2 ms·
A lot of early stage Mars terraforming talk always seem to deal in oddly limited human terms - and imposes limits we have on Earth which don't apply anywhere el
by XorNot 6y ago
A lot of early stage Mars terraforming talk always seem to deal in oddly limited human terms - and imposes limits we have on Earth which don't apply anywhere else in the solar system.
What does Mars need? An atmosphere. Doesn't really matter what it's made of, we need more pressure on the surface. But no one lives on Mars! It's not "oh how much work would this be" it's "redirect a comet and let it crash into the planet".
Most of the big early stage terraforming problems offer disproportionate returns on investment - you can do extinction-level event damage with no consequences and amazingly reasonable delta-V investments.
Personally, I've been hoping we'll get lucky and a suitably large comet would just hit Mars. A couple years back a retrograde comet looked like it would, but missed. It wouldn't have taken much effort at the right part of it's orbit to guarantee that hit.
This is what does make me wonder about the "oh it's too hard" people. We know there are bodies in the asteroid belt with more water then all of Earth's oceans. The gases and liquids we need are already in orbit and once we know where they are, getting them to Mars is comparatively very simple.
What does the terraforming argument look like once you change some of those initial assumptions people start with? Once CO2 in the atmosphere is warming it up, and surface pressure is 0.3 atmospheres? And once liquid water has filled all the low land areas?
These aren't insurmountable hurdles for us with todays technology - but they are catastrophic sort of changes which you can only do in the early phase. But once we're looking at a planet which is still "uninhabitable" but with sunlight, water and CO2...well that's an environment where Earth's greenery is going to go crazy colonizing.
- schoen 6y ago> We know there are bodies in the asteroid belt with more water then all of Earth's oceans. Can you say more about the technology to redirect that much mass to make it collide with Mars? (I understand that shifting an orbit is much different from escaping from a gravity well, but I don't have a good intuition for how different, maybe because I haven't played Kerbal Space Program or something.)
- XorNot 6y agoIt's all essentially asteroid redirect stuff, so the trick is finding something with what we want, on a close enough orbit, with some reasonable timeframes (i.e. it'd be preferable to do an impact with a 20 year arrival time so the people planning it can live to see it). So either gravity-tug with ion thrusters do a minor correction, or more likely a solar reflector to turn part of the bodies mass into it's own propellant. Or a nuclear charge on the right side of it. I suspect if we were committed to this as a thing we were doing, then once you turned more resources to it the actual calculus would get more complicated: you'd want to map out and characterize everything in orbit, and then start looking for second or even third order redirect candidates - i.e. use a smaller body on a more useful orbit to collide into a larger one for a redirect. The technological criteria are much more reasonable for all of this though: we need to be able to get to what we're going to redirect reasonably quickly, several times so we can characterize and put the gear in place to do the mission. At this point you'd hopefully be using a bunch of Starships running on autopilot. If you take some near-future tech into account, then if end up building the laser array for the Breakthrough Starshot project, a decent use of that most of the time would be lasing the surface of redirect candidates from Earth. EDIT: Just realized I didn't answer your question very well - changing an orbit is much cheaper then escaping a gravity well. To go to the Moon from Low Earth Orbit takes maybe 1000ms-1 of delta-V (weak-boundary transfer and such - I'm probably a little off on that) under the right conditions. To get into Low Earth Orbit through you need to blow through at 8km/s of Delta-V and then a lot more to overcome atmospheric drag. But to return form a Near-Earth Object (say an asteroid) back into the Earth's atmosphere can be done with as little as 60 ms-1 of delta-V in some cases (a little more if you're aiming to hit the ground and not just plough through the atmosphere). Basically with the right timing, orbital adjustments can be incredibly cheap. EDIT 2: Basically it's quite likely there's more then a few comets out there which are going to make close passes to Mars already, where for the cost of an impactor, we could ensure they hit Mars instead if we found them early enough.
- elihu 6y agoWhat would be the intended result of crashing comets into Mars? Do comets have enough mass that the addition of that much dry ice, regular ice, and assorted rubble would make a noticeable change in the climate, or is the goal to use the re-entry heat to warm things up? And would a large impact cause a dust cloud that would take years/decades to settle? (Which could be an acceptable side effect if the benefits are worth it, or if the dust itself creates a warming effect.)
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoWait. There's an asteroid with more water than Earth? How?!? Aren't there only a handful of asteroids over a 100,000 cubic kilometers? Even if they were entirely ice - aren't there 1,350,000 cubic kilometers of water in the oceans? Even if the largest asteroid was completely ice - it still couldn't have as much water as the ocean, right??
- XorNot 6y agoCeres is believed to have more water in it then Earth's oceans. Ceres is huge, of course, and we probably can't redirect it. But deorbiting more amenable bodies into Mars from the numerous comets that impinge on our solar system is achievable. And of course if there's water somewhere, then there's water almost everywhere (which there is - if nothing else there's a huge amount of it in Saturn's rings). The point is, what you can do terraforming Mars, is quite different to anything you could do to Earth, because you can't just freely cause some cataclysmic events here. EDIT: The other key point is all this work is largely fire-and-forget once you know how. An automated solar reflector probe can be launched and happily continue causing some body to outgas for years, with no human intervention at all.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoDoesn't Ceres have a diameter of less than 1000km? Even if it's entirely ice - pi*500km^2 = ~785,000 cubic kilometers of water, right? Isn't that half of what's in the oceans? What am I doing wrong??