4 ms·
Artificially restricting themselves to only corporate and government users would be a terrible move. They would still bear nearly 100% of their current costs,
by dpark 15y ago
Artificially restricting themselves to only corporate and government users would be a terrible move. They would still bear nearly 100% of their current costs, but have access to maybe 10 or 20% of their current market. This is a recipe for disaster. Being "corp and govt only" has no meaningful exclusivity. It's not elite. It's just bureaucratic. No one lusts after overpriced government-contract devices. And certainly very few people want to carry both a corporate and a personal phone. Those who do will probably like the Blackberry less, as it becomes a symbol of inconvenience, and as it's constantly compared to their latest iOS/Android device
History has shown that general-use technology eventually wins over niche technology. How many companies are running Alpha chips these days? SGI workstations? Sparc servers? The niche players lost as the mainstream passed them by. Intel processors ended up crushing the dedicated "corporate" processors, because the mainstream market could support larger R&D efforts and provided a volume that allowed a far superior price/performance ratio. Ditto with nVidia. This is a story that's played out the same way again and again. The niche player loses unless it can deliver (and continue to deliver) significant value beyond what the mainstream players can provide. No one cares if there's an "elite" status to owning a rack of Alpha processors when a rack of Pentium 3 chips can do the same job for a quarter of the price.
Also, Apple and Android are both making significant headway into the corporate environment, as employees tire of carrying two phones or being limited to a Blackberry device. Even in companies where Blackberry is the only "supported" device, they often give employees access to Exchange on their personal devices. If employees use their personal iPhones rather than receive a corp-provided Blackberry, that's a loss for RIM (and arguably a gain for the corporation, as they don't have to pick up the tab for another corp phone).
- forensic 15y agoYou're just being pessimistic. The question is not "What is the future of mobile computing?" The question is "How does RIM make as much money as possible with their resources?" RIM can't compete on merit, so their best strategy is to do what they've always done: use aggressive, obnoxious sales strategies to place BlackBerries as the "enterprise" device and the only "respectable and secure" enterprise device. Many lame executive types are very very concerned with appearing respectable and adult and elite or whatever, and will use inferior products to maintain this image. They are doing it right now with BlackBerries. The standard East Coast enterprise opinion toward iPhones has been that they are "toys" for children and plebs, while BlackBerries are serious work tools for rich and important executives. BlackBerry cannot compete on fundamentals, but it can compete on image, exclusivity, and keep targeting luddites such as people who refuse to use Apple products because they are "pretty". These people love the ugly, hard to use BlackBerry, because the ugliness and crappiness itself is a statement about their values.
- dpark 15y agoIf your only concern is the next few years, that might be a viable option, though abandoning all your consumer products would probably send a clear message that you are sinking, at which point even slow-moving corporations might decide to look elsewhere. I think over the longer term, focussing exclusively on corporations is a losing bet. At some point, the mainstream options will be so obviously superior that it just won't make any sense to continue to invest heavily in Blackberry devices (unless Blackberry can somehow catch up or pass rapidly). If Blackberry is only appealing to the corporate exec crowd, they're going to have to drastically raise prices to stay in business. I don't think many companies will indefinitely pay double for phones with half the features that 80% of their employees don't want. There's just no value there.
- forensic 15y agoI don't think they should abandon the consumer market. They should just focus on the enterprise. There are lots of wannabes in the consumer market who will pay a premium to get "the #1 executive phone in the world" RIM has always been a one trick pony run by hustling salesmen fueled with hot air. My plan is the natural continuation of their strength.
- dpark 15y agoSo they'll just do exactly what they've been doing? That strategy seems to be failing for them right now.
- forensic 15y agoMaking millions of dollars and feeding thousands of families is not failure. Failure would be shutting the doors.
- dpark 15y agoBy this definition Sun was succeeding right up to the point that Oracle bought them. In fact they're still succeeding, because they never shut the doors. I don't think this is a definition of success that RIM's executives, employees, or stockholders are looking for, though.
- run4yourlives 15y agoThey would still bear nearly 100% of their current costs, but have access to maybe 10 or 20% of their current market. What? How do you figure? They'd have a huge drop in operating expenses because they'd be supporting a much narrower field of business lines. History has shown that general-use technology eventually wins over niche technology. Maybe if you only look at the history you choose to. I'd venture that 80% of all successful businesses right now are focusing on a niche. It's easier to do one thing well than it is to do everything half ass, and that will always create opportunity. Not everyone can be the default. Also, Apple and Android are both making significant headway into the corporate environment, Um, no, they aren't. I'd love this to be so, but it isn't. Apple and Android are focusing on the consumer. You need to consider the fact that at a certain level, the needs of consumers and corporations are divergent. It's extremely difficult to focus on two groups with opposing interests and serve both well. This is essentially my argument. You seem to be making a case that employees will not carry two devices, while at the same time forgetting that one doesn't cost them anything.... As a person that would love an iPhone but who has a corporate issued blackberry, the fact that I have a free device is more than enough to comfort my lack of app selection and better UX.
- dpark 15y ago> What? How do you figure? They'd have a huge drop in operating expenses because they'd be supporting a much narrower field of business lines. I'm not sure they'd see a significant drop in operating expenses. Their development expenses in particular wouldn't change, unless they're going to completely give up on actually delivering a competitive product. When your company is built on delivering a device, selling fewer of the devices just means your profit margin goes down. It doesn't actually make the devices cheaper to design, implement, or manufacture. > Maybe if you only look at the history you choose to. I'd venture that 80% of all successful business is focusing on a niche. It's easier to do one thing well than it is to do everything half ass, and that will always create opportunity. That's only true if the niche is one that has demands a mainstream product cannot fill. When a mainstream product meets the needs of the niche, the niche evaporates. For example, you see that corporations have niche systems for land-lines, because there is no mainstream demand for complex call systems. No one needs 1000 lines in their home and so Avaya and Cisco don't try to sell PBX systems to the public. On the other hand, there are no niche desktop systems in corporations. They use the same Dell or HP systems as home users. There's no value in a niche product, so the niche product no longer exists. Smart phones are an example of where the corporate niche is evaporating. There's no requirement for a company to use Blackberry devices. At this point, it's basically just a legacy concern. If an Android phone can do the same job, then what's the value in standardizing on Blackberry, especially if Blackberry becomes a niche -- and therefore more expensive -- option? > Um, no, they aren't. I'd love this to be so, but it isn't. Apple and Android are focusing on the consumer. You need to consider the fact that at a certain level, the needs of consumers and corporations are divergent. It's extremely difficult to focus on two groups with opposing interests and serve both well. This is essentially my argument. Except this isn't true. Corporate needs and personal phone needs are very nearly the same. They both need voice service, email, maybe SMS. Corporations might need VPN, but that's built into the "consumer" phones as well. Please tell me what it is you think corporations need that they can't get from a RIM competitor? And especially please clarify how corporate users and consumers have opposing interests. > You seem to be making a case that employees will not carry two devices, while at the same time forgetting that one doesn't cost them anything.... As a person that would love an iPhone but who has a corporate issued blackberry, the fact that I have a free device is more than enough to comfort my lack of app selection and better UX. So what you're saying is that all of your needs are actually met by your Blackberry? Doesn't that mean that your claims about personal vs corporate needs being different/conflicting are incorrect? But to answer you, no, I didn't forget that. I'm saying that some people choose to pay for an iPhone rather than carry a free Blackberry. This may not be the case for you, but I've seen it at my company. I've also seen people who carry two phones.