3 ms·
>This is not like a currency, where if I had a stack of Euros from an old holiday and then exchanged them for USD or even bought something with them, there is n
by gruez 6y ago
>This is not like a currency, where if I had a stack of Euros from an old holiday and then exchanged them for USD or even bought something with them, there is no concept of "lot" price in a currency.
But are they taxed? ie. if you sold your euros now, you'd probably realize a modest profit since USD went down recently. Are those gains tax-free?
- xphilter 6y agoEffectively yes they are tax free because there’s no easy way for irs to enforce. By law though you need to pay taxes on those gains. If you use a trading platform for trading, there’s probably a better chance of getting caught if you don’t pay taxes. There’s really nothing different here.
- lbotos 6y agoI was looking for an IRS page, but it appears that there are reasonably low limits ($200 gain) before taxes trigger: https://johnschachter.com/international-taxpayers/holding-a-foreign-currency-you-may-owe-tax-or-get-a-valuable-write-off/ https://johnschachter.com/international-taxpayers/holding-a-...
- efficax 6y agoNo, forex trading is taxed as capital gains, like any other asset. It also opens up an interesting loophole for companies with cash streams in other currencies, if those currencies are falling in value relative to the dollar. They can cover their local costs in local currency but then convert profits to USD and declare a loss for a tax writeoff.
- the_optimist 6y agoCan you reference the formal accounting and financial mechanisms under which this activity supposedly generates a tax write-off? Specifically: a tax write-off that is not also an actual economic loss.
- motohagiography 6y agoIf instead of "selling" or "exchanging" those Euros, the purchasing power of those Euros may have changed as the result of inflation, PPP, used lamborghini prices, etc. The change in value depends on the change in value of what you have marked it to. Direct USD exchange, there's huge profits/loses because of the volatility of cryptocurrencies vs. USD. But NFTs...these become a kind of volatility cold storage. I'm not trying to mentally hack tax law, I'm suggesting that the law as described in an example by a journalist would show cryptocurrencies are not currencies, and now that the US is making enforcement a priority, they are collapsing the uncertainty bubble in which the whole market has operated. The invention of cryptocurrencies was a tax revolt to begin with, and it probably makes more sense to look at policy through this lens than any other.