4 ms·
That's true, but it's a pretty common interpretation of the term "natural experiment". Few, if any, "natural experiments" are actually experiments in a rigorou
by jfengel 6y ago
That's true, but it's a pretty common interpretation of the term "natural experiment".
Few, if any, "natural experiments" are actually experiments in a rigorous sense. But they are a thing that happens: you have an uncontrolled happenstance that allows you to infer, but not prove, something you want to learn more about.
When the surface meaning of a term has no referents, it will often be co-opted to refer to something people need a term for (assuming it's compact and convenient). Another example that comes to mind is "homophobia", which doesn't refer to actual "fear of homosexuals" but rather to a dislike for them -- a thing which is very common but doesn't have a convenient, short expression. (The term actually comes from being the opposite of "homophilia", a reasonably straightforward but outdated term for homosexuality.)
So it's true that we don't really have a good control and will have difficulty separating out real causes and effects. But a thing definitely happened and we can definitely try to learn something from it -- a notion that happens often enough to merit a name. If you've got a better one we can try to make it catch on.
- andersource 6y agoYou're right, but then giving the title "Work from Home & Productivity" is misleading, giving the (IMO false) impression that results are generalizable for WFH beyond COVID. And there are some pretty strong claims: > Therefore, productivity fell by about 20% > Employees also spent less time networking, and received less coaching and 1:1 meetings with supervisors > Employees with children living at home increased hours worked more than those without children at home, and suffered a bigger decline in productivity than those without children I would say these results have more to do with COVID effects and forced, sudden WFH than inherent characteristics of WFH.
- ghaff 6y ago> Employees also spent less time networking, and received less coaching and 1:1 meetings with supervisors And, in normal times, remote workers often have/should have off-sites/on-sites, in-person team meetings, etc. And I haven't actually had fewer 1:1's. Probably more because I haven't canceled as many due to travel. (Which isn't necessarily a positive thing but still.)
- jfengel 6y agoVery true. It does help that the full title has a colon followed by "Evidence from Personnel & Analytics Data on IT Professionals". That word "evidence" does help limit the expectations for how much we can generalize.
- andersource 6y agoTrue. But then why not explicitly state that this evidence is from COVID? That would immediately allow people to calibrate their expectations. In relation to GP, COVID is the "natural experiment" here, not WFH.