2 ms·
This is a fascinating discovery, but I do want to spare a moment's thought for the lab animals in the study. Asphyxiation is a deeply unpleasant way to die, whi
by jfengel 6y ago
This is a fascinating discovery, but I do want to spare a moment's thought for the lab animals in the study. Asphyxiation is a deeply unpleasant way to die, which is what happened to all of the control group, all of the group without intestinal abrasion, and 25% of the mice who were given the full treatment.
That latter is just one animal; the groups were very small. But that sounds especially horrible, getting almost enough oxygen to live. Every single animal underwent "agonal respiration", which is merely medical Latin for "gasping for breath", but nonetheless suggests that these mice were suffering substantially.
I'm glad that the groups were small. I'm well aware that animal models are necessary for medicine, and that these deaths may well one day save many human lives; presumably the Institutional Review Board decided it was worth it on balance. I hope that future experiments can continue to be done with an eye to minimizing the suffering that goes into them.
- 4gotunameagain 6y agoHaha there was a control group? What did they expect?
- prideout 6y agoIt's good that you brought this up in a tactful way. I share your concerns about animal suffering, and your hope for the future. It sounds like you are willing to concede that the suffering in this particular case is potentially worthwhile, and I too am willing to make this concession. Millions of people have died, and we have to do what we have to do. I hope we can be smarter in the future.