9 ms·
> science is a process. If research came out that changed the recommendations, well, that's how science works. CDC is a public health organization, not a scien
by acituan 5y ago
> science is a process. If research came out that changed the recommendations, well, that's how science works.
CDC is a public health organization, not a science making organization. Its responsibility is to make the competent public health decisions based on the best available data and sound risk management. No one is faulting CDC for eventually course correcting, they are criticizing it for not having followed a more risk averse strategy from the get go and not having communicated their rationale honestly.
Imagine if FDA behaved like CDC; roll out the vaccines to general public with minimal trial, updating their decision on safety as more data came in. Scientific incrementalism doesn't suit all use cases, and this has nothing to do with infallibility.
- joshribakoff 5y ago> updating their decision on safety as more data came in. That’s literally what they do. They paused when there were concerns over blood clots, then expanded access to more cohorts as more studies were completed.
- acituan 5y ago"with minimal trial" is the operative word, which didn't happen. The point being there is a balance between waiting for perfect data and making risk based policies.