4 ms·
> Stories like this drive home the point: you can’t train your machine learning for every eventuality. Overturned truck or stationary emergency vehicle should
by toast0 6y ago
> Stories like this drive home the point: you can’t train your machine learning for every eventuality.
Overturned truck or stationary emergency vehicle should be pretty high on the list; trees maybe a bit lower. But the sensor package doesn't do those well, so in the interest of comfort, stationary objects are filtered out before avoidance algorithms are run.
- richardw 6y agoThere are a lot more trees than overturned trucks. Not having sensors that see trees without reducing comfort is a choice. If the car can’t drive safely in a situation, it needs to require a driver.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> so in the interest of comfort, stationary objects are filtered out before avoidance algorithms are run. Running into stationary objects has a pretty adverse effect on comfort.
- toast0 6y agoSo does stopping for stationary objects like metal plates on the road or overhead signs.
- dragonwriter 6y agoSo, your argument is that no matter what choices were made about tuning, Autopilot isn't ready for real use?
- toast0 6y agoGiven the choices that were made, I don't think it can do the job it's marketed as doing, and I don't think I could safely and reliably supervise a car that's expected to partially drive itself. I much prefer to drive a vehicle where I'm clearly responsible, but the (on by default) assistance features might help me out from time to time if I screw up. A computer doesn't get bored of checking if there's a slowing vehicle or (if it checks for them) stationary object in the path; but I'm pretty sure I wouldn't stay alert enough to jump in. OTOH, I also don't like using cruise control either, but that's not because I want to stay alert, but because without radar cruise control it's too much work to use, and I don't like the following distance options for the radar cruise control I have access to.