4 ms·
Missile maneuvrability is measured in lateral acceleration. Hypersonic missiles pull just as many Gs as any other missile, they are not any less maneuverable.
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Missile maneuvrability is measured in lateral acceleration.
Hypersonic missiles pull just as many Gs as any other missile, they are not any less maneuverable.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoHypersonic get their claim for manoeuvrability by comparison with their faster cousins the ballistic missiles, not short range (less than 60 km) air-to-air missiles that have sort bursts of Mach 4.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThis is wrong. Hypersonic vehicles are thought to have maneuvering accelerations over 15Gs. That's more than most cruise missiles. Of course they will not be as maneuverable as A2A missiles. But what's the point? If you want to evade A2A missiles already going slower than you you're using energy to your advantage so 10Gs is more than enough. As it stands hypersonic missiles are more maneuverable than all other missiles including cruise missiles short of specialized A2A missiles. So for the purpose of evading interceptors and penetrating defence systems it's more than enough.
- jhgb 6y ago> Hypersonic vehicles are thought to have maneuvering accelerations over 15Gs Considering the mediocre L/D ratio of hypersonic vehicles, this seems extremely optimistic to me.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe X-15 was able to sustain G forces in excess of 15Gs. The limit was that its chassis would break apart. Maneuvrability works very differently for high-trust, vectored, supersonic vehicles. That's why A2A missiles can pull of 50Gs despite very low L/D ratio, speed helps a lot. Hypersonic flight magnifies this even further. I mean, look at the X15, it was able to do more than 15Gs despite having lower relative thrust and non-vectored engines, at higher altitudes!
- jhgb 5y agoThe X-15 to my knowledge was not under thrust when maneuvering in the hypersonic regime, so I don't understand the connection here. And because of being unpowered and hypersonic, it would still be losing speed more rapidly than even an unpowered airplane or missile flying at a lower velocity. > That's why A2A missiles can pull of 50Gs despite very low L/D ratio No, they can do this because they're small, and being small means a low ballistic coefficient because your mass shrinks faster than the aerodynamic-force-generating area. But a 100kg missile is not what you use to strike very remote targets on the ground.
- jhgb 6y agoIf they only pull as many Gs as any other missile, then their turning radius will be larger proportional to the square of the velocity ratios. For example a Mach 10 missile pulling the same Gs as a Mach 2 missile will turn in a circle 25 times larger. Or, to put it differently, if the missile is approaching its target and X seconds before impact decides to change the impact point, or perhaps evade a countermeasure, a Mach 10 missile will be only able to make 4% of the correction a Mach 2 missile with the same transverse acceleration would be able to make from the same distance.
- sudosysgen 6y agoTurning radius doesn't matter though. What matters is being able to outmaneuver interceptors and cause them to lose energy. What matters for that is only Gs. The turning radius is completely irrelevant if you want to evade a countermeasure. All that matters is how far you are from where the countermeasure is going. That's measured in Gs. Similarly, there's not going to be any issue changing impact points, the only issue is changing targets, but I don't see where that would be useful.
- jhgb 6y ago> The turning radius is completely irrelevant if you want to evade a countermeasure. All that matters is how far you are from where the countermeasure is going. That's measured in Gs The problem here (for the hypersonic missile) is that the countermeasure is mirroring this: it's interested where the hypersonic missile is going to be X seconds from now. And a high velocity target shrinks that circle of possibilities - very substantially, as I've noted, inversely proportionately to the square of velocity. As for Gs, today we have missiles like Python 5 than have no problem pulling something like 40 Gs. One reason for that is that they're optimized for maneuvering, not for extreme velocities. Just getting to and maintaining extremely high velocity is difficult enough so it seems unlikely that the incoming hypersonic vehicle would be capable of both, especially in terminal flight regime for which it isn't optimized. Also, one obvious problem with your reasoning is that your hypersonic missile isn't likely to be equipped or capable of evading whatever your target is throwing at it. An antimissile is going to be small, most likely much smaller than your hypersonic missile. That alone will make the antimissile hard to detect. Furthermore, assuming that your hypersonic missile will be hypersonic in the terminal phase, issues of aerodynamic heating etc. will quite likely make it difficult for any kind of sensor to operate. Especially the need to separate the antimissile from the background of the target won't make it any easier. So "wanting to evade a countermeasure" is nice but perhaps not as feasible as one might think. We're generally not even doing it today when it's easier. Not quite sure why it should work for a vehicle for which it will be substantially harder.