the network, where VM backups and snapshots also go (and get shoved out to Backblaze), as well as media and other chunky data. If you got an EliteDesk 805 you can even have a second M.2 socket so you can RAID1 the SSDs. Only downer is no 10GbE ethernet. Sits at about 12W at idle. With everything under the sun running it hums along at about 20-22W of power consumption. Absolutely silent. Plus being an APU I can even have a Plex VM happily transcode without breaking a sweat. AMD DASH means I also have full IPMI functionality as well (not as good as Intel vPro, but good enough). 1L form factors (incl. Mac Mini, NUCs) are ideal home servers at this point when you need much more power than a Raspberry Pi provides.
- Hamuko 6y ago>1L form factors (incl. Mac Mini, NUCs) are ideal home servers at this point when you need much more power than a Raspberry Pi provides. A Synology or a HPE MicroServer might be better since you can use it for storage as well without external HDDs.
- walterbell 6y agoStorage devices are so quirky that I've given up on integration of SFF compute with storage. Compact storage devices make tradeoffs, which may or may not fit your needs, e.g. flash/SSD tier, 10GbE/2.5GbE NICs, memory, TPMs, low-power vs. cores. External storage offers more flexibility, which will increase as USB4/Thunderbolt become widely available and fall in price. For now, USB 3.2 JBOD with ZFS is workable with external enclosures, https://oyendigital.com/multi-bay-storage https://oyendigital.com/multi-bay-storage Wish there was a NUC-sized device with an LSI SATA controller and external connector. If we're lucky, the https://frame.work https://frame.work "modular laptop" approach will be adapted to compact desktops based on laptop chipsets.
- MrFoof 6y agoI don't have, "external HDDs". I have a NAS running TrueNAS, with a few arrays in it depending on the performance needed for the storage. Its primary jobs are for data processing and video editing (plus smaller arrays for backups and VM snapshots), and has multiple 10GbE network interfaces (which it can saturate) to facilitate that. It was also built to sip power when there isn't any disk activity. I have no desire for it to run VMs or containers. Its job is to just be storage. The virtualization server is one of many things that connects to it. There are benefits to having the storage and the virtualization servers separate, mostly that there's no single point of failure.
- walterbell 6y agoLenovo Tiny P330/P340 and 920 have a small PCI slot that accepts an Nvidia GPU with 4X mini-displayport, or a quad-port Broadcom NIC. Flexible and powerful 1-litre box for virtualization. wish there was a Ryzen Pro version. ASRock 4x4 offers the latest Ryzen mobile CPUs (4300U 4c, 4500U 6c, 4800U 8c) in a traditional NUC form factor. Minimal expansion. Includes serial port header for kernel dev.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoTheir comparison table makes no sense. The blurb says the Intel option supports up to 64GB of of DDR4-3200 vs. AMD with only up to 32GB of DDR4-2400. The table says both options support only up to 32GB of DDR4-2400. Sloppy...
- techrat 6y agoIt gets worse when you try to look up the spec sheets on these processors and their supporting boards. Since for most at the time of copy writing for manuals before production, 8 or 16GB sticks were largest, so naturally the highest supported ram is 2x that, one for each slot. My motherboard said max was 32GB (2x16GB), tried 2x32GB (for a max of 64GB). It worked.
- Black101 6y agoThe ASUS PN50 MiniPC with AMD Ryzen is great too and can handle more then basic computing needs: https://www.microcenter.com/product/630580/asus-pn50-minipc-with-amd-ryzen-r3-4300u-4-cores-mobile-processors,-support-up-to-4-displays-in-4k-resolution,-up-to-64gb-ddr4-ram,-m2-ssd,-80211ax-wi https://www.microcenter.com/product/630580/asus-pn50-minipc-...
- blinkingled 6y agoSeconded - I do wish Asus fix the BIOS for unstable TSC that makes Linux switch to HPET which is much slower. I have also had display flickering issues with W10 but thankfully not on Linux which is perfectly fine. Otherwise a really great mini PC which can pretty much do anything you throw at it minus maybe demanding games.
- butz 6y agoStill waiting for small form factor PC with built in PSU.
- walterbell 6y agoThis is the size you're looking at, https://www.antec.com/product/case/isk300-150 https://www.antec.com/product/case/isk300-150 Or the rabbit hole of custom builds, https://smallformfactor.net/forum/ https://smallformfactor.net/forum/
- chrisandchris 6y ago> Gigabyte has 14 Brix Pro models that vary in both size, and installed hardware. One of the reason I‘m going to dislike this product. As I would like to compare 14 different models. That‘s going to take to much time.
- spaceisballer 6y agoI would love to have something very low power taking up little space like these. Even after dropping 16gb ram and maybe a 1 TB m2 you are still in the $500 range. I was interested in a Mac Mini but if you want 16gb ram and a 513gb HD you are over $1k. Sure the mini will do a lot more but it’s not the niche I’m trying to fill. I want a small low power computer running my plex server and for doing basic computing/surfing. Ability to play Roblox or Minecraft is a bonus, but I have a gaming PC for that.
- snarfy 6y agoI own three. They are great little PCs. I have one setup with win10, cubase and ableton, another is my Ubuntu box, and one I was using as a file server but am now repurposing as my cnc control pc.
- tomcam 6y agoSlightly surprised you can get mileage out of these with Cubase and Ableton. Can you tell me a little more about number of tracks and/or rendering time, anything that might give me an idea of the performance on a day-to-day basis?
- snarfy 6y agoI admit I only noodle around with DAW software. I think the most demanding thing I've run on this was cubase with about 8 tracks + effects + analog mix in. cpu was at about 50%. cpu on this specific brix pro (it's old): Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-6500U CPU @ 2.50GHz 2.59 GHz
- tomcam 6y agoStill not terrible at all. Thank you.
- rsync 6y agoWhat is the maximum number of 4k@60 displays this system can drive ? I see, of course, that it has 4x HDMI ports @ 4k@60. However, it also has 1x thunderbolt port and at least 4x USB 3.2 ports. How many displays can it actually drive if you get fancy with cabling and adaptors ?
- denkmoon 6y agoI've been using intel nucs as mini hypervisors for years. They are amazing little machines that I can shove in a cabinet somewhere - quiet, low powered, but good enough that you can do actual tasks on them, unlike an Atom (at the time, not sure where atom is at these days, does it even still exist?). Thunderbolt allows me to whack a 10GbE NIC on there and offload all storage requirements to my NAS. Brix offers a little bit more IO, at the cost of larger volume. Not necessary for me. The only thing I desire is IPMI, so MrFoof's suggestion of using AMD DASH is intriguing. Maybe next time.
- bkor 6y agoFyi: Akasa sells replacement cases for Intel NUCs. I've used this to ensure my NUC is entirely silent. After this you do need some air circulation around the case. Meaning, a closed cupboard might built be enough. I've put mine under a desk.