3 ms·
Ignoring cars for a moment, it's just super sad to me how bad the state of ad-hoc connectivity is. This is fairly car specific, but there was some ok ad-hoc ne
by rektide 6y ago
Ignoring cars for a moment, it's just super sad to me how bad the state of ad-hoc connectivity is.
This is fairly car specific, but there was some ok ad-hoc networking work in 802.11p, Wireless Access in Vehicular Environments (WAVE)[1]. Using a low-bit rate wireless channel to allow, effectively, broadcasting. Now everyone wants to get on cellular, which seems like it's probably an industry play, to lock in cell phone providers, to make sure consumers don't get access. Allegedly some occasional forms of v2v (vehicle to vehicle) or v2i (vehicle to infrastructure & reverse) do have a local "broadcast" form of cellular, that doesn't rely entirely upon existing cellular networks, but all this cellular stuff feels like a colossal degradation versus a fairly understandable, simple wifi system, that we failed with only through lack of trying.
There was Google's Physical Web[2], using a Bluetooth Low Energy beacon to broadcast a very short URL. That was integrated into Android! A notification could pop up! Ripe for abuse and bad, but it's the sort of thing I really wish the good & excited people had seized upon, had built something with. Incredible amount of potential and power. No longer developed, dropped from Android proper, but it's a simple specification, easy to implement in a couple hours. Google did a damned good job building, standardizing, promoting, trying, & this could be one instrumental way to have things in the world be able to advertise themselves digitally.
There's wifi-aware[3], for Neighbor Aware Networking, but it's hard to assess this tech. It all seems locked up being gummy sticky gnarly Apple and Android uses. There's no interop. But supposedly it's something to help us connect with those about us. I think there are some IEEE 802.11 standards in here somewhere, but wifi alliance are generally not super nice people who don't share & who keep consumers in the dark & let Apple and Google & occasional other huge player monopolize use of the technology they stamp their name on, alas.
Don't get me wrong, I'm afraid of a world where information & ads & other things bombard us, come at us from everywhere. But it distresses me to no end that we have almost no means to digitally connect with someone standing right next to us. That hopping on the same wifi is one of the only options. Or using some proprietary non-standard system that knows our identity & is tracking us, be it Google or Apple doing that tracking, doing that gatekeeping. It's weird as heck to me how advanced communications infrastructure is, but how it's still so fantastically centralized & top-down, and starting to get systems that allow us to be aware of other information resources is high on my interest list. That said, this article, especially with Vice's typical aggressive spin on the headline, doesn't sound particularly interesting or wanted to me, but it's in an area that seems radically under-examined, under-developed, that has had a fair share of could-be players pass by without making an impact.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11p https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11p
[2] http://google.github.io/physical-web/ http://google.github.io/physical-web/
[3] https://www.wi-fi.org/discover-wi-fi/wi-fi-aware https://www.wi-fi.org/discover-wi-fi/wi-fi-aware