4 ms·
The brutal policy that was applied to non-Europeans is now also applying to Europeans. This is government policy and it is popular - locking up and expelling Eu
by pjc50 6y ago
The brutal policy that was applied to non-Europeans is now also applying to Europeans. This is government policy and it is popular - locking up and expelling Europeans looking for work was one of the huge policy demands of Brexit that people voted for.
This nastiness is what the public demands.
Well, not all the public. Immigration enforcement got a rather different reception in Glasgow: https://twitter.com/david_millar/status/1392969258989150208 https://twitter.com/david_millar/status/1392969258989150208
- stereo 6y agoIt will be a lot less popular once British people arriving in the EU receive the same treatment and get told that this is what they voted for.
- throwaway8689 6y agoBritish people wanting to live and work in Europe will have to apply under Europe's rules. Seems fair. British people who have been evading existing rules and now have no basis to stay in Europe are being told to leave. Also fair.
- akudha 6y agoAre they politely asked to leave? Or are they thrown into detention centers and humiliated, despite willing to pay for the ticket to leave?
- gambiting 6y agoThe first one. The second Spanish police throws a British immigrant into a detention centre for staying illegally you will see every tabloid in the UK crying about it. But yes, British visitors to the EU who cannot enter for whatever reason are just sent back on the same flight or wait at the airport for the next one.
- oldnews193 6y agoEven if that happens, the people with whom anti-immigration policies are popular and job solicitors in the EU are likely two non-overlapping groups.
- pjc50 6y agoThere was a genre of Daily Mail comment where Brits who'd immigrated to Spain complained about the number of immigrants in the UK.
- one2three4 6y agoWhy don't they already? Seems 100% unfair. It's almost impossible for non EU citizens to enter Europe and look for a job if they come from Africa for instance. Why should it be easier for UK citizens?
- Symbiote 6y agoBecause we/they decided it, probably based on the relative economies of different countries, chance of illegal overstaying etc. I think EU and UK people can visit the USA for a job interview under the visa waiver programme. A Nigerian can't. It's the same difference.
- BerislavLopac 6y agoNot all EU people. Some still need visas for the US.
- nob0dyasked 6y agoExactly, citizens demand a government that enforces laws. Unlike the EU, where about 30% of illegal immigrants are expelled, while no one no one is interested in changing that legal status.
- knorker 6y agoDid you actually read the article? People are offering to buy their own ticket, but no they're sent to detention for no reason, at taxpayer expense. People are offering to stay private, but no they're sent to detention at taxpayer expense. A Czech woman is being sent to Mexico instead of allowing her to pay herself to fly home to Prague. All this spending of UK taxpayer funds for what? Out of spite?
- OJFord 6y ago> A Czech woman is being sent to Mexico instead of allowing her to pay herself to fly home to Prague. It's annoying and slightly weird, but isn't that just how it works? You go 'back where you came from', not wherever you want or claim to live? Say the woman in your example was refused by Czech customs, and sent back to the UK, then what? Dig through records (would they have them?) to find she came to the UK from Mexico, and then send her there? Correct me if I'm wrong, I just don't think that would be different in any other country. (That particular aspect I mean, assuming they've decided you're not allowed in, and will be deported to somewhere.)
- joshuaissac 6y ago> Say the woman in your example was refused by Czech customs, and sent back to the UK, then what? Considering she is Czech, she is far more likely to be rejected by Mexican customs rather than Czech customs.
- knorker 6y agoSure, there's always the tyrrany of the need to follow rules even when they make no sense, and if it were this in isolation then it would not raise eyebrows.
- viseztrance 6y agoBare in mind that eu citizens still don't need a visa to travel to the uk.
- knorker 6y ago"Bear in mind". "Bare in mind" sounds like you're thinking about the people naked. :-)
- pjc50 6y agoDepends on the purpose. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/visiting-the-uk-as-an-eu-eea-or-swiss-citizen https://www.gov.uk/guidance/visiting-the-uk-as-an-eu-eea-or-...
- viseztrance 6y agoI know that, and it's of course a good point. I was trying to convey the fact that citizens from eu countries are not at the level of other third countries yet. For example you can still travel using just a national id card until October. I wholeheartedly agree with the rest of your comment though.
- TheManInThePub 6y ago> This is government policy and it is popular Be very careful with such a statement. Regardless of where you sit on the issue, the Brexit referendum was roughly 50:50. The UK is fiercely split [1] and such issues are not going to be resolved anytime soon. It is incorrect to state such a policy is popular..... roughly half the population voted against it. [1] And dare I say it... looks in danger of splitting up.
- tebbers 6y agoOK then, it's fair to state that the policy is not unpopular. It commands a good deal of support from the electorate.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoPopulations usually split one third reactionary, one third progressive, and one third will-vote-how-they're told. If the policy is "popular" - which it isn't, except among the reactionaries - it's in no small measure because the UK media have normalised this kind of abuse. This kind of thing is almost a predictable syndrome associated with post-colonialism. Other countries have been through it, now it's the UK's turn. When countries lose their empires/influence, racism and fascism provide a compensation that can temporarily restore childish fantasies of omnipotence. It's associated with a death wish, so things generally get worse - sometimes much worse - before they get better.
- throwaway8689 6y agoThe referendum vote is not the best point of reference. The Conservatives won comfortably in 2019, and recently won a by election, again comfortably, all on a platform of implementing brexit.
- usr1106 6y agoWon comfortably in the UK does not mean too much in the UK. Easily 30-40% of the votes get just disregarded in the UK system. (I did not check the actual figures for the recent elections.)
- bogle 6y agoThe dawn raid in Glasgow looks a lot like a deliberate provocation from the Westminster government and the Home Office. It was in the First Minister's constituency; it was as the new MSPs (Members of the Scottish Parliament) were being sworn in; it's in the constituency that the leader of Scottish Labour, Anas Sarwar, contested in the May election; and it was the first day of Eid Al-Fitr. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-57100259 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-57100259
- nob0dyasked 6y agoYou don't sound paranoid at all.
- Glawen 6y agoEuropeans and the EU are the ideal scapegoat in the UK. I always felt that Europeans were blamed for immigration policies as it is politically correct to shame them. Shaming non european immigration is a social minefield, very few people would dare to say it aloud as they would categorised as racists.
- Veen 6y agoYou will find that non-European immigrants, especially from Commonwealth and ex-Commonwealth countries, also have a negative opinion of the previous preferential EU immigration rules. I have met many South African and Nigerian immigrants who found the disparity between their right to immigrate and that of EU citizens deeply unfair, and many who were eligible to vote in the Brexit referrendum chose to leave the EU for precicely that reason. They can hardly be accused of racism. Besides which, the conflation of a desire for immigration control with racism is a lazy canard.
- kristjankalm 6y agoi find such logic hard to understand: UK was part of the EU, hence the open labour market. That's the whole point of EU. What did they find unfair exactly -- that Nigeria was not part of the EU? Or that countries can agree to have an open labour market?
- Veen 6y agoLong before the UK joined the EU it was a member of the Commonwealth of Nations and had close relationships to countries that once were part of the Empire. Before the EU, most UK immigration came from Commonwealth countries. Freedom of movement allowed easy immigration from Europe and greater restrictions on Commonwealth immigration. People from those countries believe that the UK has prior obligations to members of the Commonwealth, and that it should prioritize those obligations (and often that privileging EU immigration is racist.) You can see the post-Brexit shift to previous obligations with the easing of immigration rules for Hong Kong citizens.
- throwaway8689 6y agoBrutal and nasty are emotive terms. If someone has no lawful basis to be in a country, what is wrong with expecting them to leave?
- bogle 6y agoIn the press articles the Home Office is quoted as saying, "suspected offences". A dawn raid is completely abhorrent for anything other than serious crimes. Note that Immigration Enforcement isn't even the police, this is a Home Office unit.
- throwaway8689 6y agoA dawn raid is designed to catch someone who is expected to try to evade arrest. Would you prefer a chase through the streets? Immigration Enforcement have power of arrest for this circumstance. The Information Commissioner has uniformed officers with limited police-type powers for their area of work too.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y ago"Power of arrest" for which circumstance, exactly? Someone visiting perfectly legally for an interview which may lead to a job offer? And I'd prefer no speculative high-drama arrests of people who are following the rules and not breaking the law.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoVisiting for an interview means having a letter of invitation for an interview from a company, not this (from article): > María, 25, from Valencia, said that like many of those detained, she thought she was free to explore the job market at least until October This sounds like coming to the UK for work without a visa, in which case it is correct in law to be detained. I think the practice of detention for up to 7 days before being deported is a way to inflict a punishment to deter people trying. Indeed, if the only thing you risk if caught is being turned away at the airport then people would just try and try, why not? There are articles from sources a bit more balanced than The Guardian: https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-citizens-detained-uk-work-visas-brexit/ https://www.politico.eu/article/eu-citizens-detained-uk-work...
- exporectomy 6y agoPeople who want unrestricted immigration for "looking for work" are completely clueless. They only think they want it because they don't know how many people will come if it's open borders with the 3rd world and what the economic and social consequences of that will be. Those unemployed people can't be allowed to starve so they must be supported by social welfare. It's easy to feel sorry for a handful of rejected migrants but only by ignoring the millions who never even tried to enter, knowing they couldn't.
- viraptor 6y ago> People who want unrestricted immigration for "looking for work" sounds like a weird strawman. Do you know of any larger group seriously fighting for that at the moment? (People coming for a scheduled interview are not "unrestricted immigration for looking for work")
- fakedang 6y agoThe article mentions a person coming "looking for work" being detained. The article also mentions a French woman who was detained for attending an interview for an internship, so I think there's that too. Imo, it's obviously very unclear as to why they're being detained, but in the case of Eugenia (Spanish woman arriving to "look for work"), it was clearly illegal per the new law.
- Stevvo 6y agoVery very few people want unrestricted immigration, however ~50% of people want unrestricted immigration from the EU on a reciprocal basis. We had that for years, with the economic and social consequences being largely positive. That said, I don't take it as a given that unrestricted immigration would cause problems; it has never been tried, there is no data to go on.
- thu2111 6y agoSupport for unlimited EU immigration is not 50%, it's much lower. You're thinking of people who voted to Remain, but a significant fraction of those people were motivated by the fear of "punishment" either from Cameron/Osborne's huge tax rises or the supposed EU allies, not actual firm support of EU policies. A breakdown is available here: https://dominiccummings.files.wordpress.com/2016/11/screenshot-2016-11-27-13-58-441.png?w=498&h=458 https://dominiccummings.files.wordpress.com/2016/11/screensh...
- ur-whale 6y ago> This nastiness is what the public demands. So you're saying democracy is bad?
- callamdelaney 6y agoBrutal? It's not brutal - it's positively tame. Take a look at the Australian system under Abott if you want 'brutal'. This is simply a Sovereign State softly removing those with zero right to remain.
- bogle 6y agoThe Home Office said, "suspected offences". Funny that the "Sovreign State" tried this in Scotland, isn't it?
- callamdelaney 6y agoWhat's the fact that it was in Scotland got to do with it? It's baseless to believe that the home office would target something in Sturgeons constituency on some particular day, especially when there's no political advantage to be drawn by said act. Immigration law applies to Scotland too; until there's a nice border there (but that's another topic).
- bogle 6y agoI see your jingoistic sensibilities are clouding your thinking. Your political nous is also somewhat lacking, perhaps, if you can't see the power play here.
- callamdelaney 6y agoSo instead of making your point, my thinking is too clouded to come to the same unexplained conclusion as you?
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agothis is a bad-faith argument: > It's baseless to believe that the home office would target something in Sturgeons constituency on some particular day, especially when there's no political advantage to be drawn by said act. Judging by #10's behavior as a predictor for future behavior there is every reason to believe it was very much on purpose (and far from "baseless"). And even it wasn't on purpose it would now be on them to apologize and try to straighten things out - which ofc they don't.