2 ms·
I don't think you quite understand what I mean. You said it yourself, the interceptor is interested in knowing where the missile will be in X seconds. Let us
by sudosysgen 6y ago
I don't think you quite understand what I mean.
You said it yourself, the interceptor is interested in knowing where the missile will be in X seconds.
Let us think about this mathematically. Let us use the following coordinate space - the missile travels along the X axis.
The missile may accelerate on the ZX plane by, say, 20Gs.
This means that after x seconds the missile may be in a circle 98m * x^2 in radius = 20G * 9.8m/Gs * 1/2 * t^2 which is the basic kinematic equation.
So if we want to answer the question, how much uncertainty is there in where the missile will be in X seconds, the correct metric is actually lateral G force, not turning radius.
The interceptor missile cannot simply have a higher lateral G than the target and be assured it will hit it. Indeed, the Python 5 missile you mentioned wouldn't be able to hit the hypersonic missile.
Why? It's too slow. The Python 5 will hit Mach 4 shortly after launch and impact around Mach 2 or so. Meanwhile the hypersonic missile will maintain Mach 7+ throughout.
This means that despite higher lateral G forces, the Python simply will not have the energy to maneuver with the hypersonic missile. Consider the following scenario, as an example that is simple to understand. The Python missile, going at Mach 3, will go towards where the missile seems to be going. This is hugely problematic for the Python 5, it means that every movement the hypersonic missile does will be amplified by the pursuant missile as it has to "get in the way". So if the missile, 150km away, increases pitch by 4 degrees, the Python 5 might have to immediately pitch up almost 30 degrees, bleeding of a lot of energy.
Then if the hypersonic missile pitches down to -4 degrees, it will seem to impact now a full 13km lower. Now the Python, already slowed down, has to maneuver down 50 degrees!
So because of the speed difference, the interceptor now has to engage much more G force than the hypersonic missile, because it has to position itself in the path of the hypersonic missile due to its speed being too low to pursue it.
This is made even worse by the fact that this very maneuvering is going to reduce the speed of the interceptor, which can't make it back up because it doesn't have an air breathing engine!
This is the reason why the Radar Warning Receiver made the early long distance missiles ineffective. Despite in this case the missiles being faster than the planes and despite being able to pull off more Gs, their inability to regenerate kinetic energy meant that fighter could bait them into losing their energy, reducing their speed and shaking them off.
Now the same problem repeats itself, except that the hypersonic missile is now faster than the interceptor and the maneuvrability gap is much lower.
That's all to say, if you want to evade intercepting missiles, what matters is : lateral G forces, speed, and energy regeneration. Nothing else!
- jhgb 6y ago> So if we want to answer the question, how much uncertainty is there in where the missile will be in X seconds, the correct metric is actually lateral G force, not turning radius. I'm sure that if you draw the situation for yourself on a paper, it will be more readily apparent to you how the two are basically the same thing. > So if we want to answer the question, how much uncertainty is there in where the missile will be in X seconds, the correct metric is actually lateral G force, not turning radius. The interceptor missile cannot simply have a higher lateral G than the target and be assured it will hit it. Indeed, the Python 5 missile you mentioned wouldn't be able to hit the hypersonic missile. Why? It's too slow. The Python 5 will hit Mach 4 shortly after launch and impact around Mach 2 or so. Meanwhile the hypersonic missile will maintain Mach 7+ throughout. I don't see how what you wrote makes sense. You've limited yourself to the transverse plane. For point defense, that makes perfect sense. But it also makes the longitudinal Mach 7 meaningless, except for the dynamics of the encounter and impact, since that movement doesn't happen in the transverse plane. > So if the missile, 150km away, increases pitch by 4 degrees, the Python 5 might have to immediately pitch up almost 30 degrees, bleeding of a lot of energy. You wouldn't be hitting it in this phase of flight. I was speaking solely of terminal defense. Therein might lie your confusion.