4 ms·
How does this so called 'CAPTCHA replacement' idea compare to Sign In With Apple? which also does not use any CAPTCHAs and aims to prevent bot sign ups.
by rvz 6y ago
How does this so called 'CAPTCHA replacement' idea compare to Sign In With Apple? which also does not use any CAPTCHAs and aims to prevent bot sign ups.
- md_ 6y agoApple Sign-In is just an OpenID federated login; these don't inherently provide any anti-automation or rate limiting; they just push the problem to the Identity Provider. IdPs like Apple/Google/Microsoft might do a fine job of limiting you to "one account per $unit-of-hardware"; Apple in particular can do this via iOS attestation. But then you're limited to either their heuristics (in the case of MSFT/Google) or their hardware (in the case of Apple). Ultimately this is apples-to-oranges, though, since Cloudflare is not offering an IdP product but simply an anti-automation solution. If you use federated auth, you're getting (and giving up) a lot of other stuff beyond just anti-automation.
- md_ 6y agoMaybe. I would have to read the FIDO group’s discussions on this to be confident in my opinion. :) I personally enjoy the ability to use my employer-provided authenticators on my personal accounts. I think this is both convenient (only one thing to carry) and helps adoption (I got a key “for free”). So maybe enterprise use is a Trojan Horse to promote consumer adoption?
- md_ 6y agoHmm. I replied to the wrong post.